Rant: Chain Restaurants

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Fat Strat »

Furthermore, the idea of having a giant bookstore is only great in a community where you drive everywhere (same goes for Target, Wal-Mart, etc... Hypermarkets, Supermarkets)
I can see that in an urban setting, and I can see how some people would really enjoy that. Where I am it's entirely unpractical. We appreciate that there's a school within walking distance of our house, but it's 2 miles to the nearest store of any substantial kind. (Sub)urban sprawl? Yup! But in 5/6's of the country (as far as landmass, not population, and I'm estimating, fyi) walking to a locally owned bookstore would turn into at least a half day hike.

User avatar
redbirdjazzz
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4921
Joined: April 17 06, 10:50 am
Location: Columbia, MO

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by redbirdjazzz »

Fat Strat wrote:
Furthermore, the idea of having a giant bookstore is only great in a community where you drive everywhere (same goes for Target, Wal-Mart, etc... Hypermarkets, Supermarkets)
I can see that in an urban setting, and I can see how some people would really enjoy that. Where I am it's entirely unpractical. We appreciate that there's a school within walking distance of our house, but it's 2 miles to the nearest store of any substantial kind. (Sub)urban sprawl? Yup! But in 5/6's of the country (as far as landmass, not population, and I'm estimating, fyi) walking to a locally owned bookstore would turn into at least a half day hike.
There's a great used book store in Kirksville, just north of the square, that I used to walk to a couple times a month (it may have gone in after you graduated), and I wish I had that here in Columbia. Most of my books, dvds, etc. I get used from Amazon, so even Barnes & Noble gets limited business from me, but it's nice to be able to walk to a nice book store sometimes.

User avatar
Hudler
All-Star
Posts: 2293
Joined: September 13 06, 12:02 am
Location: Fulton,MO

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Hudler »

clement wrote:US cities used to be like cities everywhere else in the world. Then there was a huge move to creating suburbs (around the 1950s and forward) which was largely pushed by the automobile industry, and was facilitated by the white flight phenomenon. Sure, the US is a big spread out country and people used to ride horses, but that doesn't explain why Americans who lived in cities suddenly began to spread out into suburbs in the 1950s. GM bought train and trolley tracks all over the country and dismantled them, for example. You can call it shrewd marketing I guess, but they basically rendered public transit systems in many American cities inoperable or completely unpleasant, pushing people to just opt for buying their automobiles instead.

I didn't say that chains were only a good idea if people travel by car, I said that relying on big chain stores to buy our goods further pushes our dependence on cars since they tend to locate in cheaper rent suburban areas. And sure, many of them do well in cities too... I don't want to keep repeating myself, but I am not for a second denying that these businesses do well. They are more cost efficient and capitalize on economies of scale. So they don't have to do as well in terms of margins as independent stores, whether they are big or small. They have a competitive advantage by definition.

And I'm not suggesting that we destroy existing cities, I'm saying that we should stop exacerbating a problem that has been going on for 50 years and getting worse and worse and start to reverse the trend by investing in building communities that make more sense. What's wrong with having people drive to rail stations? That's how it's done for suburban commuters in most cities that have a half-way decent rail system. It probably cuts down on traffic and emissions by well over 50% than if they drove the whole distance.
People didn't suddenly start to leave the cities in the 1950's, it's been going on in America for as long as there have been cities. My family, and 1,000's of others have stayed one step ahead of urban sprawl for over 200 years. Americans as a whole want room to breath that just isn't possible living in a dirty,expensive,crime-ridden,overpopulated city and there are probably more people like me who wouldn't live in a city if you paid us too. I guess I just don't understand the belief that urban living is the perfection that a lot of people do.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by cards2468 »

Hudler wrote:
clement wrote:US cities used to be like cities everywhere else in the world. Then there was a huge move to creating suburbs (around the 1950s and forward) which was largely pushed by the automobile industry, and was facilitated by the white flight phenomenon. Sure, the US is a big spread out country and people used to ride horses, but that doesn't explain why Americans who lived in cities suddenly began to spread out into suburbs in the 1950s. GM bought train and trolley tracks all over the country and dismantled them, for example. You can call it shrewd marketing I guess, but they basically rendered public transit systems in many American cities inoperable or completely unpleasant, pushing people to just opt for buying their automobiles instead.

I didn't say that chains were only a good idea if people travel by car, I said that relying on big chain stores to buy our goods further pushes our dependence on cars since they tend to locate in cheaper rent suburban areas. And sure, many of them do well in cities too... I don't want to keep repeating myself, but I am not for a second denying that these businesses do well. They are more cost efficient and capitalize on economies of scale. So they don't have to do as well in terms of margins as independent stores, whether they are big or small. They have a competitive advantage by definition.

