ghostrunner wrote:If this weren't a consistent talking point among religious conservatives (that separation isn't spelled out in the amendment) I wouldn't think so. But from what I've read she's been involved in religious causes for some time, and most of those people in my experience are at least somewhat familiar with the arguments and counter-arguments. She may not know the content of the amendment, but I don't think specifically the challenge on the separation was as stupid as it was made out to be.
It sounds like she has heard the argument, but it's clear that she does not actually understand it. Which is pretty bad considering that it's not a very good argument in the first place.
Just out of curiosity, as our resident (mild) defender of Christine O'Donnell and former defender of the Palin nomination, do you really think these kinds of candidates are treated unfairly? Or more unfairly than is the norm?
ghostrunner wrote:If this weren't a consistent talking point among religious conservatives (that separation isn't spelled out in the amendment) I wouldn't think so. But from what I've read she's been involved in religious causes for some time, and most of those people in my experience are at least somewhat familiar with the arguments and counter-arguments. She may not know the content of the amendment, but I don't think specifically the challenge on the separation was as stupid as it was made out to be.
It sounds like she has heard the argument, but it's clear that she does not actually understand it. Which is pretty bad considering that it's not a very good argument in the first place.
Just out of curiosity, as our resident (mild) defender of Christine O'Donnell and former defender of the Palin nomination, do you really think these kinds of candidates are treated unfairly? Or more unfairly than is the norm?
I wouldn't say I defend either of them. I thought Palin was a smart political choice until I saw her interviewed, and then it was pretty clear she was a numbskull. And no, I don't think they're treated unfairly. I think in any cases where I have defended them, it's against a specific thing. In this case, the guffaws at her first response were lame in my opinion. I do think there's a pile-on mentality with respect to certain because at some point it becomes easy and fun to do so. But if someone wants to bluntly proclaim or denounce their incompetence, I don't have any problem with that. I have to bite my tongue any time Palin comes up with my Mom.
Is anyone else kinda creeped out by the "I'm you" ad? It isn't what she's saying, but the feigned empathy she's saying it with. She actually kinda comes across like a kindergarten teacher talking to a kid.
ghostrunner wrote:I do think the laughter was crass. Literally, she's correct that separation isn't in the amendment. I don't hear her questioning what's in the amendment as ignorance, I think she's challenging Coons on the content of it in an inartful way. The amendment states that the government can't establish or prohibit religious practice, but within that wording I think you can argue there's room to allow some co-mingling. Someone more familiar than me will have to elaborate, but I think court rulings have backed up the separation interpretation, but she's not alone in disagreeing with those decisions. Even now I'd argue there's a gray area in practice. We've continued to name a deity on our currency, which to me contradicts the concept of separation pretty clearly. I've wondered for a long time why government sticks it's nose into the "marriage" issue at all.
Personally I think the separation is essential in a free society, whether it's spelled out or not.
At one point he paraphrased the "...make no law respecting an establishment of religion" clause directly and she again asked, "That's in the first amendment?" You are giving this retard too much credit.
Maybe. If this weren't a consistent talking point among religious conservatives (that separation isn't spelled out in the amendment) I wouldn't think so. But from what I've read she's been involved in religious causes for some time, and most of those people in my experience are at least somewhat familiar with the arguments and counter-arguments. She may not know the content of the amendment, but I don't think specifically the challenge on the separation was as stupid as it was made out to be.
Coons actually said several times "Congress shall make no establishment of religion", so she's technically correct, even though I doubt that's what she's driving at. She was trying to sound smart because the phrase "separation of church and state" isn't in the Constitution. She looks particularly terrible when she said "fortunately Senators don't have to memorize the Constitution" when she didn't know the Amendments.
Unfortunately, this also means a bunch more Kristin Wiig on SNL.
I thought it was a poor ad. The first sentence out of her mouth likely launched a thousand punchlines.
I'm surprised that she didn't start with "My opponent has been lying about me . . . " or "Can you believe the silly things that Candidate X has said?"
To me, "I'm you" sounds awkward, and is clearly forced. Especially after saying "I'm not a witch," I'd like some bridge-building before she pretended to be Super Empathizer.
I wonder if the Tea party is smart enough to offer idiots like O'Donnell up to be destroyed in order to take the focus off of some of their other candidates in hopes of getting them elected with less scrutiny.
Donnie Ebert wrote:Coons actually said several times "Congress shall make no establishment of religion", so she's technically correct, even though I doubt that's what she's driving at. She was trying to sound smart because the phrase "separation of church and state" isn't in the Constitution. She looks particularly terrible when she said "fortunately Senators don't have to memorize the Constitution" when she didn't know the Amendments.
Yeah, I agree.
lukethedrifter wrote:Can't we all agree that Ms O'Donnell is a complete dolt and even the Tea Partiers have to regret getting her nominated?
"I'm just like you" sounds ok. "I'm you" just sounds weird, with the way she delivers it.
I think taking the first amendment at it's face value kinda contradicts the right's interpretation of the second ammendment, since there aren't many well-reared militias running around.
Popeye_Card wrote:"I'm just like you" sounds ok. "I'm you" just sounds weird, with the way she delivers it.
I think taking the first amendment at it's face value kinda contradicts the right's interpretation of the second ammendment, since there aren't many well-reared militias running around.