Matt Holliday

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by jim »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Holliday has an .861 OPS in the postseason (122 PA) and a .929 OPS in the regular season (4800 PA).

His errors and misfortunes, which everyone has, seem to be in very, very, very high profile and well-viewed situations however.

Not to suggest Jim is your average joe blow dumb ass fan, we all know he is not, but there are a lot of joe blow dumb ass fans that share jim's thoughts because they see the two errors on Sportscenter and a stat that says he only has a .6?? OPS in the WS whiel ignoring his 1.1+ OPS in NLCS games or .937 OPS while in STL (.938 while in CO btw).

That might be, but is it any difference than taking OPS at face value and stating what a great series he had when it really wasn't? I think it can intimidate some fans who really did watch more than sportscenter and made their own conclusions. They are almost afraid to state the obvious because they don't know what the heck those numbers are. Some insecure folks will shrug their shoulders and wonder if they just don't understand this complicated game. I think it goes both ways.

I happen to think WPA is the best measure out there looking back in time. I personally could care less if someone performs when it doesn't matter. I want to know how each contribution changes the game, and in Holliday's case his NLCS numbers are very hollow. It's almost mind boggling to see how someone could put those numbers up and not have more to show for it. His first year in St. Louis it was freaking June and Holliday was hitting over .300 and had a negative WPA. Never had I seen anything like it, you could just count on Holliday getting the hit when it didn't matter and coming up empty in the clutch.

Yeah yeah, regression and all that. I get it. And Holliday hits the ball harder than anyone in baseball. It's freaking scary the way the ball comes off of his bat. I know he's a great player.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by Freed Roger »

I Stand with Jim.

Unfortunately, no good GIS for this.

User avatar
docellis
America's Most Beloved Twitter Joke Thief
Posts: 24741
Joined: April 18 06, 6:54 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by docellis »

he called in to the morning after this morning and advocated an in-studio dating game show for freese. and he said he was going to paint a picture of lance berkman flying on a bald eagle with a sword in his hand.

M1IRONMIKE
Well hello, pilgrim
Posts: 4129
Joined: October 7 06, 7:23 am
Location: springfield illinois

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by M1IRONMIKE »

I also agree with jim....Holliday has been disappointing on the big stage IMO. After the game 6 gaffes and factoring in the nutsack drop of the fly ball against the dodgers it is hard for me to toot the holliday horn. All that being said however I am still glad we signed him and hope at some point he proves to be a better big game performer. I think even Holliday himself knows he has disappointed which is why he is going out of his way this offseason to rebuild his image. He may very well blossom now that pujols has left. Some players just have a difficult time fitting in and performing when they are used to being "the man" on their teams. I am still a fan of his but seriously I was ready to explode when he screwed up so badly in game 6.

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by cardsfansince82 »

docellis wrote:and he said he was going to paint a picture of lance berkman flying on a bald eagle with a sword in his hand.
I was kind of leaning towards jim's side until I read this.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by Freed Roger »

M1IRONMIKE wrote:. I think even Holliday himself knows he has disappointed which is why he is going out of his way this offseason to rebuild his image
That is what I was thinking. when he called in to dispute his durability to a radio show, that is a bit defensive.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by jim »

How did this stay in rants? I think it's been a good baseball discussion.

Mike nailed it for me. I'm a fan, he's a great player, I'm glad he's a Cardinal. I just think he's laid an egg when it counts more than once. He needs to fix that, and I will be a very happy Cardinal fan if and when he does.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by vinsanity »

jim wrote:I just think he's laid an egg when it counts more than once. He needs to fix that, and I will be a very happy Cardinal fan if and when he does.
I just don't buy the the 'clutch' thing and I think it's just a sample size issue. In 4 playoff series he's had 1 good one and 3 bad ones. He was injured in 1 (WS) and the whole team was abysmal in another.

Rasmus sported a 1.300 OPS when it counted...would you rather have had him in LF for Game 7?

I think a big time performance in the playoffs will just cement his position as the new 'franchise player' and help him find his place in Cardinal history, but I don't put much weight on 20 games that he under-performed in.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by ghostrunner »

jim wrote:How did this stay in rants? I think it's been a good baseball discussion.

Mike nailed it for me. I'm a fan, he's a great player, I'm glad he's a Cardinal. I just think he's laid an egg when it counts more than once. He needs to fix that, and I will be a very happy Cardinal fan if and when he does.
That can all turn on a dime though. You could have slapped Rolen with that in 2004. Hitless in the World Series, very good NLCS, and hitless in the NLDS. All after more or less carrying the team (outside of Pujols) in April and May. Then in 2006 he was (IMO) the true MVP of the World Series.

I think I'm more with the random variation crowd in general, though I do think emotions and nerves can get in the way.

Getting beyond that, I'd be interested in a study of players that are able to duplicate performance day-in/day-out like Pujols, even if it's not on the same level as him. Then compare them to more erratic hitters. Then you have the difference between pitchers like Maddux and Marquis. Why can some people continuously duplicate command or control of their pitches and others can't? Is that emotional or mental, or are some bodies physically incapable of sustaining the same motions over and over again? Edwin Jackson seems to be all over the place to me. Some days he looks brilliant, others times I wonder how he's made it this far. It's been a while since this has been tested, but why did I used to get in phases where I could sink free throw after free throw and then a week later I couldn't? I've always found that interesting.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31097
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by Popeye_Card »

ghostrunner wrote:
jim wrote:How did this stay in rants? I think it's been a good baseball discussion.

Mike nailed it for me. I'm a fan, he's a great player, I'm glad he's a Cardinal. I just think he's laid an egg when it counts more than once. He needs to fix that, and I will be a very happy Cardinal fan if and when he does.
That can all turn on a dime though. You could have slapped Rolen with that in 2004. Hitless in the World Series, very good NLCS, and hitless in the NLDS. All after more or less carrying the team (outside of Pujols) in April and May. Then in 2006 he was (IMO) the true MVP of the World Series.

I think I'm more with the random variation crowd in general, though I do think emotions and nerves can get in the way.

Getting beyond that, I'd be interested in a study of players that are able to duplicate performance day-in/day-out like Pujols, even if it's not on the same level as him. Then compare them to more erratic hitters. Then you have the difference between pitchers like Maddux and Marquis. Why can some people continuously duplicate command or control of their pitches and others can't? Is that emotional or mental, or are some bodies physically incapable of sustaining the same motions over and over again? Edwin Jackson seems to be all over the place to me. Some days he looks brilliant, others times I wonder how he's made it this far. It's been a while since this has been tested, but why did I used to get in phases where I could sink free throw after free throw and then a week later I couldn't? I've always found that interesting.
I am interested in the science behind why a man would let a line drive smack his sack.

Post Reply