Starting RF in '07 playoffs
- Ace
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3781
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:36 pm
- Location: St. Louis
It would be a great thing!picasso wrote:Would that be a bad thing?Ace wrote:So you think when Juan comes back he is going to be a bench player?jdk82 wrote:I think Preston Wilson would be
The problem is it would be for someone better than Juan, not someone who has struck out in a third of his at bats so far this year.
- jdk82
- All-Star
- Posts: 2881
- Joined: April 4 07, 8:58 pm
- Location: Iowa
I just dont think Juan will have the strength in his wrist to be an everyday player when he gets back.Ace wrote:It would be a great thing!picasso wrote:Would that be a bad thing?Ace wrote:So you think when Juan comes back he is going to be a bench player?jdk82 wrote:I think Preston Wilson would be
The problem is it would be for someone better than Juan, not someone who has struck out in a third of his at bats so far this year.
As far as Wilson goes I would rather have someone else but I dont see it happening. I just dont think they will trade for another outfielder this year. Just my opinions though.
- Ace
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3781
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:36 pm
- Location: St. Louis
I don't understand. Wouldn't he just stay on the DL until it heals. I mean hes not the cornerstone of this team or anything either hes hurt or hes not.jdk82 wrote:I just dont think Juan will have the strength in his wrist to be an everyday player when he gets back.Ace wrote:It would be a great thing!picasso wrote:Would that be a bad thing?Ace wrote:So you think when Juan comes back he is going to be a bench player?jdk82 wrote:I think Preston Wilson would be
The problem is it would be for someone better than Juan, not someone who has struck out in a third of his at bats so far this year.
As far as Wilson goes I would rather have someone else but I dont see it happening. I just dont think they will trade for another outfielder this year. Just my opinions though.
And I think you need to reword your second paragraph.
- jdk82
- All-Star
- Posts: 2881
- Joined: April 4 07, 8:58 pm
- Location: Iowa
The Cards management probably believes that Juan at 80% is better than Skip at 100% in my mind. Thats why he wouldnt stay on the DL till he gained full strength in his wrist which could take a long while.Ace wrote:I don't understand. Wouldn't he just stay on the DL until it heals. I mean hes not the cornerstone of this team or anything either hes hurt or hes not.jdk82 wrote:I just dont think Juan will have the strength in his wrist to be an everyday player when he gets back.Ace wrote:It would be a great thing!picasso wrote:Would that be a bad thing?Ace wrote:So you think when Juan comes back he is going to be a bench player?jdk82 wrote:I think Preston Wilson would be
The problem is it would be for someone better than Juan, not someone who has struck out in a third of his at bats so far this year.
As far as Wilson goes I would rather have someone else but I dont see it happening. I just dont think they will trade for another outfielder this year. Just my opinions though.
And I think you need to reword your second paragraph.



