2024 Concerns

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
User avatar
pioneer98
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22007
Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
Location: High A Minors

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by pioneer98 »

a_smith wrote: ↑
October 14 23, 11:32 am
pioneer98 wrote: ↑
October 14 23, 1:19 am
In addition to all the pitching concerns another gap between the Cardinals and the top teams is DH. The top teams all have a dude that can absolutely mash at the DH spot.
Dodgers - JD Martinez
Astros - Yordan Alvarez
Yankees - Stanton
Braves - Ozuna
Etc
The top teams aren't relying on sliding a position player (like Gorman or Contreras) into that DH spot. They also don't rely on some guy they called up from triple A (like Baker or Yepez). The top teams get a guy who rakes and just locks down that DH spot. If you have a DH like that, then doing something like playing Winn at SS for 500 PA's and rolling the dice on his upside seems less risky.

This is just a long way of saying: Adding a DH that can mash raises the team's floor. I know they'll never do it but they should.
Ozuna, Alvarez and Martinez would all be in the field if they could play defense.

I agree with Popeye. For a team like the Cardinals with two superstars who are ageing (Arenado and Goldy) using the DH as a way to keep their bats in the lineup and get them rest from playing in the field is a great use of the DH. Also, Contreras and Gorman are good bats that they can use in the DH.

While I disagree about the Dh, your point that they need to raise the floor is a good one. They spent a lot of time early in the year playing Walker, Burlson, Motter, and scrubby guys who were dragging down the team. Get players who are good and play them. Improve the outfield.
Improve the pitching. Improve the defense. Fix the roster so it works as a cohesive whole
I'm not sure we can rely on Goldy and Arenado to be superstars much longer. Adding another big bat is insurance if those two decline (or fail to rebound or whatever we are saying happened this year). It's totally OK if we end up with 3 superstar players!

Online
User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31085
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by Popeye_Card »

The real point is that Goldy and Arenado are going to continue playing 95% of the time at their respective positions, where Walker and Gorman should more realistically be playing given their defensive liabilities at more difficult positions.

Instead of paying for a full-time DH, I’d be more inclined to sign a full-time corner OF, and just make Walker the de facto DH.

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by dmarx114 »

pioneer98 wrote: ↑
October 16 23, 7:20 pm
a_smith wrote: ↑
October 14 23, 11:32 am
pioneer98 wrote: ↑
October 14 23, 1:19 am
In addition to all the pitching concerns another gap between the Cardinals and the top teams is DH. The top teams all have a dude that can absolutely mash at the DH spot.
Dodgers - JD Martinez
Astros - Yordan Alvarez
Yankees - Stanton
Braves - Ozuna
Etc
The top teams aren't relying on sliding a position player (like Gorman or Contreras) into that DH spot. They also don't rely on some guy they called up from triple A (like Baker or Yepez). The top teams get a guy who rakes and just locks down that DH spot. If you have a DH like that, then doing something like playing Winn at SS for 500 PA's and rolling the dice on his upside seems less risky.

This is just a long way of saying: Adding a DH that can mash raises the team's floor. I know they'll never do it but they should.
Ozuna, Alvarez and Martinez would all be in the field if they could play defense.

I agree with Popeye. For a team like the Cardinals with two superstars who are ageing (Arenado and Goldy) using the DH as a way to keep their bats in the lineup and get them rest from playing in the field is a great use of the DH. Also, Contreras and Gorman are good bats that they can use in the DH.

While I disagree about the Dh, your point that they need to raise the floor is a good one. They spent a lot of time early in the year playing Walker, Burlson, Motter, and scrubby guys who were dragging down the team. Get players who are good and play them. Improve the outfield.
Improve the pitching. Improve the defense. Fix the roster so it works as a cohesive whole
I'm not sure we can rely on Goldy and Arenado to be superstars much longer. Adding another big bat is insurance if those two decline (or fail to rebound or whatever we are saying happened this year). It's totally OK if we end up with 3 superstar players!
They weren't superstars last year. Hopefully they can put up 5 WAR seasons this year, but I wouldn't bet on it.

