2024 Concerns

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

2024 Concerns

Post by dmarx114 »

I am not saying our season is over, but I have concerns about our yet to be formed 2024 team. In 2023, we went 71-91. Maybe if things broke right early on, we don't sell Monty, and we don't waste starts on Waino. How many wins does that team have? Maybe 77 or so?

Lets say we use our available free agent dollars on Nola and Gray. Obviously, this improves the rotation quite a bit from last year. But another pitcher still needs to acquired. And we might need to trade someone like Gorman to acquire that difference making pitcher.

At what point do we discuss Goldy and Nado regressing mightily in 2023? A repeat of 2022 was not expected, but their combined WAR dropped from like 15 to 5. What are they capable of at this point in their careers?

Walker provided a nice rookie season at the plate, and he should continue to improve there, but his defense is a major issue. There were times towards the end of the season when he made some highlight level plays, but there were still easy miscues in September. We can't rely on him to provide overall value in the outfield.

Winn is obviously going to be a work in progress at the plate. If we are trying to win the division, can we rely on him batting 550 times? Feels like there will be a hole in the lineup if we do.

O'Neill and Carlson are wild cards. Maybe they will stay healthy, but we really can't count on either to have the production we need them to have.

Contreras' defense is a constant concern. No getting around that.

Can we be confident in Matz and Mikolas? Not at all. Just hoping Matz stays healthy and repeats his second half, and Mikolas gets better BABIP luck.

And don't we need to basically revamp the bullpen? I guess Helsley sticks as the closer, but health is a major concern for him. JoJo did well, and hopefully he repeats his 2023 season, but I wouldn't exactly bank on it. Gio will still be on the team, but I really don't trust him. We need like 5 new arms there.

If I am being honest with myself, I don't think it's likely the Cardinals are 10-15 games better next year compared to 2023. The best thing for the organization is probably to rebuild by trading Goldy and Nado, and saving free agent dollars for when they are ready to compete again, which might be a couple years away.

But Mo's job relies on the Cardinals rebounding next year, so the short term is more important than the long term. I just hope we aren't throwing good money after bad.

User avatar
TheoSqua
Next Gen Wart
Posts: 8951
Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
Location: St. Louis
Contact:

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by TheoSqua »

Is your other username StLouisSportsFan?

Joking aside, I think next season for the Cardinals is going to feel a lot like the upcoming season for the Blues. It will take a lot of changes and a bit of luck to see enough improvement to make the playoffs.

The team still has a decent core though, and I think it's worth seeing what Mo and team can do in the offseason. If they fail next season then I think a larger rebuild is merited, but with the winning tradition this team has, some of the core pieces and prospects, an attempt to "retool on the fly" is worth at least trying imo.

It's been an incredible run of competitiveness, but no team can stay successful forever. I'm looking forward to seeing what the team tries this offseason, it should be interesting. If it works, awesome. If it doesn't, well we've been pretty spoiled and it's about time for a rebuild anyway.

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43331
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by heyzeus »

We finished dead last, so yeah, there are concerns. Bigguns. No one can argue with it.

But it's also not even the LCS yet. There's plenty of time for rending of garments and gnashing of teeth come spring. In the meantime, I want to see the moves we make.

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by dmarx114 »

TheoSqua wrote: ↑
October 12 23, 1:58 pm
Is your other username StLouisSportsFan?

Joking aside, I think next season for the Cardinals is going to feel a lot like the upcoming season for the Blues. It will take a lot of changes and a bit of luck to see enough improvement to make the playoffs.

The team still has a decent core though, and I think it's worth seeing what Mo and team can do in the offseason. If they fail next season then I think a larger rebuild is merited, but with the winning tradition this team has, some of the core pieces and prospects, an attempt to "retool on the fly" is worth at least trying imo.

It's been an incredible run of competitiveness, but no team can stay successful forever. I'm looking forward to seeing what the team tries this offseason, it should be interesting. If it works, awesome. If it doesn't, well we've been pretty spoiled and it's about time for a rebuild anyway.
Haha, I chose my wording carefully in the first sentence for this exact reason.

Online
User avatar
GeddyWrox
Caught you a delicious bass
Posts: 14717
Joined: April 20 06, 8:43 pm
Location: Please use blue font for the sarcasm impaired.

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by GeddyWrox »

I actually think the Blues are closer to returning to the playoffs than the Cardinals.

