2015 NFL Thread

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by jim »

JL21 wrote:For what it's worth, I don't care at all that they did it. I actually think it was funny. But I also think it was a dick move.

I don't know the exact line where you stop going for 2, but it was going to take 4 scores (including 3 TDs with successful two-point conversions and at least one if not several successful onside kicks- all VERY unlikely events) in 5 minutes for Arizona to take the lead, whether the Panthers went for 1 or went for 2. And the Cardinals had been hilariously pathetic throughout the game against Carolina's defense. That's a lot that has to go juuuuust right.

Advanced Football Analytics has a win probability calculator. Using that same scenario (5 minutes to play, entering the game as a 3 point favorite, and giving Arizona's next possession at their own 30 yard line), the Panthers have 99% or better odds of winning with a lead of anything more than 14 points. If it's "only" a 14 point lead, they still have a 98% chance of winning. At 13, it goes down to "only" 96%. You have to shave the lead all the way down to 9 points before the win probably dips under 90% (and even then, it's still 89%).

I guess in conclusion, 15 points or more with 5 minutes to go, you can just kick the extra point.
I agree all of this was VERY very unlikely. It would have taken a miracle. I can't find that calculator you referenced. Let me just ask a question - would you say the game is completely over - 100% sure fired over - if the Cardinals had the ball down 19 on the Panthers 35 yard line with 5:00 left to play?

If your answer is yes, then we will agree to disagree. Because they would be one play way from having it an 12 point game with 4:45 or so to play. Still a big comeback, that's doable.

If your answer is no, that the Cardinals would have an unlikely but non zero probability of winning, then I would say the following:

1) NFL teams run kicks back for TD's on occasion, we would agree this is a possibility. So it's possible that Arizona could return the kick and cut the lead to 19.

2) NFL teams recover onside kicks on occasion. If 1) happened, and 2) happened, you just arrived at a situation where the Cardinals have the ball on the Panthers 40 or so. One play away from an 11 point game.

Again - miracle. I get it. The odds of one of those happening is remote, both in sequence really remote. But I don't see why you would take that chance is you are the Panthers. Just keep playing the game, do everything you can to increase your odds of winning.

2:00, up 25, other team out of times, ball on their 10, 1:30 left - not taking a knee would be a dick move, classless, and not in the spirit of the game. That I would have a problem with, not going for 2 when there was still 5 minutes left in the game.

That's my take on it.
Last edited by jim on January 26 16, 12:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by Socnorb11 »

jim wrote:For all of the critics of the 2 pointer - serious question. I understand that the argument against going for 2 is that it was unsportsmanlike, because with a 25 point lead the game was over. Broncos pointed out that this type of lead has never yet been overcome as his basis. But when do you know for sure, 100% guarantee, that the game is over? Where is that line? I'm trying to understand where the line is, and why on earth anyone would criticize a team with so much on the line for playing it extra safe, and taking nothing for granted. And adding 1 point exactly running the score up in my book.

So where is this line? 5:00 left and down 17 and the trailing team has the ball? Game over? 2:00 left with the trailing team with the ball and down 14? Game over?

Where is the line? Is it simply a place that has never been crossed, with the assumption that it has never been crossed because it's impossible. Is it good to make that assumption?





I just don't know

Every other coach in the NFL and NCAA makes that assumption. Maybe they're all naive.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by jim »

Socnorb11 wrote:
jim wrote:For all of the critics of the 2 pointer - serious question. I understand that the argument against going for 2 is that it was unsportsmanlike, because with a 25 point lead the game was over. Broncos pointed out that this type of lead has never yet been overcome as his basis. But when do you know for sure, 100% guarantee, that the game is over? Where is that line? I'm trying to understand where the line is, and why on earth anyone would criticize a team with so much on the line for playing it extra safe, and taking nothing for granted. And adding 1 point exactly running the score up in my book.

So where is this line? 5:00 left and down 17 and the trailing team has the ball? Game over? 2:00 left with the trailing team with the ball and down 14? Game over?