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by dmarx114 »

dmarx114 wrote: ↑
October 12 23, 1:14 pm
I am not saying our season is over, but I have concerns about our yet to be formed 2024 team. In 2023, we went 71-91. Maybe if things broke right early on, we don't sell Monty, and we don't waste starts on Waino. How many wins does that team have? Maybe 77 or so?

Lets say we use our available free agent dollars on Nola and Gray. Obviously, this improves the rotation quite a bit from last year. But another pitcher still needs to acquired. And we might need to trade someone like Gorman to acquire that difference making pitcher.

At what point do we discuss Goldy and Nado regressing mightily in 2023? A repeat of 2022 was not expected, but their combined WAR dropped from like 15 to 5. What are they capable of at this point in their careers?

Walker provided a nice rookie season at the plate, and he should continue to improve there, but his defense is a major issue. There were times towards the end of the season when he made some highlight level plays, but there were still easy miscues in September. We can't rely on him to provide overall value in the outfield.

Winn is obviously going to be a work in progress at the plate. If we are trying to win the division, can we rely on him batting 550 times? Feels like there will be a hole in the lineup if we do.

O'Neill and Carlson are wild cards. Maybe they will stay healthy, but we really can't count on either to have the production we need them to have.

Contreras' defense is a constant concern. No getting around that.

Can we be confident in Matz and Mikolas? Not at all. Just hoping Matz stays healthy and repeats his second half, and Mikolas gets better BABIP luck.

And don't we need to basically revamp the bullpen? I guess Helsley sticks as the closer, but health is a major concern for him. JoJo did well, and hopefully he repeats his 2023 season, but I wouldn't exactly bank on it. Gio will still be on the team, but I really don't trust him. We need like 5 new arms there.

If I am being honest with myself, I don't think it's likely the Cardinals are 10-15 games better next year compared to 2023. The best thing for the organization is probably to rebuild by trading Goldy and Nado, and saving free agent dollars for when they are ready to compete again, which might be a couple years away.

But Mo's job relies on the Cardinals rebounding next year, so the short term is more important than the long term. I just hope we aren't throwing good money after bad.
Most of these concerns remain. I think the bullpen was re-shaped reasonably well. But the starting pitching isn't good enough.

76-86, 4th place, with a house cleaning coming in October.

User avatar
Joe Shlabotnik
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 24291
Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
Contact:

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by Joe Shlabotnik »

And if any of the starters go down from this point, the bullpen will be a shambles, pretty quickly.

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by dmarx114 »

Time for a bump.

I couldn't find the pre-season thread where we were nervous about the offense being silent all Spring. We all knew there were signs the bats wouldn't magically heat up once the season started.

This is really not good.

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by dmarx114 »

dmarx114 wrote: ↑
October 12 23, 1:14 pm
I am not saying our season is over, but I have concerns about our yet to be formed 2024 team. In 2023, we went 71-91. Maybe if things broke right early on, we don't sell Monty, and we don't waste starts on Waino. How many wins does that team have? Maybe 77 or so?

Lets say we use our available free agent dollars on Nola and Gray. Obviously, this improves the rotation quite a bit from last year. But another pitcher still needs to acquired. And we might need to trade someone like Gorman to acquire that difference making pitcher.

At what point do we discuss Goldy and Nado regressing mightily in 2023? A repeat of 2022 was not expected, but their combined WAR dropped from like 15 to 5. What are they capable of at this point in their careers?

Walker provided a nice rookie season at the plate, and he should continue to improve there, but his defense is a major issue. There were times towards the end of the season when he made some highlight level plays, but there were still easy miscues in September. We can't rely on him to provide overall value in the outfield.