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by haltz »

Maybe I'm in the minority here but I think if you played 2023 over again you'd get 10-15 more wins already. I'm certainly not saying it was a great team, just an OK team where almost everything went wrong or players underperformed. Opposite of the Braves where every player played over their head pretty much without exception and were obviously cheating somehow.

As far as waiting goes, that's what they did last year when there were clear pitching issues at the very least going into this season and now it's a mess. Gotta get ahead of it.

User avatar
Radbird
There's someone in my head but it's not me
Posts: 62390
Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by Radbird »

I’m pretty much where you are regarding ‘23, haltz.

Going forward, if the right moves are made in an expeditious manner to revamp the pitching staff along with a full season of Winn, an improved sophomore campaign from Walker and perhaps lightening in a bottle from someone like Saggesse or Scott III and we’ll be back in the hunt.

But for now, I’m gonna sit back, relax and enjoy the rest of the playoffs.

User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

They might still have a hard time closing the talent gap with the best teams, but I think a playoff appearance and pray for the best is feasible for next year. Signing a real number one starter would make me feel better though (and yes, I would prefer a signing because they’re eventually going to have to sign someone who wasn’t already a Cardinal to nine figures.)

User avatar
TGantz
R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
Posts: 6698
Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
Location: The Lou

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by TGantz »

I hate to say it because he's frustrating but I'm going to be kind of annoyed if we trade TON for nothing. He is a game changer when he's on. He might be taking on the DeJong role of never having enough value to trade but too talented to just cut until his contract runs out. There are worse 4th OF options. I think Carlson is a big key next year. Age wise he's due for a break out year. Since Walker will be roaming the OF with Nootbar and probably Edman, TON and Carlson at least have potential and are solid defenders to balance out Walker. Burleson had his moments and could be a decent slugger off the bench. Not the best OF but probably not worth improving in terms of FA $$$.

Arenado, Goldy, Gorman, Contreras, and Winn have infield pretty locked in. The question would be at back up catcher. Are we going in with three ML level catchers? Kniz seems to have the pitchers respect, solid defensively, and may have figured out how to bat. But we need to do something with Herrera. Or is it that weird to have 3 C's these days, especially with a player like Contreras?

SP has been covered plenty. We are all hoping for Nola, Montgomery, and someone from Japan with Mikolas and Matz. I'm mentally preparing myself for Gray and Severino with Thompson. Too many variables to talk about.

Bullpen is Helsey, Jojo, and pray for rain at this point. We'll sign a Stratton type veteran, and fill the rest with AAA SP probably.

I feel like 2023 could have been closer to 80 wins without a few key injuries, the Wainwright show, and without selling Monty and Jack. I'd guess we're gonna see 81ish wins next year. Probably in for an even worse 2025.

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43331
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: 2024 Concerns

Post by heyzeus »

TGantz wrote: ↑
October 12 23, 7:07 pm
I hate to say it because he's frustrating but I'm going to be kind of annoyed if we trade TON for nothing. He is a game changer when he's on. He might be taking on the DeJong role of never having enough value to trade but too talented to just cut until his contract runs out. There are worse 4th OF options. I think Carlson is a big key next year. Age wise he's due for a break out year. Since Walker will be roaming the OF with Nootbar and probably Edman, TON and Carlson at least have potential and are solid defenders to balance out Walker. Burleson had his moments and could be a decent slugger off the bench. Not the best OF but probably not worth improving in terms of FA $$$.

Arenado, Goldy, Gorman, Contreras, and Winn have infield pretty locked in. The question would be at back up catcher. Are we going in with three ML level catchers? Kniz seems to have the pitchers respect, solid defensively, and may have figured out how to bat. But we need to do something with Herrera. Or is it that weird to have 3 C's these days, especially with a player like Contreras?

SP has been covered plenty. We are all hoping for Nola, Montgomery, and someone from Japan with Mikolas and Matz. I'm mentally preparing myself for Gray and Severino with Thompson. Too many variables to talk about.

Bullpen is Helsey, Jojo, and pray for rain at this point. We'll sign a Stratton type veteran, and fill the rest with AAA SP probably.

I feel like 2023 could have been closer to 80 wins without a few key injuries, the Wainwright show, and without selling Monty and Jack. I'd guess we're gonna see 81ish wins next year. Probably in for an even worse 2025.
I think there's a world where we keep Kniz, and trade Herrera plus someone (a Graceffo type?) to TB for Glasnow. And I'd do it.

Post Reply