These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on November 11. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)
Enjoy the questions this week. I added 1 bonus Q&A about a former Cardinal.
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/chat-with ... 22933.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Given the payroll is the same, how can the Reds claim they will compete in 2026? Isn't it more of the same dumpster diving and wishing something good happens?
Steve Adams
They nabbed a Wild Card spot in 2025 and did so in a season where they went through notable stretches without Hunter Greene, Tyler Stephenson, Noelvi Marte and others -- plus they got nothing out of Matt McLain.
They have a handful of notable free agents in Nick Martinez, Emilio Pagan, Zack Littell and Miguel Andujar, but I think most of that group is composed of regression candidates anyhow.
All of which is to say, I don't think they need to send payroll soaring to compete. Obviously it'd be nice if the Castellinis gave Krall & Co. an extra $20MM or so on top of last year's budget, but they've got some wiggle room right now as it is, especially if they trade Brady Singer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Blue Jays pursue Kyle Tucker? I’d like to see them re-sign Bichette AND bring in Tucker.
Steve Adams
They'll pursue him. I wouldn't get your hopes up for a Tucker+Bichette combo, but it's at least slightly plausible, which is more than can be said for most clubs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Steve why did Baldwin beat out Cade Horton for NL ROY? To me that is a joke. He was unbelievable in the 2nd half. His ERA over his last 14 starts was 1- something. Come on, what are we doing here?
Steve Adams
Horton would've been perfectly deserving, but focusing only on his final 12 starts also ignores a good-not-great 10 starts to begin his career.
Drake Baldwin was in the majors all year (Horton wasn't) and was 25% better than average at the plate as a catcher -- a position where the standard player is about 10% worse than average.
I wouldn't begrudge anyone preferring Horton over Baldwin, but there wasn't a cavernous gulf between them at all.
I'd also have voted for Baldwin, in full transparency. Sorry! (If Horton had been up on Opening Day and pitched like that in the majors all season, it'd be another story.)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Dodgers could pretty easily trade for a Kwan loke player rather sign Tucker. I think that hype is there just because they are the Dodgers. They need to clean up 40 man space and have a ton of depth at the same positions in the minors.
Steve Adams
I'm sure they'll look into both. Kwan would cost quite a bit in a trade, and I'd take Tucker over him in a heartbeat. But sure, if the Dodgers feel Tucker's asking price is prohibitive, Steven Kwan is a nice alternative.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Ive always thought teams should be more open to trading within their divisions. For example if the Cubs wanted Donovan, who cares the Cards aren’t going to be good anytime soon and if you can get good prospects back it’s a win for both teams.
Steve Adams
I don't have a ton of insight other than to say I generally agree with this. Lots of clubs get caught up in optics. I get that you don't want to strengthen a division rival for years to come, but I still feel it's a bit of a blind spot for a lot of clubs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think Brendan Donovan could hold down SS for the Braves? He and Gray would make amazing pickups and fill 2 huge needs for them.
Steve Adams
I've wondered whether the Braves might consider this. I kind of like it as an out-of-the-box option for one year, given the lack of alternative options. It's a leap of faith in a guy who hasn't played there much, but there's just not a ton out there and I think Donovan is probably athletic enough to make it work short-term if you give him an offseason and spring training to prepare. Worst case, he's well below average and you move him into a utility role and plug Nick Allen's glove back in there.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Let’s say the Pirates flip Burrows and Keller for bats, also freeing up capital for a few years on Keller’s deal. Opening day rotation starts Skenes-Chandler-Ashcraft-Oviedo. Do you add a 5th starter (classic Cherington soft-tossing lefty) or give Hunter Barco a shot?
Steve Adams
You're forgetting Jared Jones as a potential entrant in that rotation. He'll be more than a year removed from Tommy John surgery.
But I still think if they traded Keller and Burrows both, then yes, they'd add a cheap one-year SP in February or so.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you feel the Reds bring in a 1B/DH or an OF as their big bat, via trade or signing?
Steve Adams
I expect them to be open to it but think it could just as likely be in the OF -- or that they could (should) add one of each.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
True or False. The Reds have a top 5 rotation in all of baseball.
Steve Adams
Off the cuff, I think this is probably right. Greene-Abbott-Lodolo-Singer-Burns, with Petty/Lowder waiting in the wings. Tons of talent there.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Pirates going to have a hard time dealing Keller? There are good free agent options at 3 years/$54MM. No need to trade a good bat for Keller if you can get a comparable talent on the open market.
Steve Adams
Keller at 3/54 is solid value. It's true there are pitchers like Merrill Kelly or Chris Bassitt who could be had on shorter deals, but they'd require larger AAVs and are already 37.
If Keller were a free agent coming off this season (really his past several seasons) and heading to market ahead of his age-30 campaign, you're not getting him for "only" three years. There's not necessarily a ton of surplus value AAV-wise, but a durable 30-year-old midrotation arm is going to get four or five years.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any chance the Phils swap Casty to St. Louis for Arenado? Then flip Bohm to the Angels for Ward? Arenado has two years left, so that could appeal to the Cards.
Steve Adams
Arenado's contract is even less desirable than Castellanos'. And I'd rather have Taylor Ward than Alec Bohm.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Bregman or Tucker: Who gets the higher AAV?
Steve Adams
Higher AAV in free agency?
Kyle Tucker (80.2% | 275 votes)
Alex Bregman (19.8% | 68 votes)
Total Votes: 343
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If the Cubs were to find a deal acceptable to Ian Happ or Seiya Suzuki, how much of their final year salaries would they have to absorb to get a useful return?
Steve Adams
I don't think they'd need to eat money for either player, but both have full no-trade clauses.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Yankees prioritize Tucker or Bellinger? If Tucker, will that put Bellinger on the back burner until Tucker is signed? (I.e. just like waiting for Soto to sign before pivoting)
Steve Adams
In general, I think Tucker feels likelier to sign earlier. Boras tends to be pretty comfortable waiting. They're in a tough spot with Bellinger a little bit. If his market does pick up early, the Yanks could run into the same scenario they saw with Willy Adames last winter... interested, but unwilling to commit until they know how the bigger fish pans out. By the time Soto was off the board last winter, it was too late on Adames.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would trading Ramos for Mitch Keller or Pablo Lopez be enough?
Steve Adams
Ramos isn't enough for either, especially Lopez.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Matt Shaw and a TOR starter or go outside the organization to fill 3rd base and go lesser in the rotation?
Steve Adams
Latter scenario is likelier. I'm not personally huge on Matt Shaw after 2025. I don't think it's at all out of the question that he just puts it together in his second year, but there weren't a ton of positives in his rookie campaign other than the plus DRS rating at 3B.
I assume there are teams (probably including the Cubs) who are higher on Shaw than me, so in the very hypothetical scenario (which Cubs fans should not at all want), I'd be seeing what kind of SP I could get with Shaw as one of the headliners and then looking at 3B alternatives.
I put the Cubs on Kazuma Okamoto on our Top 50 for this reason (and because I had a hard time placing Okamoto in general, ha).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What's a realistic return for Taylor Ward?
Steve Adams
I will call for the Brady Singer/Taylor Ward trade until I'm blue in the face. Or until it happens. Or until one of them is traded for a different player.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Harrison Bader makes too much sense for the O's IMO.
Steve Adams
Bader is a plus defensive OF who can hit a little bit and will at absolute max cost three years -- two seems likelier. He fits/makes tons of sense for a lot of teams.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Steve Adams' NL Central comments
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11769
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois