Update: Health Care Reform

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
JCShutout
MacGyver of Underwear
Posts: 13368
Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
Location: South City

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by JCShutout »

I'm very wary of any plan which forces me to participate and pay into something. I'm wondering if I'll have to be discerning civil disobedience in 2014 by not buying something. (wtf?)

On the flip side, the teabaggers complain that, among other things, this is reform and spending that the people don't want, which is why its wrong... where were they when we continued to fund wars that probably cost the same as this healthcare plan, and well over half of the country's population oppossed said wars?

User avatar
G. Keenan
Sucking on the Rally Nipple
Posts: 23719
Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by G. Keenan »

Arthur Dent wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:I have lots of experience with socialized heathcare in England.

...
Thanks for sharing. I hope everyone reads that.

I wish socialized medicine was what this bill was really about. I'd be all in favor of it. It's nuts to hears all these cries of socialism about a business friendly proposal to subsidize private health insurance. It's like people have this little model in their minds about what they assume is happening and they proceed to argue about this model without ever noticing that it has nothing to do with what is actually going on.
Thanks.

It's funny that in all the rhetoric about socialism the bill's opponents don't see what a huge victory it is for the private sector. It's the exact opposite of socialized medicine. As a proponent of socialized medicine I wish it were true that this bill was a trojan horse for phasing it in but, unfortunately, it isn't. A certain degree of paranoia aside, the neo-feudalism article I came across as a result of the fact sheet you posted in the other thread makes me very sad for what this whole process says about how thoroughly corporate influence is taking over the legislative process and the possibility for irrevocably entrenching private insurance as middle class Americans' sole access to healthcare going forward. We better hope all this free-market mumbo jumbo about exchanges and competition pays off.

tscards
Veteran Player
Posts: 1233
Joined: April 20 06, 6:28 pm
Location: Sioux Falls, SD

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by tscards »

So will people just pay fines & drop their healthcare for fines that are cheaper and then just buy insurance when they need to? :?

In all seriousness, though, what infuriates me about this whole thing is that ZERO republicans voted for it, and nearly all democrats did. I'd feel better if there was some compromise. Yes, both parties are at fault. It should not take "side deals" to get something this important signed. I don't like the "I won't vote for it unless you do this for me" attitude in our political system. Likely will be a lot of congress members from both parties that lose their jobs in the fall -- but will that fix this division in congress? Probably not......I'd be better not worrying about it and just go on with my fairly normal american life.

User avatar
Radbird
There's someone in my head but it's not me
Posts: 62390
Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by Radbird »

G. Keenan wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:I have lots of experience with socialized heathcare in England.

...
Thanks for sharing. I hope everyone reads that.

I wish socialized medicine was what this bill was really about. I'd be all in favor of it. It's nuts to hears all these cries of socialism about a business friendly proposal to subsidize private health insurance. It's like people have this little model in their minds about what they assume is happening and they proceed to argue about this model without ever noticing that it has nothing to do with what is actually going on.
Thanks.

It's funny that in all the rhetoric about socialism the bill's opponents don't see what a huge victory it is for the private sector. It's the exact opposite of socialized medicine. As a proponent of socialized medicine I wish it were true that this bill was a trojan horse for phasing it in but, unfortunately, it isn't. A certain degree of paranoia aside, the neo-feudalism article I came across as a result of the fact sheet you posted in the other thread makes me very sad for what this whole process says about how thoroughly corporate influence is taking over the legislative process and the possibility for irrevocably entrenching private insurance as middle class Americans' sole access to healthcare going forward. We better hope all this free-market mumbo jumbo about exchanges and competition pays off.
Just read your story, Geen. Can't see what would be wrong with having a system like the UK. When my daughter was doing her semester abroad in London back in 2007, one of her classmates stumbled out of a pub and in his ale-induced stupor decided it would be a good idea to climb over a wrought-iron fence to play frisbee in a field on the other side. When he didn't quite make it over and gored himself, he was rushed to the emergency room and spent time in the hospital. They did a first class job of treating his injuries and fixing him up, and he paid nothing. Nada. I was amazed, but in reading your story it sounds like that is par for the course over there.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by lukethedrifter »

tscards wrote:So will people just pay fines & drop their healthcare for fines that are cheaper and then just buy insurance when they need to? :?

