Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

A forum for non-baseball sports
User avatar
Dillagii
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7926
Joined: April 18 06, 2:37 pm

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Dillagii »

phinstd wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:
phinstd wrote:
Faceman wrote:For Phinstd - I realize Miami seems to be relevant again, but they aren't elite either.
This is also hilarious to me. It's a complete and total assumption, and really I can't think of a reason for the assumption other than to get under my skin, to even infer. Oh, Phinstd is a fan of Miami, and since he thinks another team isn't good, that OBVIOUSLY means he thinks Miami is elite. Let's make a statement that makes us feel better...I've got it! I'll make some sort of comment about Miami, even though we aren't talking about Miami, and he hasn't brought them up. That will show him!

Quick! Tell me how the Dolphins aren't winning the AFC East as well. That'll show me real well just how good Iowa is!!!!!
Out of curiosity, what is your beef with the Iowa Hawkeyes? Granted, they're not flashy and they almost certainly won't win a national championship. But they're a hard-working group of kids (not the most talented, by your own admission) with a coach that gets the most out of them. And they've beat every opponent that they've faced for a year and a half........ including some pretty good ones (Penn State twice, Wisconsin, Michigan, South Carolina). As already noted, they're normally successful when facing major programs from other conferences in bowl games. It may not be the type of football that you enjoy, but you have to admit that it's been effective for them.
I don't have beef with Iowa per se, I have a beef with people thinking they're really good. I definitely have a beef with people thinking they're a team that should play for the national title if they win out. If Alabama loses the SEC championship to Florida, I would definitely still take them to play for the title over Iowa, and vice versa. I'd take a one loss USC team over them. An undefeated Boise St. over them.

Iowa just happens to be the flag bearing program for the Big 10 at the moment...
Admit it. You think Miami is the best football team in the whole world and every other team sucks. We get it.

/blue font

Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Faceman »

JL21 wrote:
Faceman wrote:You are all of a sudden bashing anything and everything Big 10 - for what? You have run socnorb into the ground. You saying this isn't based on the fact that for once the U doesn't completely suck anymore?
Where are you getting that? I think that's a ridiculous inference. "The only reason anyone could have for bashing the Big Ten is because their own team is doing really well". I find the notion that Iowa is elite to be laughable as well. Very good? Sure. Deserve their ranking? Yeah, I suppose, but only by default. If they continue to win games by their butt hair, then I'll eat crow and say they belong.

I think if you look at the long, long, long history of phins' posts both here and at CT before here, he's one of the most rational people in the Cardinals Forumsphere.
I didn't say, or infer the bolded.

I stepped in to defend the Big 10, and I mentioned that Miami isn't elite. If Phinstd can rag the Big 10 to shreds (as he has in many posts), why can't I say Miami isn't elite, regardless of Phinstd's motivation? It's not like I went on an attack.

My point is that there is the top of the SEC, and USC, and maybe OK or Texas. That is pretty much the top tier every year. Trying to say that the Big 10 is so far behind everything else (including Miami) is laughable.
phinstd wrote:USC goes up to Midwest teams and beats them at their place every year. Miami used to go to Notre Dame and Penn St. all the time, and beat them at their places. Before they got tired of getting beat of course...

The talent is not debateable, if you're using any metric other than your heart to judge. If you can't win with a spread style of offense, reliant on speed, then why would Michigan hire a coach to bring exactly that style of play to their school? Because they got tired of getting beat by that style...though Michigan did beat Florida with Chad Henne a few years back in a bowl game.

Is this really a debate? That Big 10 football can't compete on a national level? Perhaps I'm naive, but I didn't really think anyone actually truly believed it could. Nor that anyone outside of the fan base's of those schools wanted to watch them try...

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by cardsfansince82 »

They can call themselves whatever they want as long as they keep churning out hot women.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by phins »

Faceman wrote:
phinstd wrote:
Faceman wrote:For Phinstd - I realize Miami seems to be relevant again, but they aren't elite either.
This is also hilarious to me. It's a complete and total assumption, and really I can't think of a reason for the assumption other than to get under my skin, to even infer. Oh, Phinstd is a fan of Miami, and since he thinks another team isn't good, that OBVIOUSLY means he thinks Miami is elite. Let's make a statement that makes us feel better...I've got it! I'll make some sort of comment about Miami, even though we aren't talking about Miami, and he hasn't brought them up. That will show him!

Quick! Tell me how the Dolphins aren't winning the AFC East as well. That'll show me real well just how good Iowa is!!!!!
Yeah, that's exactly what I'm doing. :shock: I couldn't care less about Miami, but you are pretty clearly grinding an axe here. I didn't say Miami sucked, or that they are laughable.
phinstd wrote: In my opinion, they're nowhere near elite, and it made me chuckle literally out loud to read someone who thinks they are.
What else have you done in this thread? You are all of a sudden bashing anything and everything Big 10 - for what? You have run socnorb into the ground. You saying this isn't based on the fact that for once the U doesn't completely suck anymore?

Iowa is undefeated in a BCS conference. That is why they are rated where they are. That is not different this year. I hate Iowa but based on the system, they are aptly ranked.
I don't get it...because I personally, and this is simply and only my opinion on the matter, they aren't an elite team, it is because Miami is pretty good?

Perhaps I came on too strong in all of this...I have a lot of fun chatting about college football, and I honestly and truly respect the heck of Kirk Ferentz.

