The Trayvon Martin shooting

Chat about non-baseball topics. No political discussions!
Post Reply
Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by Freed Roger »

Hudler wrote:
cards2468 wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:
cards2468 wrote:
jim wrote:Where is this obsession with guns rooted? It's really odd how people think about them to me. The answers to the questions from the pro-gun people just fly in the face of logic. You get answers like "Well if that kid had a gun he wouldn't be dead", or "if everyone on that plane had a gun those terrorists wouldn't fly that plane into the building". To me those answers are so absurd I don't even know how to respond.
Probably because the roots of America come from militias. The constitution wrote in that people have the right to form them and people have the right to bare arms. We're a different culture than the rest of the world because our history is very different and our beginning came at a different time than any other empire.
None of this makes any sense, frankly. Many parts of the world, socialist Europe included, have long, long histories of gun ownership, gun rights, and continue to have high rates of gun ownership among their citizenry. Most of the rest of the Americas achieved independence, through wars, within 50 years of the US. Guns, militias, and frontier culture were equally important in almost all of them and in most of them gun ownership is still legal. In fact, most of their constitutions are modeled on the US constitution.

The problem we suffer from is this noxious idea that any restriction of gun rights is a restriction on all personal liberty and freedom. This is pumped up by a massive gun industry and lobby. Where do all the criminals get their guns, anyway? They don't make them at home. They are manufactured legally and then easily slip into criminal hands in the piss-poor regulatory and accounting environment that exists in the US.
None of those countries earned independence the way the US did and followed on being the most powerful nation in the world. I think the level of nationalism here is much greater than other countries in the Americas and Europe. There's a different level of pride here over the concept of citizens picking up arms for national defense than other nations.
The U.S. is one of only about 4 countries that was settled and became a country like it did, and the others all had a large empire backing them. You cannot compare the U.S. to South America or Europe. Large numbers of white European poor migrated here and depended on guns for protection and hunting to sustain themselves. If you lived in the backwoods of Eastern Kentucky in 1800 (like my family did) would you be there unarmed? Nowhere in Europe did they have to worry about a native population trying to slaughter them, that hadn't happened there for hundreds of years.
When we talk the history of US infatuation with guns - the slave-holding scenario can't be dismissed.. Guns were needed to keep slaves. It was a minority of people that held slaves, but still, that was a heck of a lot of people to keep captive, and they couldn't just do it all with pitchforks and threats.


But in the modern day world, why is it that men like Zimmerman feel compelled to arm themselves for daily life? I'm not opposed to gun ownership, but I am guessing the carrying/packin heat demographic in cities is overwhelmingly able-bodied males that don't really need protection.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by sighyoung »

Hudler is talking about Scots-Irish ancestors, I believe, who indeed were fiercely independent, and often went to remoter areas as pioneers, and who often wanted to be left alone.

As Freed notes, though, it's not just settler or frontier culture that shaped policies or attitudes about firearms. Even dating back to the 17th century, laws in various colonies stated who could own and use firearms, and who could kill whom. This was one marker of citizenship, and was often tied to race and to slavery. The roots of Southern policing, for instance, can be partly traced to citizen patrols, which could stop any black person, question him or her, demand identification or documents, take into custody, and shoot to kill if necessary. Conversely, slaves were classified as property and had no legal standing or protection. So firearm ownership wasn't free from government control, but an expression of certain rights and privileges and a marker of distinction--as well as an inexpensive means of encouraging (even mandating) citizens identify with and protect slavery as an economic system.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by sighyoung »

I confess that I don't have well-thought-out ideas about firearms and their use. I do think that their use and perceived value is cultural, and in a country as large and diverse as the United States, you are likely to have places where extensive handgun ownership is not a big problem, and others where it is a huge problem, and generalized state or federal laws simply can't distinguish between the differing needs of differing communities--you're likely to get a Procrustean bed. I guess I'm splitting the difference between Hudler and Freed Roger, to a certain extent (and I know I haven't directly addressed either of your posts).

My second paragraph gets at a different problem--while many see gun ownership and use as an expression of personal liberty (and it can be), gun laws (and their use by ordinary people) reinforce our ideas about social and economic order. We are reinforcing rather than flouting ideas about government control through the use of guns, and we are reinforcing rather than flouting ideas about economic and social structure when we apply these laws.

Finally, laws increase certain kinds of error while decreasing others. The Stand-Your-Ground law is really just a utilitarian bargain that Florida's citizens have accepted--or rather, its legislators have accepted. Such laws may decrease some crimes, but are likely to increase the number of innocent citizens being shot and killed. How many, I can't say. Just as Ford Motor Company decided not to move the gas tanks on its Pintos, believing that it was economically better to pay out millions of dollars in settlement money rather than pay millions more to move the tanks, Florida's legislators have decided that, overall, the benefits of such a law outweigh the costs of accidental shootings. (I'm not going to weigh in here about the Martin case, because my argument is broader.)

People want to argue that the law is color-blind, or should be color-blind, but even if you argue that such a law benefits all citizens overall (and you can argue that), the citizens who are accidentally shot will fall into certain groups--the young (teenagers and folks in their twenties), and groups that demographically skew toward the young. You don't have to make a Geraldo Rivera-style hoodie argument to see why some groups would not be comfortable with such a law, as it will likely play out over the course of many years.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

I'm not 100% sure what the right answer is. But, I don't really believe toe-ing the middle ground (half-assed gun control in exchange for stupid laws) anymore is acceptable. If you're not going to go the way of London (which we're not) then maybe going the way of Switzerland is a better approach. Legalize guns, but require an intensive training course...not just a background check.