Winn is obviously going to be a work in progress at the plate. If we are trying to win the division, can we rely on him batting 550 times? Feels like there will be a hole in the lineup if we do.

O'Neill and Carlson are wild cards. Maybe they will stay healthy, but we really can't count on either to have the production we need them to have.

Contreras' defense is a constant concern. No getting around that.

Can we be confident in Matz and Mikolas? Not at all. Just hoping Matz stays healthy and repeats his second half, and Mikolas gets better BABIP luck.

And don't we need to basically revamp the bullpen? I guess Helsley sticks as the closer, but health is a major concern for him. JoJo did well, and hopefully he repeats his 2023 season, but I wouldn't exactly bank on it. Gio will still be on the team, but I really don't trust him. We need like 5 new arms there.

If I am being honest with myself, I don't think it's likely the Cardinals are 10-15 games better next year compared to 2023. The best thing for the organization is probably to rebuild by trading Goldy and Nado, and saving free agent dollars for when they are ready to compete again, which might be a couple years away.

But Mo's job relies on the Cardinals rebounding next year, so the short term is more important than the long term. I just hope we aren't throwing good money after bad.
Wasted a year to see what was obvious 12 months ago.

Let the rebuild begin.

User avatar
CardsofSTL
All Hail the GDT Master
Posts: 70085
Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
Location: Columbus, OH

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by CardsofSTL »

Twelve games better though. Yaaay

Magneto2.0
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 18100
Joined: June 16 07, 2:12 pm

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by Magneto2.0 »

CardsofSTL wrote: ↑
September 30 24, 12:08 am
Twelve games better though. Yaaay
That means we win 95 next year.

Mo is a genius.

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by dmarx114 »

dmarx114 wrote: ↑
October 12 23, 1:14 pm
I am not saying our season is over, but I have concerns about our yet to be formed 2024 team. In 2023, we went 71-91. Maybe if things broke right early on, we don't sell Monty, and we don't waste starts on Waino. How many wins does that team have? Maybe 77 or so?

Lets say we use our available free agent dollars on Nola and Gray. Obviously, this improves the rotation quite a bit from last year. But another pitcher still needs to acquired. And we might need to trade someone like Gorman to acquire that difference making pitcher.

At what point do we discuss Goldy and Nado regressing mightily in 2023? A repeat of 2022 was not expected, but their combined WAR dropped from like 15 to 5. What are they capable of at this point in their careers?

Walker provided a nice rookie season at the plate, and he should continue to improve there, but his defense is a major issue. There were times towards the end of the season when he made some highlight level plays, but there were still easy miscues in September. We can't rely on him to provide overall value in the outfield.

Winn is obviously going to be a work in progress at the plate. If we are trying to win the division, can we rely on him batting 550 times? Feels like there will be a hole in the lineup if we do.

O'Neill and Carlson are wild cards. Maybe they will stay healthy, but we really can't count on either to have the production we need them to have.

Contreras' defense is a constant concern. No getting around that.

Can we be confident in Matz and Mikolas? Not at all. Just hoping Matz stays healthy and repeats his second half, and Mikolas gets better BABIP luck.

And don't we need to basically revamp the bullpen? I guess Helsley sticks as the closer, but health is a major concern for him. JoJo did well, and hopefully he repeats his 2023 season, but I wouldn't exactly bank on it. Gio will still be on the team, but I really don't trust him. We need like 5 new arms there.

If I am being honest with myself, I don't think it's likely the Cardinals are 10-15 games better next year compared to 2023. The best thing for the organization is probably to rebuild by trading Goldy and Nado, and saving free agent dollars for when they are ready to compete again, which might be a couple years away.

But Mo's job relies on the Cardinals rebounding next year, so the short term is more important than the long term. I just hope we aren't throwing good money after bad.
26 months later, and now we are finally ready to rebuild. Really bad 2 years for Dewitt and Mo. Complete waste.

Post Reply