In all seriousness, though, what infuriates me about this whole thing is that ZERO republicans voted for it, and nearly all democrats did. I'd feel better if there was some compromise. Yes, both parties are at fault. It should not take "side deals" to get something this important signed. I don't like the "I won't vote for it unless you do this for me" attitude in our political system. Likely will be a lot of congress members from both parties that lose their jobs in the fall -- but will that fix this division in congress? Probably not......I'd be better not worrying about it and just go on with my fairly normal american life.
How do you buy insurance when you need to? I'm interested to see if you will be allowed to simply buy catastrophic coverage. I assume so.

ZERO Repubs voted for it because it would have been political suicide.

User avatar
JackofDiamonds
Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
Posts: 15010
Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by JackofDiamonds »

JCShutout wrote:I'm very wary of any plan which forces me to participate and pay into something. I'm wondering if I'll have to be discerning civil disobedience in 2014 by not buying something. (wtf?)
Do you have a car? Do you have car insurance?
tscards wrote: In all seriousness, though, what infuriates me about this whole thing is that ZERO republicans voted for it, and nearly all democrats did.
Have you followed congressional voting at all since Obama won? Seriously, any at all? I don't mean to be so confrontational, but this has been the story for every single democratic bill since 2008. There hasn't been a chance for bipartisanship.

User avatar
G. Keenan
Sucking on the Rally Nipple
Posts: 23719
Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by G. Keenan »

tscards wrote:So will people just pay fines & drop their healthcare for fines that are cheaper and then just buy insurance when they need to? :?

In all seriousness, though, what infuriates me about this whole thing is that ZERO republicans voted for it, and nearly all democrats did. I'd feel better if there was some compromise. Yes, both parties are at fault. It should not take "side deals" to get something this important signed. I don't like the "I won't vote for it unless you do this for me" attitude in our political system. Likely will be a lot of congress members from both parties that lose their jobs in the fall -- but will that fix this division in congress? Probably not......I'd be better not worrying about it and just go on with my fairly normal american life.
Most of the big legislation in this country's history has been passed along similar lines as this. This is nothing new. Don't kid yourself into thinking there was some golden age of political cooperation from which we've departed.

And even though not a single Republican voted for this there can be no mistaking that this bill is the result of HUGE compromises granted to the right. What began as proposals for a single payer system or for publicly run insurance companies that could compete with private ones ended up as handing taxpayer subsidies to private corporations. The Republicans did not oppose this bill for ideological reasons; they opposed it in order to deal Obama a huge political setback.

If you are happy with your current insurance there is little to dislike about this bill. To top it off, it offers significant deficit reductions, which is what the republicans we're clamoring about the whole time but ignoring in lieu of painting the bill as a govt. takeover of a private sector, which it OBVIOUSLY, seriously, obviously, is not. It's a freakin' insurance industry boondoggle predicated on a belief in the efficiency of market forces. How can it get more Republican than that? Throw in further restrictions on women's reproductive rights, that's how, which they did.

User avatar
Hudler
All-Star
Posts: 2293
Joined: September 13 06, 12:02 am
Location: Fulton,MO

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by Hudler »

G. Keenan wrote:
tscards wrote:So will people just pay fines & drop their healthcare for fines that are cheaper and then just buy insurance when they need to? :?

In all seriousness, though, what infuriates me about this whole thing is that ZERO republicans voted for it, and nearly all democrats did. I'd feel better if there was some compromise. Yes, both parties are at fault. It should not take "side deals" to get something this important signed. I don't like the "I won't vote for it unless you do this for me" attitude in our political system. Likely will be a lot of congress members from both parties that lose their jobs in the fall -- but will that fix this division in congress? Probably not......I'd be better not worrying about it and just go on with my fairly normal american life.
Most of the big legislation in this country's history has been passed along similar lines as this. This is nothing new. Don't kid yourself into thinking there was some golden age of political cooperation from which we've departed.

