I think it's about time we consider a "NEW" CLOSER. Issy has been my main man in 2-two or less Innings. He's in my opinion have loss some steam, selection of pitches have also become suspect. A very hitable guy right now, I know he's a slow starter but he make closing out very difficult. I view every game, let's continue to support and cheer Issy on but also keep close tabs on his prodution. "PEACE BE UNTO YOU"
He didn't pitch well last night, but let's face it. Were it not for a play that Rolen makes 999 times out of 1000, he's got another save (albeit a lucky one).
That doesn't negate your point - it's a valid debate - but right now I'm with Michael - not ready to give up on Izzy yet.