Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on January 11.

Lot of questions this week, and one bonus question about Skubal's arb hearing (since we were discussing this in another thread). Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/01/ ... at-99.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Bellinger will get more or less than Bregman?

Mark Polishuk
I probably shouldn’t doubt Boras’ ability to work his magic, but I think it’ll be less.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
As a Brewers fan, is there any rebuttal to the Cubs recent moves?

Mark Polishuk
The Brewers aren’t ever going to outspend the Cubs, but that hasn’t stopped Milwaukee from beating them in the past. I’m not sure I’d necessarily even pick Chicago for first in the Central right now.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What type of package should the Brewers receive from a Freddy Peralta trade? Which teams seem to be most interested?

Mark Polishuk
Peralta is so inexpensive that pretty much any contender in the league would or should want him.

The most popular comp for a Peralta trade package is the Corbin Burnes package: a MLB-ready position player, an MLB-ready pitcher, and a draft pick (or another minor leaguer, if the Brewers are dealing with a team that doesn’t have a tradeable Competitive Balance Pick).
Given how Peralta is also making a little more than half of Burnes’ salary in his final arb-eligible season, the Brewers may well ask for more in a trade return.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Think the Cubs will do the Red Sox a solid and trade Hoerner to Boston?

Mark Polishuk
The Bregman signing makes a Nico trade slightly more likely, but if I’m the Cubs, I keep everyone for the sake of depth. Injuries are inevitable, and there are worse ideas than having Moises/Shaw/Alcantara as the all-younger bench core.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With Ketel reportedly off the trading block, what do you think the timing and return of a Donovan trade would be?

Mark Polishuk
Bregman’s signing might open things up for a Donovan trade in the next couple of weeks, since now you figure Boston might make a larger push (not that the Sox are the only Donovan suitor by a long shot).

I also have my doubts that Marte is truly off the market. That might be a little bit of gamesmanship from Mike Hazen to try and spur better offers.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who says no, Brendan Donovan for Bryce Eldridge?

Mark Polishuk
Giants in a heartbeat. They’re not moving a top prospect for two years of Donovan.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Wouldn’t the Jays be better off trying to get a deal done with Bo as opposed to Tucker? Tucker is clearly the better player, but in addition to costing more his arrival would mean one of Springer, Varsho, Santander, Okamoto or Barger would have to take a seat. Bringing Bo back lets those big bats all stay in the line up and Clement moves to the bench… which also solves the Jays need for a bench bat that can play SS and 2b.

Mark Polishuk
Toronto has enough multi-positional guys that they’d sign Tucker and let the rest figure itself out. If that means keeping Santander as a very expensive part-timer, so be it.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who gets the better return? One year of Hoerner or two years of Donovan?

Mark Polishuk
Donovan.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
is Alec Burleson the Cardinals first baseman next year? Or do the Cardinals spend 5 to 6 million for Rhys Hoskins?

Mark Polishuk
Burleson will get every opportunity for everyday at-bats. St. Louis is in a rebuild and will prioritize giving their younger guys chances.
Put another way, the Cards aren’t moving Contreras to open up first base just to sign someone like a Hoskins to cut into Burleson’s playing time.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What’s the latest on Louis Robert and K Tucker? I really thought the Sox would’ve move Robert by now and I certainly thought Tucker and Bellinger would have new homes by now? I can’t recall – is it odd that the some of the top names in the FA/to be traded group are still out there?

Mark Polishuk
It’s not at all unusual, especially since Boras represents so many top guys and he is not shy about letting his clients’ markets play out deeper into the winter. And even then, you saw Boras clients Cease and Alonso both sign relatively early.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Better chance of winning a championship in the year 2026: Cubs or Bears?

Mark Polishuk
As a Packers fan, this question really made me grit my teeth. My answer is the Cubs, since the Bears’ next opponent probably won’t decide to phone in a half of football.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What would you grade the Marlins in the Cabrera trade? Caissie seems like another young player to add to a nice young core.

Mark Polishuk
I like the deal for Miami. Caissie is the kind of blue-chip prospect you want to get back for a pitcher with Cabrera’s upside and years of team control.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What's the holdup with Tucker, with Soto last year it got done quickly, are teams mulling over Tucker’s projection? it seems what reporters said about him has many GM's scared, even his supposed $400M ask is slipping into $300’s.

Mark Polishuk
Soto has a much stronger track record than Tucker, plus several big-market teams involved in his bidding war. This offseason, the Mets, Yankees, etc. aren’t as keen to spend big money, leaving Tucker’s market more than a little uncertain.

For all of the reports that Toronto might be a frontrunner for Tucker, for instance, the Jays might not be willing to offer him a desired contract if they feel they’re bidding against themselves.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Pirates done with adding to the lineup? I know it’s not great but it’s much improved especially considering they have the top offensive prospect in baseball. If money is tight, I’d rather add a veteran starter.

Mark Polishuk
Cherington said the other day that the team is still looking for a third baseman or shortstop. Adding such a player on a short-term deal could work, while still allowing for enough dollars to bring in a veteran arm. (Jose Quintana, come on down!)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is Bregman’s signing with the Cubs at all a reflection of ownership cheapness or front office incompetence in Boston, or did the Cubs just overpower the Red Sox with a great offer?

