AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Holliday has an .861 OPS in the postseason (122 PA) and a .929 OPS in the regular season (4800 PA).
His errors and misfortunes, which everyone has, seem to be in very, very, very high profile and well-viewed situations however.
Not to suggest Jim is your average joe blow dumb ass fan, we all know he is not, but there are a lot of joe blow dumb ass fans that share jim's thoughts because they see the two errors on Sportscenter and a stat that says he only has a .6?? OPS in the WS whiel ignoring his 1.1+ OPS in NLCS games or .937 OPS while in STL (.938 while in CO btw).
That might be, but is it any difference than taking OPS at face value and stating what a great series he had when it really wasn't? I think it can intimidate some fans who really did watch more than sportscenter and made their own conclusions. They are almost afraid to state the obvious because they don't know what the heck those numbers are. Some insecure folks will shrug their shoulders and wonder if they just don't understand this complicated game. I think it goes both ways.
I happen to think WPA is the best measure out there looking back in time. I personally could care less if someone performs when it doesn't matter. I want to know how each contribution changes the game, and in Holliday's case his NLCS numbers are very hollow. It's almost mind boggling to see how someone could put those numbers up and not have more to show for it. His first year in St. Louis it was freaking June and Holliday was hitting over .300 and had a negative WPA. Never had I seen anything like it, you could just count on Holliday getting the hit when it didn't matter and coming up empty in the clutch.
Yeah yeah, regression and all that. I get it. And Holliday hits the ball harder than anyone in baseball. It's freaking scary the way the ball comes off of his bat. I know he's a great player.