As far as Miami, I tend to go the opposite direction if anything. I'm always nervous when they play, they can ruin my day with a loss (as crazy as that is for me to allow to happen, I know). Miami is not an elite team, and if you watched them play UCF, you'd agree. My thinking Iowa isn't a national title contender has to do with my personal observation of the team in watching them play. Nothing less, nothing more.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by phins »

cardsfansince82 wrote:Iowa beat Northern Iowa by one point. Northern Iowa beat SMS by 28 points. SMS would lose to Iowa by 29 points.

IN YO FACE
Oh man...Northern Iowa could have beaten us by 70 bazillion if they'd had wanted to. We're very lucky our coach used to coach there, and they felt sorry for us. They basically moved out of the way and let us a score a TD with like 8 seconds left in that game.

/Painful memories.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by phins »

Faceman wrote:
JL21 wrote:
Faceman wrote:You are all of a sudden bashing anything and everything Big 10 - for what? You have run socnorb into the ground. You saying this isn't based on the fact that for once the U doesn't completely suck anymore?
Where are you getting that? I think that's a ridiculous inference. "The only reason anyone could have for bashing the Big Ten is because their own team is doing really well". I find the notion that Iowa is elite to be laughable as well. Very good? Sure. Deserve their ranking? Yeah, I suppose, but only by default. If they continue to win games by their butt hair, then I'll eat crow and say they belong.

I think if you look at the long, long, long history of phins' posts both here and at CT before here, he's one of the most rational people in the Cardinals Forumsphere.
I didn't say, or infer the bolded.

I stepped in to defend the Big 10, and I mentioned that Miami isn't elite. If Phinstd can rag the Big 10 to shreds (as he has in many posts), why can't I say Miami isn't elite, regardless of Phinstd's motivation? It's not like I went on an attack.

My point is that there is the top of the SEC, and USC, and maybe OK or Texas. That is pretty much the top tier every year. Trying to say that the Big 10 is so far behind everything else (including Miami) is laughable.
phinstd wrote:USC goes up to Midwest teams and beats them at their place every year. Miami used to go to Notre Dame and Penn St. all the time, and beat them at their places. Before they got tired of getting beat of course...

The talent is not debateable, if you're using any metric other than your heart to judge. If you can't win with a spread style of offense, reliant on speed, then why would Michigan hire a coach to bring exactly that style of play to their school? Because they got tired of getting beat by that style...though Michigan did beat Florida with Chad Henne a few years back in a bowl game.

Is this really a debate? That Big 10 football can't compete on a national level? Perhaps I'm naive, but I didn't really think anyone actually truly believed it could. Nor that anyone outside of the fan base's of those schools wanted to watch them try...
I get it...Miami isn't quite back to the big boy table...

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by cardsfansince82 »

The gap between the SEC and every other conference is as big as its ever been this year. Beyond that you have Texas, USC (and OU if they were at full strength) and a bunch of nerds fighting in the parking lot to borrow from JL.

Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Faceman »

phinstd wrote:
I don't have beef with Iowa per se, I have a beef with people thinking they're really good. I definitely have a beef with people thinking they're a team that should play for the national title if they win out. If Alabama loses the SEC championship to Florida, I would definitely still take them to play for the title over Iowa, and vice versa. I'd take a one loss USC team over them. An undefeated Boise St. over them.

Iowa just happens to be the flag bearing program for the Big 10 at the moment...
Then your beef will be with the system. If Iowa goes undefeated they will more than likely be 1 or 2 at the end of the year. The way it works, they should go to the championship game.

And yet it's still possible they don't. Was it 2006 when Michigan was still #2 after losing at OSU by 4? Then, in the very last poll (as the Big 10 finishes earlier), the pollsters decided they didn't want the rematch, and moved Florida ahead of Michigan. So it's no lock.

It doesn't matter anyway, because Iowa will likely lose at OSU and Texas will probably go undefeated.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by phins »

cardsfansince82 wrote:The gap between the SEC and every other conference is as big as its ever been this year. Beyond that you have Texas, USC (and OU if they were at full strength) and a bunch of nerds fighting in the parking lot to borrow from JL.
Man it really grinds my gears how good the SEC is. I want to watch Urban Meyer lose so badly it stings...you have to give it to them though. That conference is good, and Florida and Alabama are operating at another level both on the field, and in recruiting.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by phins »

Faceman wrote:
phinstd wrote:
I don't have beef with Iowa per se, I have a beef with people thinking they're really good. I definitely have a beef with people thinking they're a team that should play for the national title if they win out. If Alabama loses the SEC championship to Florida, I would definitely still take them to play for the title over Iowa, and vice versa. I'd take a one loss USC team over them. An undefeated Boise St. over them.

Iowa just happens to be the flag bearing program for the Big 10 at the moment...
Then your beef will be with the system. If Iowa goes undefeated they will more than likely be 1 or 2 at the end of the year. The way it works, they should go to the championship game.

And yet it's still possible they don't. Was it 2006 when Michigan was still #2 after losing at OSU by 4? Then, in the very last poll (as the Big 10 finishes earlier), the pollsters decided they didn't want the rematch, and moved Florida ahead of Michigan. So it's no lock.

It doesn't matter anyway, because Iowa will likely lose at OSU and Texas will probably go undefeated.
Iowa has every chance in the world to stick my nose in everything I've said (written). All they have to do is win their games and they get that chance...if they do, I'll be here to eat my crow, humble pie, and Hawkeye stew. It wouldn't taste very good either...my wife is from Iowa, and would probably be there spoon feeding me.

Post Reply