AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:...or Soc, say Newton did take 200K to play for Auburn and then gets paralyzed on Saturday. What heat will there be?
Or better yet, given that scenario, would you as his father have advised him to take the money when he signed? I don't think the school, conference or NCAA has a policy to take care of a player that is crippled, literally, playing for them. If so, then I'll recant my position.
Is the rutgers guy going to be taken care of and compensated for his debilitating injury?
Nobody is twisting the arms of all of these players, forcing them to live their dream and get a full scholarship in return. All of them make that choice on their own. I don't think they need our pity.
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:...or Soc, say Newton did take 200K to play for Auburn and then gets paralyzed on Saturday. What heat will there be?
Or better yet, given that scenario, would you as his father have advised him to take the money when he signed? I don't think the school, conference or NCAA has a policy to take care of a player that is crippled, literally, playing for them. If so, then I'll recant my position.
Is the rutgers guy going to be taken care of and compensated for his debilitating injury?
Nobody is twisting the arms of all of these players, forcing them to live their dream and get a full scholarship in return. All of them make that choice on their own. I don't think they need our pity.
So, AW, I don't disagree that these guys should get compensated. To me that's another argument. But you suggesting that Cam Newton and Reggie Bush and whoever can get whatever should do so does nothing to help the 45th guy on the roster who suffers a debilitating injury.
lukethedrifter wrote:So, AW, I don't disagree that these guys should get compensated. To me that's another argument. But you suggesting that Cam Newton and Reggie Bush and whoever can get whatever should do so does nothing to help the 45th guy on the roster who suffers a debilitating injury.
And, the 45th guy on the roster isn't planning on making millions in the NFL, dodging homework assignments/learning in general because he knows that rather or not his leg falls off, he's going to have to get a job after college. So....that scholarship he's getting for his degree has a lot of value unlike it does to Reggie Bush/Cam Newton who will make their money in the NFL and won't get a degree.
lukethedrifter wrote:So, AW, I don't disagree that these guys should get compensated. To me that's another argument. But you suggesting that Cam Newton and Reggie Bush and whoever can get whatever should do so does nothing to help the 45th guy on the roster who suffers a debilitating injury.
And, the 45th guy on the roster isn't planning on making millions in the NFL, dodging homework assignments/learning in general because he knows that rather or not his leg falls off, he's going to have to get a job after college. So....that scholarship he's getting for his degree has a lot of value unlike it does to Reggie Bush/Cam Newton who will make their money in the NFL and won't get a degree.
For the NFL-caliber players, playing college football is the price that they pay for the opportunity to earn ridiculous amounts of money. If they pay the price, they earn the opportunity. If they don't pay the price, then they don't. It's just like everything else. It's no different than the 45th guy on the roster who is paying a price to earn a college degree. It's give-and-take. You give something, and you get something in return.
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:...or Soc, say Newton did take 200K to play for Auburn and then gets paralyzed on Saturday. What heat will there be?
Or better yet, given that scenario, would you as his father have advised him to take the money when he signed? I don't think the school, conference or NCAA has a policy to take care of a player that is crippled, literally, playing for them. If so, then I'll recant my position.
Is the rutgers guy going to be taken care of and compensated for his debilitating injury?
Nobody is twisting the arms of all of these players, forcing them to live their dream and get a full scholarship in return. All of them make that choice on their own. I don't think they need our pity.
That in no way answered my question(s)
The answer to your question is - I don't know if the Rutgers guy will be compensated, and as a father I most certainly would not advise my son to skirt the rules.
Socnorb11 wrote:
For the NFL-caliber players, playing college football is the price that they pay for the opportunity to earn ridiculous amounts of money.
That's a false statement. No where in the NFL rules does it state that a player must play college football to earn an opportunity to play in the NFL.
lukethedrifter wrote:
Wondering if you are okay with Newton stealing laptops and cheating on his papers- if that is what happened?
Cheating on papers, meh. Stealing laptops, absolutely not. Do you really think accepting money to play football at a University is comparable to stealing a laptop from someone?