Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on February 3. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

Same number of questions as last week, with one bonus Q&A about three-ways. (They must have let @Leroy ask a question.) Enjoy!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/02/ ... t-105.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Cardinals getting 3 prospects and two draft picks for Donovan. What’s your take on the trade?

Steve Adams
Not surprisingly, probably 50+ questions queued up on yesterday’s trade haha. I’ll spare you publishing them all and offer some thoughts (while also noting that Darragh and I broke this trade down for about 15 minutes on the episode of the podcast we recorded this morning, so keep an eye/ear out for that tomorrow morning!)

Donovan is an ideal fit for a Mariners team that has holes at 2B/3B/one corner OF spot and young options at each. He furthers their goal of cutting back on strikeouts/improving contact, and he does so while maintaining the flexibility/agility needed should any of Colt Emerson, Cole Young, Dom Canzone, etc. really show they need everyday ABs early in the season.

I think the Cards did well. They didn’t get a massive, marquee prospect but landed a top-100-ish guy (Cijntje), two recent top-100 draft picks (Peete, Ledbetter) and a pair of top-75 picks in the upcoming draft.Tai Peete (contact) and Colton Ledbetter (lack of any one true standout tool) both have some red flags but are solid additions to the middle tiers of the system. The picks are nice both for adding talent and giving them the flexibility to be creative if a first-round talent slides due to signability concerns.

The Rays’ side of this is the strangest to me, but I’ve come around on it. Williamson is a high-floor defender with decent contact skills who can back up at multiple positions. He has multiple minor league options remaining.Rays gave up a Comp pick for three years of a solid middle reliever (Bryan Baker) last July and another for a glove-first utility guy with decent contact skills this offseason. If you could guarantee a team an immediately usable RP or utility guy at the No. 70 pick, that guy would absolutely be scooped up.

It’s boring to say it works for everyone, but … I don’t have an immediately negative reaction to any angle of the deal.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pirates to send Thomas Harrington and Mitch Jebb to the Astros for Isaac Paredes? Would that be enough to get a deal done?

Steve Adams
Don’t think so.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think the Nats could sign someone like Hoskins or Goldschmidt this offseason to fill their hole at first base?

Steve Adams
Either guy works. Ty France, Miguel Andujar, Dom Smith too. Could try to buy low on a guy like Triston Casas (Toboni connection!). Lots of options for them.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any notable RP arms available on the trade market?

Steve Adams
Cardinals will probably trade JoJo Romero. Rockies are open on some of their guys (Vodnik, Halvorsen, Mejia). Broadly speaking though, I don’t think there are a ton of obvious RP trade candidates out there.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who’s the best lefty reliever still available via trade/free agency?

Steve Adams
Danny Coulombe, Justin Wilson, JoJo Romero
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How does Kevin Alcantara figure into the Cubs plans? I’d like to see him as the 4OF, but i feel like he needs regular playing time. Happ and Suzuki may be gone next year.

Steve Adams
I feel like he’s a guy they could trade eventually. I’m not all that bullish on him, honestly. He’s had two seasons in AAA and struck out at a 29% clip in both. Power/speed combo is intriguing, but I wonder if he’ll ever hit enough.

Not saying DFA him or anything, but he might just be more of a fourth outfielder in the long run.

If they don’t trade him, then yeah, regular work in AAA to try to cut back on the chase and whiff rates would be good. He feels like a guy who’d strike out at like a 35% clip in MLB right now.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Michael Busch or Christian Walker seem like perfect trade targets for the padres to play 1B. What am I missing?

Steve Adams
The Cubs have no reason to trade Busch when they’re trying to contend. He’s one of their best hitters. No team wants Christian Walker’s contract, and I doubt the Astros want to eat $30MM of that $40MM to just get someone to take part of the deal.

Better to preserve the depth, hope he can build on last year’s second-half improvements, etc.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any hope for Walker or Gorman?

Steve Adams
I’m pretty much out on both.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on the Nationals taking a flyer on another arm for their rotation? Before the Gore trade there were a lot of question marks so it might make sense to grab a vet who can eat some innings.

Steve Adams
They have to add another arm. Someone has to pitch those innings. Doesn’t need to be anyone great. Throw $4MM at Miles Mikolas. Obviously, someone with a bit more upside would be nice, but they need someone to pitch some innings.

