BCS in the news
- clevername
- Bringer of FRBG
- Posts: 10380
- Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
- Location: Alabama
Re: BCS in the news
that would be fine if the big boys would schedule those teams, but they won't schedule them because they don't want to be the ones to lose to them. They'd rather schedule La Tech and have a guaranteed win and home game money.
I don't think that it's the mid majors avoiding the big conferences, it's the other way around. How are they supposed to "prove" they deserve it?
I don't think that it's the mid majors avoiding the big conferences, it's the other way around. How are they supposed to "prove" they deserve it?
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: BCS in the news
You go to their place...if you don't beat anybody, you don't deserve to be in. Fair or not, I'm just not able to accept it as equal footing.clevername wrote:that would be fine if the big boys would schedule those teams, but they won't schedule them because they don't want to be the ones to lose to them. They'd rather schedule La Tech and have a guaranteed win and home game money.
I don't think that it's the mid majors avoiding the big conferences, it's the other way around. How are they supposed to "prove" they deserve it?
I'm on a losing end of a battle when it comes to lay fans over this issue, I get that, but it just isn't the same in football to be playing Tulsa on the road, than an SEC/ACC/Big10/Pac10 schedule. You get millions in a nice little bowl, what more do you want?
- clevername
- Bringer of FRBG
- Posts: 10380
- Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
- Location: Alabama
Re: BCS in the news
no, it's not that these teams are asking the big boys to come to them for road games. I don't think the big boys are even entertaining home only's against them.
Of course I realize it's not the same to play against Tulsa as, say, Ole Miss. That really has nothing to do with whether or not these guys have a chance to prove themselves against the major conferences, especially given the fact that the few times it's happened recently the smaller schools have held their ground and won their share, even beating Oklahoma and Alabama. If they were matching up against major conference teams in bowl games and getting pasted it would be a different story...but they aren't.
Of course I realize it's not the same to play against Tulsa as, say, Ole Miss. That really has nothing to do with whether or not these guys have a chance to prove themselves against the major conferences, especially given the fact that the few times it's happened recently the smaller schools have held their ground and won their share, even beating Oklahoma and Alabama. If they were matching up against major conference teams in bowl games and getting pasted it would be a different story...but they aren't.
- Cheddar Tom
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5885
- Joined: May 13 09, 2:55 pm
Re: BCS in the news
the florida, bama, texas, oklahomas of the world, etc. wouldn't dare invite boise or tcu to their place. florida barely schedules fbs teams.
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: BCS in the news
You can't honestly believe Alabama gave two turds about that game last year after the disappointment of losing in the SEC championship game. It's just not the same...Utah wanted that game, and good for them for getting it, but it just isn't the same once you know you don't have a shot at the title anymore.clevername wrote:no, it's not that these teams are asking the big boys to come to them for road games. I don't think the big boys are even entertaining home only's against them.
Of course I realize it's not the same to play against Tulsa as, say, Ole Miss. That really has nothing to do with whether or not these guys have a chance to prove themselves against the major conferences, especially given the fact that the few times it's happened recently the smaller schools have held their ground and won their share, even beating Oklahoma and Alabama. If they were matching up against major conference teams in bowl games and getting pasted it would be a different story...but they aren't.
They get millions of dollars to play in a bowl game, is that not enough? I'm definitely with Colin Cowherd on this one, let big boy football teams play for the big boy title. In years they prove it (like TCU has done), then they can have a shot. Otherwise, take your millions and your #2 ranking, and be ecstatic with it.
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: BCS in the news
Yet, Oklahoma scheduled a neutral site game with BYU just this year (and lost). Miami plays everyone, and will go to their place. Lots of teams give these guys a chance, they just have to want to. When you're Boise St. you have to beat Oregon, play at anyone who will have you in your non-con. Much like Florida takes a break in their non-con, Boise gets to take a break in their conference.Cheddar Tom wrote:the florida, bama, texas, oklahomas of the world, etc. wouldn't dare invite boise or tcu to their place. florida barely schedules fbs teams.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: BCS in the news
There's not a chance in hell you'd be saying that if a) you hadn't adopted Miami as your college football team of choice and b) Missouri State built their program up to the level of Boise St.phinstd wrote:You can't honestly believe Alabama gave two turds about that game last year after the disappointment of losing in the SEC championship game. It's just not the same...Utah wanted that game, and good for them for getting it, but it just isn't the same once you know you don't have a shot at the title anymore.clevername wrote:no, it's not that these teams are asking the big boys to come to them for road games. I don't think the big boys are even entertaining home only's against them.
Of course I realize it's not the same to play against Tulsa as, say, Ole Miss. That really has nothing to do with whether or not these guys have a chance to prove themselves against the major conferences, especially given the fact that the few times it's happened recently the smaller schools have held their ground and won their share, even beating Oklahoma and Alabama. If they were matching up against major conference teams in bowl games and getting pasted it would be a different story...but they aren't.
