Trade offer--good or not?
Posted: April 19 10, 5:58 pm
I've been offered Johnny Damon, Garrett Jones, Carlos Zambrano, and Jake Peavy for Ichiro Suzuki and Jonathan Broxton. What say you, GRB?
Quantity for quality. If you have poor depth, maybe it's not a bad deal. But if you have good secondary players and adding Zambrano and Peavy is just adding more mediocre pitchers to the shuffle, then it's a step back to give up higher-quality players.
I wouldn't personally do it, but that's because I don't trust Zambrano and Peavy to do overly well this season.