Update: Health Care Reform

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
letsgocards89
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3654
Joined: April 17 06, 7:35 pm
Location: Too close for missiles, switching to guns

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by letsgocards89 »

Joe Shlabotnik wrote:
clevername wrote:the wait times thing kills me.

the long wait times at your PCP's office were coming anyway, if they haven't arrived already.

edit: I should add that I have no idea whether the new legislation will have any real effect on wait times.
Only an anecdote but here in North Alabama where Blue Cross covers 95% of the people (that number was quoted to me - probably not that high but it seems to be what everyone I know of with employer health care has), we can't find a physician to take us - all full. So its off to the Doc in the Box when we're sick where wait times are worse then we've ever experienced in other states (oregon, idaho, texas).

Right here. Right now. In the heart of Red America where the they are disgusted by socialized medicine. I don't know, 95% seems like it might as well be government run to me...

My wife called her doctor today at 8am and was seen by the doc at 11am. I do not know if the difference in times is insurance based or just a higher ratio of doctors to patients.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by cpebbles »

I didn't get into this business to see patients, I got into it to score chicks, and "doctor" sounds better to women than "physician assistant."

Honestly, the only advice I can give you is 5 years old, but an anesthesiologist once told me the health profession that's best-rewarded for the amount of headache is CRNA (Nurse anesthetist). It appears to be more training than a PA, but they get paid roughly twice as well (As well as primary care physicians). I actually decided not to go into anesthesiology because I think CRNAs are going to take over the field almost entirely, so job security is quite good.

User avatar
clevername
Bringer of FRBG
Posts: 10380
Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
Location: Alabama

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by clevername »

cpebbles wrote:I didn't get into this business to see patients, I got into it to score chicks, and "doctor" sounds better to women than "physician assistant."

Honestly, the only advice I can give you is 5 years old, but an anesthesiologist once told me the health profession that's best-rewarded for the amount of headache is CRNA (Nurse anesthetist). It appears to be more training than a PA, but they get paid roughly twice as well (As well as primary care physicians). I actually decided not to go into anesthesiology because I think CRNAs are going to take over the field almost entirely, so job security is quite good.
that was the other thing that came to mind. These folks have it made right now. They can make more than a primary care doc.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by Arthur Dent »

tscards wrote:And the CBO's analysis is based on 10 yrs of revenues and 6 years of actual expenses. What happens when we have 10 years of revenues and 10 years of expenses? Medicare was supposed to be a low cost program and we're continually trying to find ways to fund it. I do hope I'm wrong, though....nobody really knows for sure, but this makes me nervous.
The deficit is measured for single years. It is completely irrelevant to the deficit estimate 10 years out that the major changes don't go into effect until 2014.

User avatar
G. Keenan
Sucking on the Rally Nipple
Posts: 23719
Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by G. Keenan »

tscards wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:It's strange because of all the people I know and have met from countries with nationalized healthcare, none of them describe the horrors that I hear described on my television and on the internet.
They're just used to it & don't know any other way. Or, all you've met have all been perfectly healthy & have very very few dr. visits.

Just kidding!! Hope we have no horrors.
I have lots of experience with socialized heathcare in England. My father is English and half my extended family lives there. On family vacations there I remember being shocked when I needed an occasional prescription and it was free because I was a student even though I wasn't a UK citizen. If I hadn't been a student they would have cost about $15-$20, no matter what they were. When my step-mom, an American, was living there a few years ago all her prescriptions were free because she was over 60 years old.

But the most impressive aspect of the system was seeing, first-hand, how it took care of my grandmother as she aged. FREE: all her prescriptions, all doctor visits, two hip-replacement surgeries, including rehab and physical therapy, two eye surgeries. No wait times for the hip surgeries, maybe a month wait for the eye surgery, which was elective. When she was diagnosed with terminal pancreatic cancer at age 88 she spent a few weeks in the hospital before going home to die in peace. She could have opted for treatment and received it immediately but didn't want it. Her doctor came to her house every couple of days to check on her, talk to her, adjust her medicines as necessary. A registered nurse came twice a day to do whatever she needed and a nigh nurse came every night and stayed until the day nurse came in the morning.

Because of all this her quality of life in her "golden years" was excellent and she got to die without pain and with grace and dignity in her own home, well cared for and surrounded by her family.

By contrast when my mother, an American, got leukemia here in the USA it was an insurance nightmare. She had HMO (GHP) health insurance through her employer, Washington University, and was getting treatment at Barnes Hospital in StL, one of the best in the country. The insurance company refused to pay for a bone-marrow transplant, the procedure that the doctors thought was the best chance of saving her life. My father had to threaten to sue the insurance company, which probably would have done nothing. Ultimately, the only reason GHP finally authorized treatment was my dad wrote a letter to Senator Danforth, Wash U board of trustee and board member on the very same insurance company, who had it in his heart to pull strings and get the company to pay for the treatment. Unfortunately for her and my family the cancer was too far advanced by that point. Her doctors were some of the best in the country on the cutting edge of bone marrow transplantation in 1995. They fought the insurance company just has hard as my dad just to be able to do their own jobs.