They get millions of dollars to play in a bowl game, is that not enough? I'm definitely with Colin Cowherd on this one, let big boy football teams play for the big boy title. In years they prove it (like TCU has done), then they can have a shot. Otherwise, take your millions and your #2 ranking, and be ecstatic with it.
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: BCS in the news
Yes, Lukethefudging drifter knows me better than I know myself. Boise should certainly be playing in the title game over Texas.lukethedrifter wrote:There's not a chance in hell you'd be saying that if a) you hadn't adopted Miami as your college football team of choice and b) Missouri State built their program up to the level of Boise St.phinstd wrote:You can't honestly believe Alabama gave two turds about that game last year after the disappointment of losing in the SEC championship game. It's just not the same...Utah wanted that game, and good for them for getting it, but it just isn't the same once you know you don't have a shot at the title anymore.clevername wrote:no, it's not that these teams are asking the big boys to come to them for road games. I don't think the big boys are even entertaining home only's against them.
Of course I realize it's not the same to play against Tulsa as, say, Ole Miss. That really has nothing to do with whether or not these guys have a chance to prove themselves against the major conferences, especially given the fact that the few times it's happened recently the smaller schools have held their ground and won their share, even beating Oklahoma and Alabama. If they were matching up against major conference teams in bowl games and getting pasted it would be a different story...but they aren't.
They get millions of dollars to play in a bowl game, is that not enough? I'm definitely with Colin Cowherd on this one, let big boy football teams play for the big boy title. In years they prove it (like TCU has done), then they can have a shot. Otherwise, take your millions and your #2 ranking, and be ecstatic with it.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: BCS in the news
Sometimes a bit of perspective is helpful.phinstd wrote:Yes, Lukethefudging drifter knows me better than I know myself. Boise should certainly be playing in the title game over Texas.lukethedrifter wrote:There's not a chance in hell you'd be saying that if a) you hadn't adopted Miami as your college football team of choice and b) Missouri State built their program up to the level of Boise St.phinstd wrote:You can't honestly believe Alabama gave two turds about that game last year after the disappointment of losing in the SEC championship game. It's just not the same...Utah wanted that game, and good for them for getting it, but it just isn't the same once you know you don't have a shot at the title anymore.clevername wrote:no, it's not that these teams are asking the big boys to come to them for road games. I don't think the big boys are even entertaining home only's against them.
Of course I realize it's not the same to play against Tulsa as, say, Ole Miss. That really has nothing to do with whether or not these guys have a chance to prove themselves against the major conferences, especially given the fact that the few times it's happened recently the smaller schools have held their ground and won their share, even beating Oklahoma and Alabama. If they were matching up against major conference teams in bowl games and getting pasted it would be a different story...but they aren't.
They get millions of dollars to play in a bowl game, is that not enough? I'm definitely with Colin Cowherd on this one, let big boy football teams play for the big boy title. In years they prove it (like TCU has done), then they can have a shot. Otherwise, take your millions and your #2 ranking, and be ecstatic with it.
EDITED to come across as less of a prick
Last edited by lukethedrifter on December 10 09, 10:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
- clevername
- Bringer of FRBG
- Posts: 10380
- Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
- Location: Alabama
Re: BCS in the news
is it really more arrogant than insinuating we're all "lay" persons who don't understand the competitive structure of major division I college football? edit: well, the arrogant post got removed.
back to the discussion, the scheduling of regular season OOC games against these mid majors is a 2 way street. Things have changed since FSU and UM were willing to go anywhere and play anybody back in the 80's. Teams were willing to take the chance back then, now they aren't. And part of that is due to the current BCS system we have in place penalizing teams for losing tough regular season games. I don't know that it would change a whole lot, even if we moved to an 8 team playoff because you still wouldn't want to chance more than 1 loss in a season for fear of falling out of that 8 team window, especially with 6 of those spots going to conference champions some of which may actually have worse records/rankings than your team.
A 16 team playoff gets all the conf champs in while leaving room for those 1-2 loss teams that probably deserve a spot over even some of the conference champions and could allow some teams to take a chance on a tougher OOC game to help prepare their team for playoff intensity.
back to the discussion, the scheduling of regular season OOC games against these mid majors is a 2 way street. Things have changed since FSU and UM were willing to go anywhere and play anybody back in the 80's. Teams were willing to take the chance back then, now they aren't. And part of that is due to the current BCS system we have in place penalizing teams for losing tough regular season games. I don't know that it would change a whole lot, even if we moved to an 8 team playoff because you still wouldn't want to chance more than 1 loss in a season for fear of falling out of that 8 team window, especially with 6 of those spots going to conference champions some of which may actually have worse records/rankings than your team.
A 16 team playoff gets all the conf champs in while leaving room for those 1-2 loss teams that probably deserve a spot over even some of the conference champions and could allow some teams to take a chance on a tougher OOC game to help prepare their team for playoff intensity.