Mark Polishuk
According to reports, Boston’s offer also had a lot of deferred money but spread out over a much longer period of time.

And, the lack of a no-trade clause seemed like an issue of Bregman. This is speculative on my part, but I wonder if seeing what happened with Devers last year made Bregman wary about committing with the Sox unless they gave him no-trade protection.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who’s taking JoJo Romero off my hands?

Mark Polishuk
Hard to say, since tons of teams could use a solid lefty reliever.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Barger to the Pirates? Good move? Or is Bohm more likely?

Mark Polishuk
There is basically zero chance the Jays would trade Barger. Bohm is vastly more likely, and while that’s technically an upgrade for Pittsburgh, I think they can do better.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does Hunter Greene play for Cincy or somewhere else?

Mark Polishuk
Cincinnati. The Reds aren’t moving him unless they got an absolute haul in return.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Doesn’t seem like the Angels will be good anytime soon. Any other HOF caliber players to play on such bad teams their entire career?

Mark Polishuk
Ernie Banks leaps to mind.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Reports say Boras is going to use a seldom used clause that allows final arb eligible players to comp to free agent contracts. How much would Skubal get on a 1 year free agent contract? Do you think Skubal wins his arbitration hearing?

Mark Polishuk
I think the Tigers win, just because I’m not sure the panel will want to give Skubal such a precedent-shattering salary.

This is another reason why a Skubal trade might be unlikely, at least until the hearing is over. It would be mighty awkward for a team to trade for Skubal, then immediately go into a contentious arbitration and arguing “well, he’s not THAT good…”

If Skubal was magically a free agent now and was limited to one-year deals, he would also easily clear $32MM.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by phins »

Who says no, Brendan Donovan for Bryce Eldridge?

Mark Polishuk
Giants in a heartbeat. They’re not moving a top prospect for two years of Donovan.

I would have to think before I traded Donovan for Eldridge straight up. This guy says Giants say no in a heartbeat? These chats are great, I read every year, but goodness do the writers see the world differently than I do.

User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by Famous Mortimer »

Yes, they do, because they're not homers for one of the teams referenced. There is absolutely no way that trade happens.

User avatar
CardsofSTL
All Hail the GDT Master
Posts: 70085
Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
Location: Columbus, OH

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by CardsofSTL »

Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
January 13 26, 8:59 am
Yes, they do, because they're not homers for one of the teams referenced.
Don't be homerphobic

cardsfantx
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12220
Joined: November 6 10, 10:58 am

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by cardsfantx »

I have agree with phins; I know Eldridge is a top prospect, but he's got Gorman written all over him IMO

gonna be able to hit a ton of bombs, but that whiff rate is yuck, plus he's a bad fielder...and at 6'7", and seeing what struggles walker has at that size?

there's a reason that he's supposed to break camp and he wasn't even mentioned on MLB's potential ROY winners (jj was ranked #1 as who they thought would win)
2026 could end up being a breakout season for top SF Giants prospect Bryce Eldridge, but MLB executives around the league do not seem to think so. In a recent poll, Eldridge did not get much love when it came to predicting the 2026 National League Rookie of the Year.

In fact Eldridge's name did not come up at all in a poll that included responses, all anonymous of course, from general managers, farm directors, scouts, and other front office types.

User avatar
CardsofSTL
All Hail the GDT Master
Posts: 70085
Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
Location: Columbus, OH

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by CardsofSTL »

I think the Giants are going to go after Hoerner at a cheaper price than what the Cardinals are asking for Donovan anyway. Hoerner is now expendable from the Cubbies.

User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by Famous Mortimer »

cardsfantx wrote: ↑
January 13 26, 10:44 am
and at 6'7", and seeing what struggles walker has at that size?
If only there were other examples of players of that height, so we could see if it's not the height that's the issue but the player. Unless that's the joke you're making? I'm very tired.

aaronjudge.jpg

cardsfantx
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12220
Joined: November 6 10, 10:58 am

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by cardsfantx »

Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
January 13 26, 11:29 am
cardsfantx wrote: ↑
January 13 26, 10:44 am
and at 6'7", and seeing what struggles walker has at that size?
If only there were other examples of players of that height, so we could see if it's not the height that's the issue but the player. Unless that's the joke you're making? I'm very tired.

aaronjudge.jpg
yes, Aaron judge...and that's it

stanton is the only other one in MLB history that size who's been any good, and he's struggled with injuries for so long; does it have anything to do with his size?

User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

Dave Winfield too, but yes I get the point

User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

cardsfantx wrote: ↑
January 13 26, 11:44 am
Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
January 13 26, 11:29 am
cardsfantx wrote: ↑
January 13 26, 10:44 am
and at 6'7", and seeing what struggles walker has at that size?
If only there were other examples of players of that height, so we could see if it's not the height that's the issue but the player. Unless that's the joke you're making? I'm very tired.

aaronjudge.jpg
yes, Aaron judge...and that's it

stanton is the only other one in MLB history that size who's been any good, and he's struggled with injuries for so long; does it have anything to do with his size?
Randy Johnson is looking down his nose at you with an icy glare.

Frank Howard would also disagree, if he was still alive.

Post Reply