Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31100
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
What I'm saying is that while USC has beaten the Big Ten like a rented mule recently, the location and coditions of the game clearly favor USC. Yes it is a neutral field, but everything about the location favors SC.
Sothern teams get to play their bowl games in their home conditions. The Big Ten (among others) do not. It isn't nearly everything, but it is a factor. "The Big Ten can't handle speed!" Sure. The SEC probably can't play very well in the cold and wind either. They just don't get placed in those conditions every January to expose it.
I would expect Iowa or Penn State or OSU to get blown out in the Rose Bowl against USC this year, if it happens. I just think the game would be much closer, possibly with a different outcome if they played the game in, say, Cleveland in November.
Sothern teams get to play their bowl games in their home conditions. The Big Ten (among others) do not. It isn't nearly everything, but it is a factor. "The Big Ten can't handle speed!" Sure. The SEC probably can't play very well in the cold and wind either. They just don't get placed in those conditions every January to expose it.
I would expect Iowa or Penn State or OSU to get blown out in the Rose Bowl against USC this year, if it happens. I just think the game would be much closer, possibly with a different outcome if they played the game in, say, Cleveland in November.
- PurdueSTL
- Veteran Player
- Posts: 770
- Joined: June 15 06, 8:36 am
- Location: Originally: LA (lower Alton); Now: along the Potomac
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
-It's an absolutely natural match-up--They're border rivals; plenty of IL residents attend(ed) Mizzou and vice versa;Faceman wrote:Why should Illinois be signing up to play Mizzou every year?
-They regularly go head-to-head for recruits;
-They're roughly at the same level in the football pecking order in their respective conferences
wow- thank goodness Mizzou doesn't take that attitude about the Braggin' Rights basketball gameFaceman wrote:I like the game too but it's never been an annual deal. I will not mind taking some time away from it while Illinois licks wounds.
Like they don't already have "confidence-boosting" games??Faceman wrote:Just because it's "close" to a home game doesn't make it a home game. They need 7 home games per year, at least. Guenther isn't a scheduling guru anyway (see @ Cincy and home for Fresno State to end this year)....And they need to start out with some confidence boosting games - not a bowl game atmosphere that is every year more of a home game for Mizzou than Illinois. It might as well be an away game.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31100
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
Also phin, I'm focusing on USC and the Rose Bowl because the Big Ten is 0-5 vs. USC (0-4 in the Rose Bowl), and 8-6 vs. everyone else in BCS bowls. So they're doing OK outside of facing SC.
FWIW, the ACC is 2-9 in BCS bowls.
FWIW, the ACC is 2-9 in BCS bowls.
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
I guess I don't really understand what you're trying to say. The Big 10 is built to play brusing, smashmouth football. I can buy that. It makes sense to say that a team playing half their games in the snow is built that way. But, it just doesn't seem that way. A team with a brusing O-line would be able to dominate the line of scrimmage and run the ball and dominate the clock. If they could do this, they wouldn't allow the opposing passing attack to control the game.Popeye_Card wrote:I never claimed that they are bigger. They just play differently. They're used to run blocking, and aren't well prepared for speed pass rushers.
I would have to look at individual games, but if memory serves, Big Ten teams typically give up points early in the air, then have to switch their gameplan to passing to play catch-up. You don't notice the speed disparity as much when they're in a game situation where they are able to dictate the game and run the ball.
As for why they get down, see my comments regarding pass coverage. Big Ten DB's usually don't see many deep patterns because you don't pass deep in Big Ten country conditions late in the season. Seeing it on video during prep is one thing. Doing it against big, fast receivers from USC in the Rose Bowl is a different situation.
Regarding the DB excuse. I don't really buy that. A guy can cover someone or he can't. A lot of B10 DB's simply can't cover USC or top-tier receivers. Not many college DB's are going to be able
to.
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
Popeye, first, I'm glad we're able to disagree so strongly, and still have an intelligent conversation about it.Popeye_Card wrote:Also phin, I'm focusing on USC and the Rose Bowl because the Big Ten is 0-5 vs. USC (0-4 in the Rose Bowl), and 8-6 vs. everyone else in BCS bowls. So they're doing OK outside of facing SC.
FWIW, the ACC is 2-9 in BCS bowls.
The ACC is no great shakes either...the Big 10 just bores the hell out of me, and this all started with Iowa in partiular. Penn St. probably finishes as the third or fourth best ACC team. Iowa, to me, is no different than say, NC St.
Ferentz is such a great coach he overcomes the complete lack of athleticism they have.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31100
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
I make no claims that any Big Ten team is very good this year. Sure, Penn State could be 4th best in the ACC, but they could end up 4th in the Big Ten too. Not a great team or teams in either conference.
Mostly, I'm jst defensive over the whole "Big Ten is overrated they don't belong in BCS bowls" thing. They deserve to be there as much as anyone. SEC and USC are a step above the past few seasons. Sadly, they get to be spanked by USC in the Rose Bowl each season. My contention is if somebody else was playing USC, and/or the Big Ten got to play Kansas or Georgia or VT, maybe we wouldn't hear the same complaints. Oklahoma has been beaten handily in the title game 3 times. Maybe it is just the people I hear from, but I don't hear the same cries about them being overrated every year.
Mostly, I'm jst defensive over the whole "Big Ten is overrated they don't belong in BCS bowls" thing. They deserve to be there as much as anyone. SEC and USC are a step above the past few seasons. Sadly, they get to be spanked by USC in the Rose Bowl each season. My contention is if somebody else was playing USC, and/or the Big Ten got to play Kansas or Georgia or VT, maybe we wouldn't hear the same complaints. Oklahoma has been beaten handily in the title game 3 times. Maybe it is just the people I hear from, but I don't hear the same cries about them being overrated every year.
