pujols005 wrote:I don't really watch Big Ten games, unless Indiana is playing, because they are simply too boring to watch. The best games like Ohio State vs. Michigan are no longer exciting and the Michigan vs. Michigan State games are getting more boring every year.
This is beyond silly--you didn't think the Michigan-MSU game this year wasnt' exciting?
Or the Purdue-Northwestern game?
Or the Iowa/Penn State game?
Faceman wrote:Have you ever been to the game? I guarantee the Mizzou players feel more at home there. It's not 50/50 - not even close.
You have 4 (used to be 3) non conference games in football. That's it. I knew basketball would get brought up. Apples and oranges. We are talking about football which generates much more $$ than basketball, per game. You can't afford to give those games away every year at Illinois. Maybe Mizzou can, I don't know.
The football games in the 80's were home and homes - and they played 3 times. Guenther said in his statement they'd bring it back here and there, either in STL or home and home. Getting a home game vs Mizzou is much different than a neutral site game.
The busch braggin rights game has been played every year since 1980 (except 1982). Apples and oranges.
I love the football game myself - and I love it in St. Louis. It's like a early bowl game. But I understand the reasons behind not doing in every single year. Very few non-con rivalries get played every year in football. Not enough games.
I like having good non conference competition. This year, Illinois still gets to play at Cincinnati and Fresno State at home. You can save the non-conference lecture. If you start the year with the game at STL, where is the confidence boosting game? Looks like Purdue plays some layups before they go to Notre Dame. Give me a break.
It will go away for a few years, then they'll bring it back. It's not a big deal. Look at the history - they've played 20 times (before the current 4 year agreement).
Whatever works for you guys, but it sounds pretty defeatist to me....
The only reason the hoops game became the special event it is, was because both schools committed to it--I really don't see why that same attitude can't apply to football....
Cupcake nonconference games are a fact of life, but that does not make them suck any less.
FWIW I will stack the quality of Purdue's noncon schedules over the years up against anybody's, but that isn't the issue here.
Again, it's a shame that what could someday be a cool tradition is ending, apparently in order to "dumb down" UI's schedule....
I personally hate it when top-tier schools play pansy schedules. I understand the economic reasons for it (both for the school that travels to the slaughter and the importance of the favored school gaining bowl eligibility), but it makes for crappy football, IMO.
My Cats are as a guilty of a weak non-conf schedule as any. They won a few games, but it certainly doesn't make them better. I respect Illinois for playing Mizzou, Cincy and Fresno State this year, because they are far bolder than most in terms of this year's non-conf schedule. I don't like Notre Dame, but I do respect them for the schedule they play every year.
phinstd wrote:Ehhh...my dog was that I think Iowa is above suckitude, but certainly not anywhere near a team that should be playing for the national title.
The Big 10 bores me, but they deserve their title winner to get sacrificed as much as anyone I suppose.
I guess you missed my list of recent bowl results for Iowa. They've fare well against the likes of Florida, LSU, and Texas. They may not be as good as Alabama, Florida or Texas, but they're just as good as anyone else. If they win out, there's not a single reason why they don't deserve national championship consideration.
So.....don't you think FL, AL and TX if they win out (and obviously FL and AL both can't) deserve to go to the NC before IA? Since you just said they weren't as good. Not trying to be a smart ass here, just pointing out what I thought you said.
phinstd wrote:Ehhh...my dog was that I think Iowa is above suckitude, but certainly not anywhere near a team that should be playing for the national title.
The Big 10 bores me, but they deserve their title winner to get sacrificed as much as anyone I suppose.
I guess you missed my list of recent bowl results for Iowa. They've fare well against the likes of Florida, LSU, and Texas. They may not be as good as Alabama, Florida or Texas, but they're just as good as anyone else. If they win out, there's not a single reason why they don't deserve national championship consideration.
So.....don't you think FL, AL and TX if they win out (and obviously FL and AL both can't) deserve to go to the NC before IA? Since you just said they weren't as good. Not trying to be a smart ass here, just pointing out what I thought you said.
Don't put me in the position of defending spornoc, please. Iowa, based on how this [expletive] has worked for years, deserves to be a Top 10 team. If they win out then they should be in the mix for a BCS game.
phinstd wrote:Ehhh...my dog was that I think Iowa is above suckitude, but certainly not anywhere near a team that should be playing for the national title.
The Big 10 bores me, but they deserve their title winner to get sacrificed as much as anyone I suppose.
I guess you missed my list of recent bowl results for Iowa. They've fare well against the likes of Florida, LSU, and Texas. They may not be as good as Alabama, Florida or Texas, but they're just as good as anyone else. If they win out, there's not a single reason why they don't deserve national championship consideration.
So.....don't you think FL, AL and TX if they win out (and obviously FL and AL both can't) deserve to go to the NC before IA? Since you just said they weren't as good. Not trying to be a smart ass here, just pointing out what I thought you said.
If all of those teams won out, then Iowa would have to be out of the picture. I understand that. It would be unfortunate, but I don't think Iowa should play for a national championship if that happened.
phinstd wrote:Ehhh...my dog was that I think Iowa is above suckitude, but certainly not anywhere near a team that should be playing for the national title.
The Big 10 bores me, but they deserve their title winner to get sacrificed as much as anyone I suppose.
I guess you missed my list of recent bowl results for Iowa. They've fare well against the likes of Florida, LSU, and Texas. They may not be as good as Alabama, Florida or Texas, but they're just as good as anyone else. If they win out, there's not a single reason why they don't deserve national championship consideration.
Iowa deserves a ton of credit for being able to put an elite football team together. It's easy to convince kids to go to school in California or Florida. Try convincing an elite football player to spend his time in Iowa City. It's not easy. In that regard, what they're accomplishing is even more impressive than the top 4 or 5 teams in the country.
In my opinion, they're nowhere near elite, and it made me chuckle literally out loud to read someone who thinks they are.
They'll get their chance to prove otherwise, and then you can chuckle at me.
Is fooling themselves. Once you get past the top 4 or so, you could draw names out of a hat.
For Phinstd - I realize Miami seems to be relevant again, but they aren't elite either.
The Big 10 is just like everyone else. They compete fine against everyone but the very elite. They will almost always lose to the top SEC team, and USC (but so does everyone else - Oklahoma last year for example).
But in the other Big 10 / SEC matchups, the Big 10 does just fine. The ACC, Big East, and Pac 10 have no room to criticize. It's SEC, then everyone else.
PurdueSTL wrote:
Whatever works for you guys, but it sounds pretty defeatist to me....
The only reason the hoops game became the special event it is, was because both schools committed to it--I really don't see why that same attitude can't apply to football....
Cupcake nonconference games are a fact of life, but that does not make them suck any less.
FWIW I will stack the quality of Purdue's noncon schedules over the years up against anybody's, but that isn't the issue here.
Again, it's a shame that what could someday be a cool tradition is ending, apparently in order to "dumb down" UI's schedule....
You aren't getting it - but one last try. This tradition isn't "ending". They are taking a break from the border war in St. Louis for a number of reasons, and not any of them are to "dumb down" a schedule. It's never been a Purdue / ND type of thing. Illinois and Mizzou are like 6 hours apart - not the 90 minutes or whatever it is from PU to ND. It's a different deal than basketball, period.
Now please, let's focus on Purdue not running up the score on Illinois this weekend. Thanks.