And even though not a single Republican voted for this there can be no mistaking that this bill is the result of HUGE compromises granted to the right. What began as proposals for a single payer system or for publicly run insurance companies that could compete with private ones ended up as handing taxpayer subsidies to private corporations. The Republicans did not oppose this bill for ideological reasons; they opposed it in order to deal Obama a huge political setback.

If you are happy with your current insurance there is little to dislike about this bill. To top it off, it offers significant deficit reductions, which is what the republicans we're clamoring about the whole time but ignoring in lieu of painting the bill as a govt. takeover of a private sector, which it OBVIOUSLY, seriously, obviously, is not. It's a freakin' insurance industry boondoggle predicated on a belief in the efficiency of market forces. How can it get more Republican than that? Throw in further restrictions on women's reproductive rights, that's how, which they did.
If this reduces the deficit I'll run naked through Busch Stadium. Anyone who actually believes the government can pass something this huge AND bring it to us at the price they told us it would is probably in the market for beach-front property in Arizona.

tscards
Veteran Player
Posts: 1233
Joined: April 20 06, 6:28 pm
Location: Sioux Falls, SD

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by tscards »

JackofDiamonds wrote:
tscards wrote: In all seriousness, though, what infuriates me about this whole thing is that ZERO republicans voted for it, and nearly all democrats did.
Have you followed congressional voting at all since Obama won? Seriously, any at all? I don't mean to be so confrontational, but this has been the story for every single democratic bill since 2008. There hasn't been a chance for bipartisanship.
Pattern? Yes.

Who's fault is it? Each side says the other & nobody is right. I said before that both parties are at fault. This is a huge bill. Really wish they would all get their act together. Some dems voted against this (including a rep from SD), wondering why they would vote against their party when everything (no exceptions) is either all Left or all Right. I'd like to think that if this was handled differently, some from both sides would agree....but that's silly thinking!

GRB should run Congress!!!

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by ghostrunner »

Hudler wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:
tscards wrote:So will people just pay fines & drop their healthcare for fines that are cheaper and then just buy insurance when they need to? :?

In all seriousness, though, what infuriates me about this whole thing is that ZERO republicans voted for it, and nearly all democrats did. I'd feel better if there was some compromise. Yes, both parties are at fault. It should not take "side deals" to get something this important signed. I don't like the "I won't vote for it unless you do this for me" attitude in our political system. Likely will be a lot of congress members from both parties that lose their jobs in the fall -- but will that fix this division in congress? Probably not......I'd be better not worrying about it and just go on with my fairly normal american life.
Most of the big legislation in this country's history has been passed along similar lines as this. This is nothing new. Don't kid yourself into thinking there was some golden age of political cooperation from which we've departed.

And even though not a single Republican voted for this there can be no mistaking that this bill is the result of HUGE compromises granted to the right. What began as proposals for a single payer system or for publicly run insurance companies that could compete with private ones ended up as handing taxpayer subsidies to private corporations. The Republicans did not oppose this bill for ideological reasons; they opposed it in order to deal Obama a huge political setback.

If you are happy with your current insurance there is little to dislike about this bill. To top it off, it offers significant deficit reductions, which is what the republicans we're clamoring about the whole time but ignoring in lieu of painting the bill as a govt. takeover of a private sector, which it OBVIOUSLY, seriously, obviously, is not. It's a freakin' insurance industry boondoggle predicated on a belief in the efficiency of market forces. How can it get more Republican than that? Throw in further restrictions on women's reproductive rights, that's how, which they did.
If this reduces the deficit I'll run naked through Busch Stadium. Anyone who actually believes the government can pass something this huge AND bring it to us at the price they told us it would is probably in the market for beach-front property in Arizona.
The legislation is huge because it has to be. But the government is not going to be significantly enlarged because of it.

Post Reply