If you want the right to own a gun, then complete a (for example) 200 day training course over the span of 4 years. Any misuse negates your right to own a gun. Register handguns/assault rifles, but nothing else. Don't outlaw any types of guns.

FWIW, here is a summary of Switzerlands program:
In the right to bear arms debate, pro-gun Americans point to Switzerland, where almost every adult male is legally required to possess a gun. One of the few nations with a higher per capita rate of gun ownership than the United States, Switzerland has virtually no gun crime. Therefore, argue the pro-gunners, America doesn't need gun control.

Yet Handgun Control, Inc. (HCI), in its brochure "Handgun Facts," points to Switzerland as one of the advanced nations with strict handgun laws." The brochure states that all guns are registered, and handgun purchases require a background check and a permit. Gun crime in Switzerland is virtually non-existent. Therefore, concludes Handgun Control, America needs strict gun control.

..........



Today, military service for Swiss males is universal. At about age 20, every Swiss male goes through 118 consecutive days of recruit training in the Rekrutenschule. This training may be a young man's first encounter with his countrymen who speak different languages. (Switzerland has four official languages: German, French, Italian and Romansch.)

Even before required training begins, young men and women may take optional courses with the Swiss army's M57 assault rifle. They keep that gun at home for three months and receive six half-day training sessions.

From age 21 to 32, a Swiss man serves as a "frontline" troop in the Auszug, and devotes three weeks a year (in eight of the 12 years) to continued training. From age 33 to 42, he serves in the Landwehr (like America's National Guard); every few years, he reports for two-week training periods. Finally, from ages 43, to 50, he serves in the Landsturm; in this period, he only spends 13 days total in "home guard courses."

Over a soldier's career he also spends scattered days on mandatory equipment inspections and required target practice. Thus, in a 30-year mandatory military career, a Swiss man only spends about one year in direct military service. Following discharge from the regular army, men serve on reserve status until age 50 (55 for officers).
http://guncite.com/swissgun-kopel.html

I used to be anti gun control period. I've kind of softened on that stance.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by TimeForGuinness »

My high school had a rifle range in the basement.

With everything, education is key...the lack of education with guns, driving, and alcohol in this country is not only embarrassing but also deadly.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by cards2468 »

I'm on board with beerstrike.


It sort of fits in line with the way we handle driver's licenses. Any dumbass 16 year old can get one, and it's tough to lose it. An intense training program that really drives home the point to individuals that driving is a serious responsibility would completely change our society's outlook on driving.


The problem: guns and driving laws will always be left to states. Perhaps states would move towards a similar system as to what Switzerland has, but it will definitely take time. States are starting to become fairly uniform with CCW laws. If a state could prove that a system like that reduces gun related crimes and secures people's right to bare arms, it could spread.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by sighyoung »

cards2468 wrote:I'm on board with beerstrike.


It sort of fits in line with the way we handle driver's licenses. Any dumbass 16 year old can get one, and it's tough to lose it. An intense training program that really drives home the point to individuals that driving is a serious responsibility would completely change our society's outlook on driving.


The problem: guns and driving laws will always be left to states. Perhaps states would move towards a similar system as to what Switzerland has, but it will definitely take time. States are starting to become fairly uniform with CCW laws. If a state could prove that a system like that reduces gun related crimes and secures people's right to bare arms, it could spread.
I wish, but whereas most people know that driving is a privilege granted and controlled by the state, the insistence upon gun rights (rather than privileges) will likely undermine any increased state-mandated training, despite the NRA's insistence on gun training.

And let's be honest about Switzerland, too. Its military conscription policies and training really support and reflect a pretty xenophobic society.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by sighyoung »

TimeForGuinness wrote:My high school had a rifle range in the basement.

With everything, education is key...the lack of education with guns, driving, and alcohol in this country is not only embarrassing but also deadly.
What America needs is a tall, thin, likable bald priest as its rifle coach.

I remember a friend joking that if he took off his clothes and put on fur slippers, he'd look like a [expletive]. Which is exactly what America needs for firearms training.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by TimeForGuinness »

sighyoung wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:My high school had a rifle range in the basement.

With everything, education is key...the lack of education with guns, driving, and alcohol in this country is not only embarrassing but also deadly.
What America needs is a tall, thin, likable bald priest as its rifle coach.

I remember a friend joking that if he took off his clothes and put on fur slippers, he'd look like a [expletive]. Which is exactly what America needs for firearms training.
...and he remembers everyone's name and where they sat freshman year.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

sighyoung wrote:
And let's be honest about Switzerland, too. Its military conscription policies and training really support and reflect a pretty xenophobic society.
No doubt about it, but you could certainly make a case that their well-armed militia enabled them to maintain their meutrality during the 20th century.

You can likewise make the case for there being no need for it anymore.

Regardless, you've got to account for how well educated they are regarding firearms when taking into account the lack of gun violence.

Obviously America has no need for a well-armed militia to defend it against foreginers like Switzerland does.

Post Reply