BCS in the news
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: BCS in the news
I think I enjoy the annual BCS discussion on GRB more than I enjoy the Christmas season. They both come at the same time of year.
/not being facetious or a wiseass
/not being facetious or a wiseass
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: BCS in the news
I don't think I put everyone is lay, wouldn't that term in and of itself take out anyone who does understand it isn't so easy as putting the little guy in?clevername wrote:is it really more arrogant than insinuating we're all "lay" persons who don't understand the competitive structure of major division I college football? edit: well, the arrogant post got removed.
back to the discussion, the scheduling of regular season OOC games against these mid majors is a 2 way street. Things have changed since FSU and UM were willing to go anywhere and play anybody back in the 80's. Teams were willing to take the chance back then, now they aren't. And part of that is due to the current BCS system we have in place penalizing teams for losing tough regular season games. I don't know that it would change a whole lot, even if we moved to an 8 team playoff because you still wouldn't want to chance more than 1 loss in a season for fear of falling out of that 8 team window, especially with 6 of those spots going to conference champions some of which may actually have worse records/rankings than your team.
A 16 team playoff gets all the conf champs in while leaving room for those 1-2 loss teams that probably deserve a spot over even some of the conference champions and could allow some teams to take a chance on a tougher OOC game to help prepare their team for playoff intensity.
It isn't an easy fix, either way. All I'm saying is that I wouldn't be feeling too sorry for Boise this year. They got in the BCS. This is honestly a landmark year for the BCS, as they let in TWO non-BCS teams for the first time.
Am I really going off the grid so much in saying I think the teams from the non-BCS conference should have to do more than the ones from the BCS conference? My response was in reference to a discussion about a proposed 8 team playoff that would allow two non-BCS teams in, and no non-conference champs from the BCS. I just don't agree with that decision or setup at all.
- clevername
- Bringer of FRBG
- Posts: 10380
- Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
- Location: Alabama
Re: BCS in the news
I don't agree with that, either, which is part of the basis for my 16 team playoff reasoning.phinstd wrote:I don't think I put everyone is lay, wouldn't that term in and of itself take out anyone who does understand it isn't so easy as putting the little guy in?clevername wrote:is it really more arrogant than insinuating we're all "lay" persons who don't understand the competitive structure of major division I college football? edit: well, the arrogant post got removed.
back to the discussion, the scheduling of regular season OOC games against these mid majors is a 2 way street. Things have changed since FSU and UM were willing to go anywhere and play anybody back in the 80's. Teams were willing to take the chance back then, now they aren't. And part of that is due to the current BCS system we have in place penalizing teams for losing tough regular season games. I don't know that it would change a whole lot, even if we moved to an 8 team playoff because you still wouldn't want to chance more than 1 loss in a season for fear of falling out of that 8 team window, especially with 6 of those spots going to conference champions some of which may actually have worse records/rankings than your team.
A 16 team playoff gets all the conf champs in while leaving room for those 1-2 loss teams that probably deserve a spot over even some of the conference champions and could allow some teams to take a chance on a tougher OOC game to help prepare their team for playoff intensity.
It isn't an easy fix, either way. All I'm saying is that I wouldn't be feeling too sorry for Boise this year. They got in the BCS. This is honestly a landmark year for the BCS, as they let in TWO non-BCS teams for the first time.
Am I really going off the grid so much in saying I think the teams from the non-BCS conference should have to do more than the ones from the BCS conference? My response was in reference to a discussion about a proposed 8 team playoff that would allow two non-BCS teams in, and no non-conference champs from the BCS. I just don't agree with that decision or setup at all.
But, what more can teams like Boise do in a year when they went undefeated? If bigger teams won't schedule them and they're stuck with the preconception that they're inferior, then even undefeated seasons aren't worthy for consideration for a national championship? That seems completely broken to me.
- Radio_Bugtussle
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3450
- Joined: July 26 06, 9:51 am
- Location: Searching for the perfect microbrew
Re: BCS in the news
Shouldn't that be in blue font?phinstd wrote:. Boise should certainly be playing in the title game over Texas.
And not from the discolored playing field up there in the north...
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: BCS in the news
What would you do differently though? If it's a 16 team playoff, you don't have this problem as much for sure.
This discussion, which has escalated more than intended, was about an 8 team playoff. If we went 8 teams this year, you'd have a great discussion for boise over Florida, and I'm sure I'd live with it if Boise got in since they're undefeated, and the SEC hasn't been as great as advertised this year. I've noticed we all have tendency to read a little what we think, rather than what is there. I responded to a post advocating an 8 team playoff that allowed only the 6 conference champs, and two from non-BCS conferences as at-large teams. I'm strongly against that. This isn't about making it more fair for the little guy. It's about settling a national championship on the field.
If we're going to do an 8 team playoff, it has to include only the 8 best teams. However it is decided to determine that. Boise is getting a lot of great thigns for their program, and they've earned them. I just don't see what they would have to gripe about this year. Should they be in the title game over Texas? Over TCU, a team that has unequivocally had a better season? Over Cinnci?
It's been a weird year. A great year honestly...but Boise should be happy with what they have right now. The winner of that game probably finishes #2 in the entire country. Can you believe that? It's been since BYU hasn't it, that a non-BCS team finished higher?
This discussion, which has escalated more than intended, was about an 8 team playoff. If we went 8 teams this year, you'd have a great discussion for boise over Florida, and I'm sure I'd live with it if Boise got in since they're undefeated, and the SEC hasn't been as great as advertised this year. I've noticed we all have tendency to read a little what we think, rather than what is there. I responded to a post advocating an 8 team playoff that allowed only the 6 conference champs, and two from non-BCS conferences as at-large teams. I'm strongly against that. This isn't about making it more fair for the little guy. It's about settling a national championship on the field.
If we're going to do an 8 team playoff, it has to include only the 8 best teams. However it is decided to determine that. Boise is getting a lot of great thigns for their program, and they've earned them. I just don't see what they would have to gripe about this year. Should they be in the title game over Texas? Over TCU, a team that has unequivocally had a better season? Over Cinnci?
It's been a weird year. A great year honestly...but Boise should be happy with what they have right now. The winner of that game probably finishes #2 in the entire country. Can you believe that? It's been since BYU hasn't it, that a non-BCS team finished higher?
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: BCS in the news
Yeah, I figured the context showed I was being sarcastic...I'm not a regular user of the blue font.Radio_Bugtussle wrote:Shouldn't that be in blue font?phinstd wrote:. Boise should certainly be playing in the title game over Texas.![]()
And not from the discolored playing field up there in the north...
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: BCS in the news
I think their are two parallel themes here. One is about football and whether life is fair or not. The other is whether what the BCS and the NCAA do is actually legal or should be considered legal given the financial ramifications of the current system.
- slide_into_first
- is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
- Posts: 14433
- Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
- Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos
- InvincibleCakeEater
- GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
- Posts: 28275
- Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
- Location: Raptured
Re: BCS in the news
This Montana v Appalachian St. playoff game is awesome.
- InvincibleCakeEater
- GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
- Posts: 28275
- Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
- Location: Raptured
Re: BCS in the news
24-17 Montana
APP ST 1st and goal with 6 seconds left
and it's a snow game
This game is great.
APP ST 1st and goal with 6 seconds left
and it's a snow game
This game is great.