Where is the line? Is it simply a place that has never been crossed, with the assumption that it has never been crossed because it's impossible. Is it good to make that assumption?





I just don't know

Every other coach in the NFL and NCAA makes that assumption. Maybe they're all naive.
No they don't. You are just saying that.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by Socnorb11 »

jim wrote:
JL21 wrote:For what it's worth, I don't care at all that they did it. I actually think it was funny. But I also think it was a dick move.

I don't know the exact line where you stop going for 2, but it was going to take 4 scores (including 3 TDs with successful two-point conversions and at least one if not several successful onside kicks- all VERY unlikely events) in 5 minutes for Arizona to take the lead, whether the Panthers went for 1 or went for 2. And the Cardinals had been hilariously pathetic throughout the game against Carolina's defense. That's a lot that has to go juuuuust right.

Advanced Football Analytics has a win probability calculator. Using that same scenario (5 minutes to play, entering the game as a 3 point favorite, and giving Arizona's next possession at their own 30 yard line), the Panthers have 99% or better odds of winning with a lead of anything more than 14 points. If it's "only" a 14 point lead, they still have a 98% chance of winning. At 13, it goes down to "only" 96%. You have to shave the lead all the way down to 9 points before the win probably dips under 90% (and even then, it's still 89%).

I guess in conclusion, 15 points or more with 5 minutes to go, you can just kick the extra point.
I agree all of this was VERY very unlikely. It would have taken a miracle. I can't find that calculator you referenced. Let me just ask a question - would you say the game is completely over - 100% sure fired over - if the Cardinals had the ball down 19 on the Panthers 35 yard line with 5:00 left to play?

If your answer is yes, then we will agree to disagree. Because they would be one play way from having it an 12 point game with 4:45 or so to play. Still a big comeback, that's doable.

If your answer is no, that the Cardinals would have an unlikely but non zero probability of winning, then I would say the following:

1) NFL teams run kicks back for TD's on occasion, we would agree this is a possibility. So it's possible that Arizona could return the kick and cut the lead to 19.

2) NFL teams recover onside kicks on occasion. If 1) happened, and 2) happened, you just arrived at a situation where the Cardinals have the ball on the Panthers 40 or so. One play away from an 11 point game.

Again - miracle. I get it. The odds of one of those happening is remote, both in sequence really remote. But I don't see why you would take that chance is you are the Panthers. Just keep playing the game, do everything you can to increase your odds of winning.

2:00, up 25, other team out of times, ball on their 10, 1:30 left - not taking a knee would be a dick move, classless, and not in the spirit of the game. That I would have a problem with, not going for 2 when there was still 5 minutes left in the game.

That's my take on it.

The chance of Cam Newton tearing an ACL while trying to convert a 2-point conversion is far more likely than Arizona wining the game, in my opinion.

Not only is it a punk move, but it's stupid from that standpoint as well.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by Socnorb11 »

jim wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:
jim wrote:For all of the critics of the 2 pointer - serious question. I understand that the argument against going for 2 is that it was unsportsmanlike, because with a 25 point lead the game was over. Broncos pointed out that this type of lead has never yet been overcome as his basis. But when do you know for sure, 100% guarantee, that the game is over? Where is that line? I'm trying to understand where the line is, and why on earth anyone would criticize a team with so much on the line for playing it extra safe, and taking nothing for granted. And adding 1 point exactly running the score up in my book.

So where is this line? 5:00 left and down 17 and the trailing team has the ball? Game over? 2:00 left with the trailing team with the ball and down 14? Game over?

Where is the line? Is it simply a place that has never been crossed, with the assumption that it has never been crossed because it's impossible. Is it good to make that assumption?





I just don't know

Every other coach in the NFL and NCAA makes that assumption. Maybe they're all naive.
No they don't. You are just saying that.
Well, you're right. There was a Wisconsin coach that did it, too. So there's 2, out of several thousand professional football coaches............ and you & Wart.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by jim »

Socnorb11 wrote:
jim wrote:
JL21 wrote:For what it's worth, I don't care at all that they did it. I actually think it was funny. But I also think it was a dick move.