I bet you anything that most Americans fighting against this bill not only have no experience with socialized medicine but have never been seriously ill themselves. My family paid premiums to this company for 20 years only to have it fight us when it came time to pay up with no way to hold them accountable. If it hadn't been for a purely fortuitous connection to a freakin' former Senator who happened to be on the company board she would have had no chance. This is the system people are afraid of changing.

tscards
Veteran Player
Posts: 1233
Joined: April 20 06, 6:28 pm
Location: Sioux Falls, SD

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by tscards »

lukethedrifter wrote:
tscards wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:
tscards wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:It's strange because of all the people I know and have met from countries with nationalized healthcare, none of them describe the horrors that I hear described on my television and on the internet.
They're just used to it & don't know any other way. Or, all you've met have all been perfectly healthy & have very very few dr. visits.

Just kidding!! Hope we have no horrors.

I do have personal experience with people calling 911 in order to get a ride to the hospital because they can't get a doctor's appt for 5 weeks. That's in the United States of America. I do have experience with people calling 911 to go to the ER for the same thing they went to the ER for three days ago because they couldn't afford to get their prescriptions filled. I do have experience with people who call 911 because they have several different docs prescribing several different pharmaceuticals for the same thing.
We're very lucky where we live right now -- our town has awesome hospitals and the wait times are fanastically low! I know if we went through all of the breast cancer treatments in a large city (ie - chicago where we used to live), we'd have a lot of wait times. Right now we can get appts very quickly.

But, that aside, I wouldn't expect all of those experiences mentioned to just simply go away with th. We've all had our experiences and nobody knows what they will be like in 15 years or so. Different?? Same???
I don't expect those things to go away immediately or at all either. The point is that this stuff exists here and I am sick of the stupid phony arguments against change. Make your case but enough with the lies. To be clear I'm not talking to any poster but to the Greater Opposition.



Dealing with insurance is but a small piece of the puzzle. There's a whole lot more wrong with the health of Americans and the burden it places on our society. But guess what? Sick people are the new Manufacturing of our economy so it probably ain't going away til the economy crashes.
I understand, but will not sit here and pretend to be happy about this. I am not happy that this was pushed through with side deals in order to "get" a vote. Yes, that is politics unfortunately, though. I am skeptical that this is going to create a great future because what we have now is broken. Yes, to some is is broken. To me personally, it works good, and maybe that's why I'm more skeptical. I do wish this could have been a bill agreed to by both sides. It 'seems' to be very one sided with 100% of one side voting against it.

I wouldn't call everything here 'lies'. They are opinions - from both sides. Nobody can predict with certainty what will happen. Arguments for benefits from the left are based on what they see - from the right based on what they see. If this had been all Right-sided, I guarantee people would be against it as well.

I do hope this works out as well as it is being heradled as!

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by haltz »

so I have to pay several grand a year for health care or face tax penalties? I'm very uninformed here but that's the gist I'm getting from a couple of links.

User avatar
G. Keenan
Sucking on the Rally Nipple
Posts: 23719
Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by G. Keenan »

haltz wrote:so I have to pay several grand a year for health care or face tax penalties? I'm very uninformed here but that's the gist I'm getting from a coupe of links.
Starting in 2014 you will have to either have employer provided insurance or buy it from an insurance company of your choice on an exchange set up by your state. Depending on the plan you buy it could be thousands, could be less. If your annual income is less than $88,000 you will be eligible for a federal subsidy to help pay those premiums.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by Arthur Dent »

letsgocards89 wrote:Our taxes will go up. Less of my money in my pocket does not make me happy. It's not a back-breaker but when is enough, enough?
Which taxes do you expect to go up?
letsgocards89 wrote:The cost of insurance will go up, and possibly skyrocket. The insurance companies will build the inherant risk of no lifetime caps and having to provide coverage for preexisting conditions into my premiums. Some of the cost might be absorbed by my employer, but certainly not all. I fully expect a LOT of people to pay the no-insurance fines and purchase insurance after sickness or injuries.
It is highly unlikely that insurance prices will skyrocket. With regard to pre-existing conditions, insurers already cover these in group/employer-based health insurance. Eliminating lifetime maximums may increase premiums somewhat but "skyrocket" would be a huge exaggeration. In any case, lifetime maximums make no sense on humanitarians grounds and should be scrapped. In the market for individually purchased insurance, requiring companies to cover pre-existing conditions would certainly raise premiums expect for the fact that everyone will now be required to be an insurance customer greatly improving the risk pool. Unless you believe people with pre-existing conditions ought to be denied care, there is really no justification for this practice anyway. The flip side of covering pre-existing conditions is that people must be required to pay when they are healthy. Remember, no matter the insurance system, the whole point is to create a mechanism whereby the healthy pay for the sick. Too often, this is forgotten by people who want to use a totally individualist framework. This framework just doesn't apply here.
letsgocards89 wrote:I expect my quality of care to decrease and my wait times to increase. According to the New England Journal of Medicine, 33% of doctors polled claimed they would quit the industry if this bill passed. Other countries, and even Massachssetts, have had patient wait times increase substantially.
I'm not aware of any aspect of this bill that would justify 33% of doctors quitting. Maybe you know one? It sounds to me like a bunch of nervous doctors worried that their privileges will be upset. If anything, the bill will deliver many new paying customers to the industry. See e.g. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/22/busin ... ealth.html

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Tea Bag Loonies

Post by ghostrunner »

haltz wrote:so I have to pay several grand a year for health care or face tax penalties? I'm very uninformed here but that's the gist I'm getting from a coupe of links.
It depends on your income.

This is a pretty good breakdown of some of the basics:

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2010 ... ation.html

See the "subsidies for individuals" tab on the left.

Post Reply