And I'm not suggesting that we destroy existing cities, I'm saying that we should stop exacerbating a problem that has been going on for 50 years and getting worse and worse and start to reverse the trend by investing in building communities that make more sense. What's wrong with having people drive to rail stations? That's how it's done for suburban commuters in most cities that have a half-way decent rail system. It probably cuts down on traffic and emissions by well over 50% than if they drove the whole distance.
People didn't suddenly start to leave the cities in the 1950's, it's been going on in America for as long as there have been cities. My family, and 1,000's of others have stayed one step ahead of urban sprawl for over 200 years. Americans as a whole want room to breath that just isn't possible living in a dirty,expensive,crime-ridden,overpopulated city and there are probably more people like me who wouldn't live in a city if you paid us too. I guess I just don't understand the belief that urban living is the perfection that a lot of people do.
I've lived in the sticks, lived in a couple different urban areas, and lived in suburbs. They all have their positives and their negatives, and I enjoyed them all, but I too don't understand why people look down on non-urban living. There's an incredible amount of things you can do in rural areas that you can't do in urban areas, and to me, occasionally going out to my friend's farm is 1 of the most therapeutic experiences I've ever felt. It's just peaceful. I don't know if I could spend every day doing it, but it's shown me that there's absolutely nothing wrong with that type of lifestyle.

User avatar
clement
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6008
Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by clement »

cards2468 wrote:
Hudler wrote:People didn't suddenly start to leave the cities in the 1950's, it's been going on in America for as long as there have been cities. My family, and 1,000's of others have stayed one step ahead of urban sprawl for over 200 years. Americans as a whole want room to breath that just isn't possible living in a dirty,expensive,crime-ridden,overpopulated city and there are probably more people like me who wouldn't live in a city if you paid us too. I guess I just don't understand the belief that urban living is the perfection that a lot of people do.
I've lived in the sticks, lived in a couple different urban areas, and lived in suburbs. They all have their positives and their negatives, and I enjoyed them all, but I too don't understand why people look down on non-urban living. There's an incredible amount of things you can do in rural areas that you can't do in urban areas, and to me, occasionally going out to my friend's farm is 1 of the most therapeutic experiences I've ever felt. It's just peaceful. I don't know if I could spend every day doing it, but it's shown me that there's absolutely nothing wrong with that type of lifestyle.
In US cities there was indeed the beginning of a very significant urban sprawl phenomenon in the 1950s that has continued almost unabated in many parts of the country to today. This was where mostly centralized cities started expanding into suburbs. You can look it up if you don't believe me. But that doesn't mean that nobody ever left a city before 1950!

And I'm not talking at all about rural life. I'm talking about large metropolitan areas and the problems of sustainability, crowding, traffic, transportation, water, obesity, health, pollution, and any number of other problems that are contributed to or caused by it.

If you're living in a suburb with sprinklers watering the green grass and trees in your yard, don't be fooled by the mirage. The most polluted cities with the most unhealthy air quality in America are not just the most populated ones but are the ones that have the most urban sprawl (cities like Los Angeles, Atlanta, Houston, Dallas, Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, Phoenix, and even smaller cities like Sacramento, Birmingham, and Salt Lake City). Although there are still some cities that rank high because of industrial pollution (factories and the like), one of the most significant contributor to pollution in most cities comes from automobile exhaust emissions.

So it's not about me or anyone trying to say that urban living is perfection; it's about trying to say that if you choose or need to live in a community where there is a large population, it is more sustainable, more healthy, and I'd argue even more pleasant to live in one where everyone is not completely dependent on automobiles to get everywhere. If local, state, and even federal governments are doing their jobs, then they should be investing in infrastructure and projects to reverse a clearly foolish 50+ year trend that we have been embarking on and start providing incentives to private citizens and businesses to adjust to a more sustainable urban (and suburban) existence, and negative incentives to those who don't wish to adjust.

If people want to escape the dirty polluted big cities, they should join Leroy in North Dakota. Moving out to St. Charles or Wildwood sure isn't going to help.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by cards2468 »

I'm not doubting you, just adding on to hudler's post.

I know Cincinnati used to have an elaborate trolly system, and in some areas you'll still see tracks, but I think the bus replaced the trolly and airplanes replaced rail. In the 1950's I assume parents of the baby boomer generation wanted out of the cities as they saw personal transportation as an alternative. For my family, though, both sides lived out in rural areas and moved towards cities into very close suburbs (the st. Louis side you can see the arch from their house and the Chicago side you can see the Sears Tower from)

Edit: I don't understand putting down suburban life though. I personally would not raise kids in an urban area. Between crime, lack of real space for them to play, and school quality, the suburbs are much more appealing, not to mention I'd like a large garage where I can work on my projects.

