When we talk the history of US infatuation with guns - the slave-holding scenario can't be dismissed.. Guns were needed to keep slaves. It was a minority of people that held slaves, but still, that was a heck of a lot of people to keep captive, and they couldn't just do it all with pitchforks and threats.Hudler wrote:The U.S. is one of only about 4 countries that was settled and became a country like it did, and the others all had a large empire backing them. You cannot compare the U.S. to South America or Europe. Large numbers of white European poor migrated here and depended on guns for protection and hunting to sustain themselves. If you lived in the backwoods of Eastern Kentucky in 1800 (like my family did) would you be there unarmed? Nowhere in Europe did they have to worry about a native population trying to slaughter them, that hadn't happened there for hundreds of years.cards2468 wrote:None of those countries earned independence the way the US did and followed on being the most powerful nation in the world. I think the level of nationalism here is much greater than other countries in the Americas and Europe. There's a different level of pride here over the concept of citizens picking up arms for national defense than other nations.G. Keenan wrote:None of this makes any sense, frankly. Many parts of the world, socialist Europe included, have long, long histories of gun ownership, gun rights, and continue to have high rates of gun ownership among their citizenry. Most of the rest of the Americas achieved independence, through wars, within 50 years of the US. Guns, militias, and frontier culture were equally important in almost all of them and in most of them gun ownership is still legal. In fact, most of their constitutions are modeled on the US constitution.cards2468 wrote:Probably because the roots of America come from militias. The constitution wrote in that people have the right to form them and people have the right to bare arms. We're a different culture than the rest of the world because our history is very different and our beginning came at a different time than any other empire.jim wrote:Where is this obsession with guns rooted? It's really odd how people think about them to me. The answers to the questions from the pro-gun people just fly in the face of logic. You get answers like "Well if that kid had a gun he wouldn't be dead", or "if everyone on that plane had a gun those terrorists wouldn't fly that plane into the building". To me those answers are so absurd I don't even know how to respond.
The problem we suffer from is this noxious idea that any restriction of gun rights is a restriction on all personal liberty and freedom. This is pumped up by a massive gun industry and lobby. Where do all the criminals get their guns, anyway? They don't make them at home. They are manufactured legally and then easily slip into criminal hands in the piss-poor regulatory and accounting environment that exists in the US.
But in the modern day world, why is it that men like Zimmerman feel compelled to arm themselves for daily life? I'm not opposed to gun ownership, but I am guessing the carrying/packin heat demographic in cities is overwhelmingly able-bodied males that don't really need protection.
