College football player and NFL player are two different jobs. Success on one level is not necessarily predicted by success on the prior level.ghostrunner wrote:Explain to me, as a relative football rube, how this works. If this guy is so untalented, how did he win the Heisman and come close to winning twice? Seems like either people's criteria for Heisman awards is completely off (i.e. - if his throw is so bad, how is he in the running?), or he's better than people here seem to think.
Tebow's NFL career
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Tebow's NFL career
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: Tebow's NFL career
Others can explain it better than I can, but I'll take a quick stab at it.ghostrunner wrote:Explain to me, as a relative football rube, how this works. If this guy is so untalented, how did he win the Heisman and come close to winning twice? Seems like either people's criteria for Heisman awards is completely off (i.e. - if his throw is so bad, how is he in the running?), or he's better than people here seem to think.
Certain offensive styles that work in college won't work in the NFL because NFL defenses are too athletic and talented. Florida's offense was made for a big, dopey quick guy like Tebow. It was the perfect marriage of Florida's spread offense and Tebow's talents. In the NFL, where every millisecond counts, things like a throwing motion that's slightly off or shorter QB's will lead to serious trouble. In college, even if that was ever an issue (and no college defense would be talented enough to ever make it that much of an issue), he had the escapability to make plays on his own.
In short, I wouldn't say that he's untalented. I'd say that his talents aren't suited for the NFL, and certainly not for an NFL QB.
- omaha_red
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12963
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
- Location: toning it done
Re: Tebow's NFL career
ghostrunner wrote:Explain to me, as a relative football rube, how this works. If this guy is so untalented, how did he win the Heisman and come close to winning twice? Seems like either people's criteria for Heisman awards is completely off (i.e. - if his throw is so bad, how is he in the running?), or he's better than people here seem to think.



- Hungary Jack
- Mother Earth
- Posts: 19536
- Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
- Location: In Cognito
Re: Tebow's NFL career
Quarterback Heisman winners--and there have been lots--are often miscast as future NFL stars, or at least good players. This long list includes names like Danny Wuerrfel, Chris Weinke, Gino Torretta (!), Andre Ware, Jason White, and so on.
The NFL game is so much faster, the openings much tighter, the pass lanes close much faster, the defenders taller, the defenses more varied and disguised, and the offenses more complex such that excelling as a QB in college is really no predictor of NFL success. It is a terribly tough position to evaluate, and the college adoption of the spread offense has made it easier for players like Timmy Chang and Case Keenum to amass gaudy stats that make them look better than they are.
The NFL game is so much faster, the openings much tighter, the pass lanes close much faster, the defenders taller, the defenses more varied and disguised, and the offenses more complex such that excelling as a QB in college is really no predictor of NFL success. It is a terribly tough position to evaluate, and the college adoption of the spread offense has made it easier for players like Timmy Chang and Case Keenum to amass gaudy stats that make them look better than they are.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Tebow's NFL career
I would disagree with the bolded part of your statement. Of those you listed, none were loved by scouts as NFL talent. Well, maybe a few like Ware.Hungary Jack wrote:Quarterback Heisman winners--and there have been lots--are often miscast as future NFL stars, or at least good players. This long list includes names like Danny Wuerrfel, Chris Weinke, Gino Torretta (!), Andre Ware, Jason White, and so on.
The NFL game is so much faster, the openings much tighter, the pass lanes close much faster, the defenders taller, the defenses more varied and disguised, and the offenses more complex such that excelling as a QB in college is really no predictor of NFL success. It is a terribly tough position to evaluate, and the college adoption of the spread offense has made it easier for players like Timmy Chang and Case Keenum to amass gaudy stats that make them look better than they are.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Tebow's NFL career
I concur with what's said. the big difference is the defenses at the NFL are much better than college. (bigger faster stronger) Thus NFL requires different skills. Think about highlight reels of college games -all the long runs where the defense looks sillly and like boys against men.
If a QB is a running QB, eventually NFL D's will close down this aspect of their game and force them to be a passing QB, thereby exposing a guy like Tebow's weakness.
Running QB's can have short term success in the NFL -Vick and Culpepper. Its possible Tebow could succeed for a short while as a QB. but probably not. In Culpeppers case, he had fabulous WR that helped him out, and opened up the scramble. But eventually the wear and tear got to him. Now Culpepper without his ability to run is a bad QB.
If a QB is a running QB, eventually NFL D's will close down this aspect of their game and force them to be a passing QB, thereby exposing a guy like Tebow's weakness.
Running QB's can have short term success in the NFL -Vick and Culpepper. Its possible Tebow could succeed for a short while as a QB. but probably not. In Culpeppers case, he had fabulous WR that helped him out, and opened up the scramble. But eventually the wear and tear got to him. Now Culpepper without his ability to run is a bad QB.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: Tebow's NFL career
Freed Roger wrote:I concur with what's said. the big difference is the defenses at the NFL are much better than college. (bigger faster stronger) Thus NFL requires different skills. Think about highlight reels of college games -all the long runs where the defense looks sillly and like boys against men.
If a QB is a running QB, eventually NFL D's will close down this aspect of their game and force them to be a passing QB, thereby exposing a guy like Tebow's weakness.
Running QB's can have short term success in the NFL -Vick and Culpepper. Its possible Tebow could succeed for a short while as a QB. but probably not. In Culpeppers case, he had fabulous WR that helped him out, and opened up the scramble. But eventually the wear and tear got to him. Now Culpepper without his ability to run is a bad QB.

- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Tebow's NFL career
Archie Griffin is a good example of this phenomenon.
The only 2 time Heisman Trophy winner, he was drafted 24th in the first round by the Bengals and had a decent career. Drafted ahead of him were 5 running backs; Chuck Muncie, Joe Washington, Mike Pruitt, Bubba Bean and Lawrence Gaines. His teammate both at OSU and on the Bengals Pete Johnson had a more productive pro career.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1976_NFL_Draft
The only 2 time Heisman Trophy winner, he was drafted 24th in the first round by the Bengals and had a decent career. Drafted ahead of him were 5 running backs; Chuck Muncie, Joe Washington, Mike Pruitt, Bubba Bean and Lawrence Gaines. His teammate both at OSU and on the Bengals Pete Johnson had a more productive pro career.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1976_NFL_Draft
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30874
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Tebow's NFL career
Thanks to those who explained what exactly is different. I don't really watch college ball much, so the pros are my only frame of reference.
Seems like Heisman voting is a little flawed, then. I'd think voters would recognize when a guy like Tebow is benefitting from a system or situation.
Seems like Heisman voting is a little flawed, then. I'd think voters would recognize when a guy like Tebow is benefitting from a system or situation.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Tebow's NFL career
The Heisman system is flawed but not for the reason you give. It is ostensibly given to the most outstanding player in college football, not the best pro prospect.ghostrunner wrote:Thanks to those who explained what exactly is different. I don't really watch college ball much, so the pros are my only frame of reference.
Seems like Heisman voting is a little flawed, then. I'd think voters would recognize when a guy like Tebow is benefitting from a system or situation.
What is flawed is that is has typically been given to the Best Player at a High Profile Position on One of the Best College Football Teams in America not the actual Most Outstanding Player.