I don't know the exact line where you stop going for 2, but it was going to take 4 scores (including 3 TDs with successful two-point conversions and at least one if not several successful onside kicks- all VERY unlikely events) in 5 minutes for Arizona to take the lead, whether the Panthers went for 1 or went for 2. And the Cardinals had been hilariously pathetic throughout the game against Carolina's defense. That's a lot that has to go juuuuust right.

Advanced Football Analytics has a win probability calculator. Using that same scenario (5 minutes to play, entering the game as a 3 point favorite, and giving Arizona's next possession at their own 30 yard line), the Panthers have 99% or better odds of winning with a lead of anything more than 14 points. If it's "only" a 14 point lead, they still have a 98% chance of winning. At 13, it goes down to "only" 96%. You have to shave the lead all the way down to 9 points before the win probably dips under 90% (and even then, it's still 89%).

I guess in conclusion, 15 points or more with 5 minutes to go, you can just kick the extra point.
I agree all of this was VERY very unlikely. It would have taken a miracle. I can't find that calculator you referenced. Let me just ask a question - would you say the game is completely over - 100% sure fired over - if the Cardinals had the ball down 19 on the Panthers 35 yard line with 5:00 left to play?

If your answer is yes, then we will agree to disagree. Because they would be one play way from having it an 12 point game with 4:45 or so to play. Still a big comeback, that's doable.

If your answer is no, that the Cardinals would have an unlikely but non zero probability of winning, then I would say the following:

1) NFL teams run kicks back for TD's on occasion, we would agree this is a possibility. So it's possible that Arizona could return the kick and cut the lead to 19.

2) NFL teams recover onside kicks on occasion. If 1) happened, and 2) happened, you just arrived at a situation where the Cardinals have the ball on the Panthers 40 or so. One play away from an 11 point game.

Again - miracle. I get it. The odds of one of those happening is remote, both in sequence really remote. But I don't see why you would take that chance is you are the Panthers. Just keep playing the game, do everything you can to increase your odds of winning.

2:00, up 25, other team out of times, ball on their 10, 1:30 left - not taking a knee would be a dick move, classless, and not in the spirit of the game. That I would have a problem with, not going for 2 when there was still 5 minutes left in the game.

That's my take on it.

The chance of Cam Newton tearing an ACL while trying to convert a 2-point conversion is far more likely than Arizona wining the game, in my opinion.

Not only is it a punk move, but it's stupid from that standpoint as well.
Ok we disagree. All I know is I hope the Panthers score with 10 seconds left to make the score 42-8, then decide to go for two and get it and end the game at 44-8. That would be awesome.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by Socnorb11 »

jim wrote:

Ok we disagree. All I know is I hope the Panthers score with 10 seconds left to make the score 42-8, then decide to go for two and get it and end the game at 44-8. That would be awesome.

Of course you do. Because being right on an internet message board is what life is all about, even if thousands of professional coaches disagree with you.

User avatar
go birds
-go birds
Posts: 32057
Joined: February 5 10, 9:54 am

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by go birds »

havent really read the argument too much, but isnt going for 2 when youre up like that pretty standard, as in, the chances of you coming up with a stop are greater than our chances of converting?

like when teams go for it on 4th down instead of kicking the field goal?

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by jim »

Where are these thousands at?

I also hope going for two pisses off Peyton Manning so much that he throws a tizzy fit and trips and falls and tears his ACL.

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by wart57 »

It is 1 extra point, not really running it up if it is 1 extra point. Hardly a dick move for 1 extra point. If they went for a T.D. on 4th and goal from the 1 up by 19 with 5 minutes left, that is a dick move.

What happens if the Panthers go for the extra point kick, the kick is blocked and AZ returns it for the 2 points. Now it is a 23 point lead - 3 td's with 2 - 2 point conversions and 1 extra point kick ties it, 3 td's with 3 - 2 point conversions win it for AZ.

Still far fetched, but the odds were better for victory if the Panthers go for 2.

All this "dick move" stuff is heavy on assumptions, sometimes, things are just down to the numbers.

Post Reply