Could add two guys too. Mikolas for innings and Buehler or Marquez or Canning if they want some more upside to try to spin into a deadline chip.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Bloom is still looking for a RHB via external means. Best targets via either FA or trades?

Steve Adams
Was writing about this when the chat started.

Options at this point are limited, regardless of handedness. If a right-handed bat remains the goal, then any of Miguel Andujar, Austin Slater or old friends Randal Grichuk and Tommy Pham remain available. Trade options are tougher to nail down, particularly with so many names off the board already, but the Cardinals aren’t likely to take on any notable veteran salaries (e.g. Nick Castellanos). Speculatively speaking, the Rays (Jonny DeLuca), Blue Jays (Jonatan Clase), Phillies (Johan Rojas) and Royals (Drew Waters) have some outfield options who have fallen down their depth charts this winter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does Milwaukee roll with the young guys on their starting staff or make a late addition (like they did last year) of a veteran arm? Reunion with someone like Quintana or Montgomery?

Steve Adams
They make a late addition every year, it seems. I don’t know that a veteran like Quintana, Tyler Anderson, Patrick Corbin is going to want to head there when they have so many rotation options. Someone like Montgomery, who probably isn’t ready for Opening Day anyhow, makes some sense. They’ll probably have other injuries by the time he’s ready. Regardless, some form of cheap veteran depth seems fair to predict.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What are your thoughts on the Suarez deal? Will this have any real impact for Cincinnati or just another feel-good reunion for the fanbase? That starting rotation won’t be around forever!

Steve Adams
Great price. Hard not to like it. Gives them some cover for Hayes at 3B (hurt a lot) or Stewart at 1B (limited MLB experience). If they’re both healthy and hitting (well, as much as Hayes is ever going to hit), then Geno mashes as a DH. Nice deal all around.

Wouldn’t bank on 49 homers again, but 30-35 homers? Sure. Probably a low OBP and obviously negligible defensive value, but he can still be an above-average offensive contributor overall.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If O’Hearn is worth 2/29, then Walker is worth more than 2/10 as you say. His numbers were near career norms after a brutal start. I expect him to push for 30 homers again, even if he only hits .250

Steve Adams
Pirates bought ROH’s age-32 and 33 seasons. Walker’s next two seasons are age-35 and 36. MLB teams hate paying guys in their mid/late 30s (hence Suarez’s one-year deal).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If the Pirates still don’t contend this year, do you think they considered trading Skenes next off-season?

Steve Adams
No.

Maybe by the time Skenes has only one year left, but not anytime soon.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Bassitt or Buehler to solidify Cleveland’s starting 5?

Steve Adams
If they’re going to spend money, it should be on a bat. But they keep sitting back while bats are flying off the shelves via free agency and trade, so maybe they’re just going to be this cheap this year. I don’t know, but it’s been a brutal offseason for them. I thought Suarez as a once-a-week sub for Ramirez at third (DH day for him), a platoon partner at 1B for Manzardo and a DH otherwise would’ve been a great fit, and the 1/15 price point wasn’t major. Cleveland would’ve had to beat that, sure, but feels like something they should’ve tried to do.

I know he spurned the Pirates on a two-year offer, but Cleveland is coming off a division win. Their park is also terrible for RH power, just like Pittsburgh though, so maybe Geno wouldn’t have had interest.

Regardless, the Guards need to do something to improve that lineup.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Why is everyone still so intrigued by Buehler?

Steve Adams
I personally wasn’t even intrigued by him last offseason, but I listed him as an “upside” guy because he’s relatively young and was good awhile ago.I think just because he was a former top prospect who had a big few moments in the postseason in ’24, primarily.

He was just … not good …. in 2025. I’m similarly out on Dustin May, but hey, the Cardinals gave him $12MM. Really, really don’t like that deal but let’s see what they can do with him.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Cardinals have an all home grown starting 8 on opening day?

Steve Adams
Bloom’s out here saying he wants to add an OF from outside the organization.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------

This is the Rays’ second three-way deal this offseason. The first was the Lowe trade. Do they have a thing for three-ways?

Steve Adams
Jon Becker from FanGraphs pointed out that the Rays have been involved on six of the past seven three-team trades in MLB. Amazing.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by phins »

Fair analysis.

Post Reply