User avatar
Hudler
All-Star
Posts: 2293
Joined: September 13 06, 12:02 am
Location: Fulton,MO

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Hudler »

I'm just saying that the suburbs were something that was starting to happen well before the 1950's. Most of the towns around St. Louis, for example, were havens for people to get out of the city and all it's problems in the late 1800's. In the mid-1800's people left the cities in droves to get something they would probably never get while living in an urban enviroment, a piece of land and a house of their own instead of living in filthy tenements.

Everyone mentions Los Angeles when talking about pollution and cars but almost never mention why it's so bad. L.A. has too many cars and factories and is surrounded by tall hills and mountains that hold it all in.

User avatar
clement
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6008
Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by clement »

cards2468 wrote:I don't understand putting down suburban life though. I personally would not raise kids in an urban area. Between crime, lack of real space for them to play, and school quality, the suburbs are much more appealing, not to mention I'd like a large garage where I can work on my projects.
As far as putting it down, that's just a matter of preference. People put down cities too - polluted, crowded, dirty, crime-ridden, etc. Sometimes I think suburban dwellers are overly sensitive about this stuff. I don't have anything against suburban living per se, except for the problems they cause environmentally. From a personal preference point of view, I find them very generic and bland. That's what this thread initially was about, and I find myself in agreement not only with respect to restaurants, but also with stores, neighborhoods, architecture, and even the people. I grew up in the suburbs so it's not like I don't have experience with them; I acknowledge that I am glad I was educated in the school district I was as opposed to the one where i was before we moved west. And I certainly benefited from all of the woods and farms and open spaces that were around me at the time. Of course all of those open spaces are gone now, they've all been developed in the last 30 years, so I think the space argument becomes much more tenuous than it might have been at one time. I think a lot of St. Louis city has a lot more "space" than much of St. Louis County today.

But to the second point, I agree that's why many people moved to the suburbs. But there is nothing by definition that makes urban areas have more crime and worse schools. In fact in many places in the world the urban areas are where you have the least crime and the best schools. That was even true in many cities in the US for a long time. Decaying cities is an American and relatively recent phenomenon. Not saying it doesn't happen anywhere else, but it happened on a really widespread, grand, and rapid scale in the US between the 1950s and 1980s. I'm talking about needing to do things to reverse this trend. And with that, make city schools better and neighborhoods safer.

And yes the decisions to move to suburbs had a lot to do with the rise of the automobile as an easy transportation option, but it also had to do with a lot of racism and fear of property values plummeting as soon as a black family moved into the neighborhood. So then white family owners panicked, sold their homes too, and the next thing you know, property values were indeed plummeting. Self-fulfilling prophecy. Not to mention a very concerted effort on the part of both automobile and oil interests to ween us off of trolleys and trains and on to automobiles. So when someone brings up the electric car as an option, I'm quick to point out that we tried that once and lobbyists and special corporate interests sabotaged it.

People like suburbs and suburban living, I get that. And I'm fine with that as a preference. And they like their cars and they like their garages and they like having the convenience of being able to walk 10 feet to the car, and drive directly to wherever they wanna go. But there ought to be a cost for all this. Government should do its job and provide the right incentives to people to choose a more sustainable, cleaner, and healthier option.
Hudler wrote:I'm just saying that the suburbs were something that was starting to happen well before the 1950's. Most of the towns around St. Louis, for example, were havens for people to get out of the city and all it's problems in the late 1800's. In the mid-1800's people left the cities in droves to get something they would probably never get while living in an urban enviroment, a piece of land and a house of their own instead of living in filthy tenements.
You're absolutely right, though in those days suburb meant something completely different. The problem is not that suburbs exist, it's the size of them (in terms of population and area combined). When suburbs like Kirkwood were first created, they were small towns outside of the city. That's a completely different animal than there being a continuous and borderless spread out network of Kirkwoods connected by gas stations, shopping strips, roads and highways.

Found this: Between 1950 and 1990, the urban-suburban population in the United States increased by more then 200 percent, but the area occupied by these residents nearly quintupled [source: National Geographic].
Everyone mentions Los Angeles when talking about pollution and cars but almost never mention why it's so bad. L.A. has too many cars and factories and is surrounded by tall hills and mountains that hold it all in.
Sure, too many cars being one of the problems (and being totally spread out, and no viable public transportation system to speak of for a population of >12 million people). But if it were just Los Angeles, then okay. But it's a problem in most American cities, it just happens to be worst in L.A. for some of the reasons you mention, plus the climate doesn't help.
Last edited by clement on September 13 09, 1:27 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Cronos »

I grew up in south St. Louis city. I moved to the suburbs and I liked it a lot better.

Sorry.

User avatar
clement
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6008
Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by clement »

Cronos69 wrote:I grew up in south St. Louis city. I moved to the suburbs and I liked it a lot better.

Sorry.
So?

Post Reply