I agree all of this was VERY very unlikely. It would have taken a miracle. I can't find that calculator you referenced. Let me just ask a question - would you say the game is completely over - 100% sure fired over - if the Cardinals had the ball down 19 on the Panthers 35 yard line with 5:00 left to play?JL21 wrote:For what it's worth, I don't care at all that they did it. I actually think it was funny. But I also think it was a dick move.
I don't know the exact line where you stop going for 2, but it was going to take 4 scores (including 3 TDs with successful two-point conversions and at least one if not several successful onside kicks- all VERY unlikely events) in 5 minutes for Arizona to take the lead, whether the Panthers went for 1 or went for 2. And the Cardinals had been hilariously pathetic throughout the game against Carolina's defense. That's a lot that has to go juuuuust right.
Advanced Football Analytics has a win probability calculator. Using that same scenario (5 minutes to play, entering the game as a 3 point favorite, and giving Arizona's next possession at their own 30 yard line), the Panthers have 99% or better odds of winning with a lead of anything more than 14 points. If it's "only" a 14 point lead, they still have a 98% chance of winning. At 13, it goes down to "only" 96%. You have to shave the lead all the way down to 9 points before the win probably dips under 90% (and even then, it's still 89%).
I guess in conclusion, 15 points or more with 5 minutes to go, you can just kick the extra point.
If your answer is yes, then we will agree to disagree. Because they would be one play way from having it an 12 point game with 4:45 or so to play. Still a big comeback, that's doable.
If your answer is no, that the Cardinals would have an unlikely but non zero probability of winning, then I would say the following:
1) NFL teams run kicks back for TD's on occasion, we would agree this is a possibility. So it's possible that Arizona could return the kick and cut the lead to 19.
2) NFL teams recover onside kicks on occasion. If 1) happened, and 2) happened, you just arrived at a situation where the Cardinals have the ball on the Panthers 40 or so. One play away from an 11 point game.
Again - miracle. I get it. The odds of one of those happening is remote, both in sequence really remote. But I don't see why you would take that chance is you are the Panthers. Just keep playing the game, do everything you can to increase your odds of winning.
2:00, up 25, other team out of times, ball on their 10, 1:30 left - not taking a knee would be a dick move, classless, and not in the spirit of the game. That I would have a problem with, not going for 2 when there was still 5 minutes left in the game.
That's my take on it.

