NFL 2010 Week 16

A forum for non-baseball sports
User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: NFL 2010 Week 16

Post by lukethedrifter »

Socnorb11 wrote:
Fat Strat wrote:
MrCrowesGarden wrote:There was some toolshed on ESPN Radio the other day (national program, filling in for Scott Van Pelt)... not so much dismissing the NFC West winner, but saying that the Wild Card team should be given the home game against them because they have a better record. He then cited examples about how the NBA does it, etc.

Then he railed on the NFC West as a lame conference.

Okay, fine. Except there's a distinct possibility both Wild Card winners in the AFC will have a better record than the Chiefs and the AFC South winner, but not one mention is made of it there.
I'm not going to defend anyone on talk radio, but there is a difference between an 11-5 Chiefs/10-6 Colts facing clubs with 1-2 more wins in competitive divisions than a possible 7-9 NFC west team hosting a 12 win NO team. The first of those happens almost every year. The second almost never happens.

Anyway, to me it's just like baseball. You win the division? You get rewarded, regarded of how good or bad that division is. Otherwise you might as well not even have divisions.
I'm alright with rewarding the division winners with a playoff berth, but I'm not sure they've earned a home game with a .500 record.
Actually, they did. Until they change the format.

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: NFL 2010 Week 16

Post by Fat Strat »

I'm alright with rewarding the division winners with a playoff berth, but I'm not sure they've earned a home game with a .500 record.
It happens so unfrequently that I don't think it's worth changing the system. For one season the NFC West champion didn't earn anything; I agree with that. But, record isn't the only or best indicator of how good of a team you are; we all think that Pitt and Bal are better than the Chiefs, but we'll probably finish with the same record. We had an easier division and an easier schedule. How do you determine who gets home field in that situation? ESPN's power rankings?

Anyway, there's no perfect system, but I like the current system better than re-seeding because it gives bonus points for winning the division, which should mean something.

User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: NFL 2010 Week 16

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

Fat Strat wrote:
MrCrowesGarden wrote:There was some toolshed on ESPN Radio the other day (national program, filling in for Scott Van Pelt)... not so much dismissing the NFC West winner, but saying that the Wild Card team should be given the home game against them because they have a better record. He then cited examples about how the NBA does it, etc.

Then he railed on the NFC West as a lame conference.

Okay, fine. Except there's a distinct possibility both Wild Card winners in the AFC will have a better record than the Chiefs and the AFC South winner, but not one mention is made of it there.
I'm not going to defend anyone on talk radio, but there is a difference between an 11-5 Chiefs/10-6 Colts facing clubs with 1-2 more wins in competitive divisions than a possible 7-9 NFC west team hosting a 12 win NO team. The first of those happens almost every year. The second almost never happens.

Anyway, to me it's just like baseball. You win the division? You get rewarded, regarded of how good or bad that division is. Otherwise you might as well not even have divisions.
I know one looks a lot better than the other. But, if they're going to suggest the rule, you can't start bending it because you don't like one of the division winners.

It's probably my massive inferiority complex, but I also don't recall this much backlash about an 8-8 Chargers team winning a division and making the playoffs.

User avatar
InvincibleCakeEater
GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
Posts: 28275
Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
Location: Raptured

Re: NFL 2010 Week 16

Post by InvincibleCakeEater »

If the Rams go 8-8 there won't be much complaining, it's that there is a very real possibility that a 7-9 team gets in.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: NFL 2010 Week 16

Post by lukethedrifter »

The likelihood of a bad time winning a division was increased significantly when they went to four divisions per conference. I guess we'll have to live with it since 3 per gives an uneven number (this doesn't bother MLB) and 2 makes the divisions too big.

User avatar
AdmiralKird
MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
Posts: 10179
Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
Location: Tycho Crater, Luna

Re: NFL 2010 Week 16

Post by AdmiralKird »

Okay, if a 7-9 team gets in the playoffs and faces a 11-5 team do they really need homefield advantage? If you lose to a 7-9 team with that kind of record on the road its your own fault.

Plus, probably the only thing that would even make that game worth watching is giving the 7-9 team homefield, otherwise its gonna be a blowout. People watch the playoffs for good matchups. Viewers are going to switch stations if the Saints are killing the Seahawks at home 3-37 going into the half instead of 7-17. As a journalist or commentator, you're shooting yourself in the foot if you think that the Wildcard should have homefield advantage against an inferior team; you're killing interest in the sport you're covering.

Post Reply