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
Ehhh...my dog was that I think Iowa is above suckitude, but certainly not anywhere near a team that should be playing for the national title.
The Big 10 bores me, but they deserve their title winner to get sacrificed as much as anyone I suppose.
The Big 10 bores me, but they deserve their title winner to get sacrificed as much as anyone I suppose.
-
Faceman
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 4800
- Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
- Location: Memphis, TN
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
Have you ever been to the game? I guarantee the Mizzou players feel more at home there. It's not 50/50 - not even close.
You have 4 (used to be 3) non conference games in football. That's it. I knew basketball would get brought up. Apples and oranges. We are talking about football which generates much more $$ than basketball, per game. You can't afford to give those games away every year at Illinois. Maybe Mizzou can, I don't know.
The football games in the 80's were home and homes - and they played 3 times. Guenther said in his statement they'd bring it back here and there, either in STL or home and home. Getting a home game vs Mizzou is much different than a neutral site game.
The busch braggin rights game has been played every year since 1980 (except 1982). Apples and oranges.
I love the football game myself - and I love it in St. Louis. It's like a early bowl game. But I understand the reasons behind not doing in every single year. Very few non-con rivalries get played every year in football. Not enough games.
I like having good non conference competition. This year, Illinois still gets to play at Cincinnati and Fresno State at home. You can save the non-conference lecture. If you start the year with the game at STL, where is the confidence boosting game? Looks like Purdue plays some layups before they go to Notre Dame. Give me a break.
It will go away for a few years, then they'll bring it back. It's not a big deal. Look at the history - they've played 20 times (before the current 4 year agreement).
http://www.stlsports.org/MizzouIllini/background.php
You have 4 (used to be 3) non conference games in football. That's it. I knew basketball would get brought up. Apples and oranges. We are talking about football which generates much more $$ than basketball, per game. You can't afford to give those games away every year at Illinois. Maybe Mizzou can, I don't know.
The football games in the 80's were home and homes - and they played 3 times. Guenther said in his statement they'd bring it back here and there, either in STL or home and home. Getting a home game vs Mizzou is much different than a neutral site game.
The busch braggin rights game has been played every year since 1980 (except 1982). Apples and oranges.
I love the football game myself - and I love it in St. Louis. It's like a early bowl game. But I understand the reasons behind not doing in every single year. Very few non-con rivalries get played every year in football. Not enough games.
I like having good non conference competition. This year, Illinois still gets to play at Cincinnati and Fresno State at home. You can save the non-conference lecture. If you start the year with the game at STL, where is the confidence boosting game? Looks like Purdue plays some layups before they go to Notre Dame. Give me a break.
It will go away for a few years, then they'll bring it back. It's not a big deal. Look at the history - they've played 20 times (before the current 4 year agreement).
http://www.stlsports.org/MizzouIllini/background.php
PurdueSTL wrote:-It's an absolutely natural match-up--They're border rivals; plenty of IL residents attend(ed) Mizzou and vice versa;Faceman wrote:Why should Illinois be signing up to play Mizzou every year?
-They regularly go head-to-head for recruits;
-They're roughly at the same level in the football pecking order in their respective conferences
wow- thank goodness Mizzou doesn't take that attitude about the Braggin' Rights basketball gameFaceman wrote:I like the game too but it's never been an annual deal. I will not mind taking some time away from it while Illinois licks wounds.I know UM and UI played a few times back in the 80s, and my alum friends from both schools loved it; in an age where everyone fattens up on lower-tier schools, it's refreshing and right for teams to schedule legitimate preconference competition whenever possible-- besides, it's not like the Illlini have a probable unbeaten season to "preserve" every year--it's a good measuring stick for both programs....
Like they don't already have "confidence-boosting" games??Faceman wrote:Just because it's "close" to a home game doesn't make it a home game. They need 7 home games per year, at least. Guenther isn't a scheduling guru anyway (see @ Cincy and home for Fresno State to end this year)....And they need to start out with some confidence boosting games - not a bowl game atmosphere that is every year more of a home game for Mizzou than Illinois. It might as well be an away game.From what I've seen and read, Illinois represents at these games every bit as much as Mizzou. It's HUGE to the legions of Illini fans in central and southern Illinois. I would think the Illinois AD and Illini fans would relish the opportunity to nurture a unique neutral-site tradition in a great atmosphere, and take it to a roughly equal program in a neighboring rival state, but apparently that's too tall an order; that's a shame....
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21913
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
phinstd wrote:Ehhh...my dog was that I think Iowa is above suckitude, but certainly not anywhere near a team that should be playing for the national title.
The Big 10 bores me, but they deserve their title winner to get sacrificed as much as anyone I suppose.
I guess you missed my list of recent bowl results for Iowa. They've fare well against the likes of Florida, LSU, and Texas. They may not be as good as Alabama, Florida or Texas, but they're just as good as anyone else. If they win out, there's not a single reason why they don't deserve national championship consideration.
Iowa deserves a ton of credit for being able to put an elite football team together. It's easy to convince kids to go to school in California or Florida. Try convincing an elite football player to spend his time in Iowa City. It's not easy. In that regard, what they're accomplishing is even more impressive than the top 4 or 5 teams in the country.
- pujols005
- Everyday Player
- Posts: 242
- Joined: September 13 09, 5:43 pm
Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State
I don't really watch Big Ten games, unless Indiana is playing, because they are simply too boring to watch. The best games like Ohio State vs. Michigan are no longer exciting and the Michigan vs. Michigan State games are getting more boring every year.

