Swingingbunt wrote:As much as I want to give Haley credit for everything he's doing in KC...and it seems like he's doing a TON...A part of me wonders how much credit needs to go to the O and D Coordinators for everything on the field. I will say this though, Haley has done a great job changing the player culture in KC.
Haley is really [expletive] ballsy. Like 10x more ballsy than a normal head coach. It's great.
IIRC, a lot of Chiefs fans hated him last year. It's all about results. I always thought he would make a good HC even though I didn't follow the Chiefs that closely. If you're handing out credit Pioli needs to be mentioned too.
To me a head coach needs to be good at motivating players and be somebody they want to play for. Being good at Xs and Os is a bonus, but that can be handled with good coordinators. I think it's impossible to compare those coaches considering the different situations they were given, but to me Ryan, Spags and Haley definitely fit that and McDaniels doesn't. I don't really know a lot about Schwartz or Morris but they are both getting pretty good results. I know the Lions aren't winning but they aren't that far away either.
Swingingbunt wrote:As much as I want to give Haley credit for everything he's doing in KC...and it seems like he's doing a TON...A part of me wonders how much credit needs to go to the O and D Coordinators for everything on the field. I will say this though, Haley has done a great job changing the player culture in KC.
I would give a lot of credit to the coordinators for how the team has performed on the field -- but that all goes back to Haley. Haley was the guy who brought them in. There were questions in the offseason about whether or not Haley -- a young, arrogant, emotional, inexperienced guy coming off a bad season -- would be able to get 2 highly successful, highly respected, highly experienced coordinators in Weiss and Crennel to buy into this way of doing things and follow his lead. From all indications, they've bought in. And, perhaps more impressively, Haley has willingly stepped back from them and let them do their job while he focuses on head coach stuff.
I think he's the coach of the year in the NFL right now and KC is on the verge of being a dominant franchise for the forseeable future.
Swingingbunt wrote:As much as I want to give Haley credit for everything he's doing in KC...and it seems like he's doing a TON...A part of me wonders how much credit needs to go to the O and D Coordinators for everything on the field. I will say this though, Haley has done a great job changing the player culture in KC.
I would give a lot of credit to the coordinators for how the team has performed on the field -- but that all goes back to Haley. Haley was the guy who brought them in. There were questions in the offseason about whether or not Haley -- a young, arrogant, emotional, inexperienced guy coming off a bad season -- would be able to get 2 highly successful, highly respected, highly experienced coordinators in Weiss and Crennel to buy into this way of doing things and follow his lead. From all indications, they've bought in. And, perhaps more impressively, Haley has willingly stepped back from them and let them do their job while he focuses on head coach stuff.
I think he's the coach of the year in the NFL right now and KC is on the verge of being a dominant franchise for the forseeable future.
Yeah, with the type of people who coach NFL teams, it definitely is unusual to go from calling the plays on your own team to hiring a "big name" coordinator for both offense and defense. But it's paid big dividends. I don't know if they're on the verge of being a "dominant" franchise, for all they've done this year they've had a very easy schedule, and the only above .500 team they've beaten is a mediocre Jacksonville team with a QB they hired off the street. But they made big strides, and if they draft well again this year, I think you'll see them continue to progress, and that's all to Pioli and Haley's credit.
But in the bigger picture, he has made some horrible personnel decisions (letting Ron Rivera walk to give the DC job to his good friend Babich, bringing back Adam Archuleta, trying to make Hester a wideout (ie taking him off returns).
I'd give him a C.
Last time I checked, Lovie was a head coach before 2009.
cardsfansince82 wrote:
IIRC, a lot of Chiefs fans hated him last year. It's all about results. I always thought he would make a good HC even though I didn't follow the Chiefs that closely. If you're handing out credit Pioli needs to be mentioned too.
.
Most of that came from the small segment of Chiefdom that actually bought the stuff Whitlock used to write in the KC Falling Star.
Haley also benefits from the decision by the previous regime to go young. Some of those guys are a huge part of this. The coordinators are classic cases of career assistants that aren't particularly good HFC choices.
What I like about this team is that they're pretty good at avoiding stupid mistakes in win/lose game situations. They're better than the Jets and a lot of other teams on that count.
I expect the Chiefs to be a serious Super Bowl contender a year from now. One more solid off season and it happens. Add a deep threat WR that can scare d-coordinators and the offense is in business.
cardsfansince82 wrote:
IIRC, a lot of Chiefs fans hated him last year. It's all about results. I always thought he would make a good HC even though I didn't follow the Chiefs that closely. If you're handing out credit Pioli needs to be mentioned too.
.
Most of that came from the small segment of Chiefdom that actually bought the stuff Whitlock used to write in the KC Falling Star.
Haley also benefits from the decision by the previous regime to go young. Some of those guys are a huge part of this. The coordinators are classic cases of career assistants that aren't particularly good HFC choices.
What I like about this team is that they're pretty good at avoiding stupid mistakes in win/lose game situations. They're better than the Jets and a lot of other teams on that count.
I expect the Chiefs to be a serious Super Bowl contender a year from now. One more solid off season and it happens. Add a deep threat WR that can scare d-coordinators and the offense is in business.
I agree that they are benefitting from teh youth movement that started a couple of years ago. That's one thing that really hurt McDaniels in Denver. Mike Shanahan would never commit to rebuilding, but rather used a patchwork approach for about 10 years. That approach was bound to catch up with them sooner or later........ I think McDaniels just happened to be in the hot seat when it happened. I will give McDaniels credit for this - he commited to the youth movement the last 2 years. It's going to take awhile to pay off (just like with the Chiefs), but you've got to go there at some point.
Super Bowl contender for Kansas City next year? Meh...... I don't see it. They don't really have a "signature win" this year, and all of their losses have been to teams .500 or worse. They're getting better, but I think their success is a little misleading. They could take a real step forward if they win at San Diego against a desperate Charger team.
I just noticed you forgot a couple of coaches in this list. Jim Caldwell of the Colts was a first time head coach in 2009. I don't know if you count Singletary or Cable since they were interim coaches in 2008 but there were first time too.
Fat Strat wrote:
I think he's the coach of the year in the NFL right now
Spags took over a team with very little talent on it. Less than what Haley inherited when he was hired by the Chiefs.The Rams had Atogwe, Jackson and Long. That's it. If the Rams finish 8-8, Spags better win it.