Trade offer--good or not?

[Mary1966]

I've been offered Johnny Damon, Garrett Jones, Carlos Zambrano, and Jake Peavy for Ichiro Suzuki and Jonathan Broxton. What say you, GRB?

[Popeye_Card]

Quantity for quality. If you have poor depth, maybe it's not a bad deal. But if you have good secondary players and adding Zambrano and Peavy is just adding more mediocre pitchers to the shuffle, then it's a step back to give up higher-quality players.

I wouldn't personally do it, but that's because I don't trust Zambrano and Peavy to do overly well this season.