Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
- AdmiralKird
- MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
- Posts: 10178
- Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
- Location: Tycho Crater, Luna
Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
It's B.C. and A.D. okay, its not BCE and BC, there is no need to change how we name points taking place before and after two millennia ago. I'm not one to get involved what the left calls the "Separation of church and state" or the right's "War against Christianity," but this is just stupid. There's no reason to start rewriting almost every single historic document to remove two letters. If you get offended by two letter's denoting the separation of human history, then you have way more problems than political correctness will fix.
In fact, the idea that we should have B.C. and A.D. in 2,000 years, even if Christianity dies out is kind of cool. We have the same thing today. Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday are all vestiges of Norse gods (woden, thor, freya) that has stuck with everyday life. Even though humans may not worship them, just their contemporary existence says something about us that connects us to our ancestors' lives and society. In time, BC and AD will also lose their common recognition as being symbols of Christianity, just as the days of the week have. There's no need take political correctness this far.
In fact, the idea that we should have B.C. and A.D. in 2,000 years, even if Christianity dies out is kind of cool. We have the same thing today. Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday are all vestiges of Norse gods (woden, thor, freya) that has stuck with everyday life. Even though humans may not worship them, just their contemporary existence says something about us that connects us to our ancestors' lives and society. In time, BC and AD will also lose their common recognition as being symbols of Christianity, just as the days of the week have. There's no need take political correctness this far.
- Maclowery
- Child Pot Activist
- Posts: 7742
- Joined: June 15 06, 7:27 am
- Location: NYC
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
As a history major for a long time, and as someone fascinated with the relationship between society, religion, and myth, this is a really awesome rant.
Even to the most stringent, but educated, atheist, Christ was one of the most important people in written history. Calendars created based off his life don't necessarily require devotion to the Christian faith. So, I agree, as does my old college-going self, that the whole secular BCE deal is kind of silly. I mean, we all still know where that zero-number came from. Mohammad, as a prophet, had an equally massive philosophical reach - the only difference was that scholars didn't re-work calendars around his life.
I don't see why non-Christian religions, or secular logic in general, should be offended enough by the harmless title "anno domini" to rename it.
Awesome rant. I like Jameson.
Even to the most stringent, but educated, atheist, Christ was one of the most important people in written history. Calendars created based off his life don't necessarily require devotion to the Christian faith. So, I agree, as does my old college-going self, that the whole secular BCE deal is kind of silly. I mean, we all still know where that zero-number came from. Mohammad, as a prophet, had an equally massive philosophical reach - the only difference was that scholars didn't re-work calendars around his life.
I don't see why non-Christian religions, or secular logic in general, should be offended enough by the harmless title "anno domini" to rename it.
Awesome rant. I like Jameson.
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43335
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
Problem solved: tonight we're gonna party like it's 5769 (because if you're Jewish, it is).
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43335
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
In the book I'm reading now, Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace, in the future we stop using BC/AD or CE/BCE to identify years. Instead, the year name is sponsored. So this year could be the Year of the Burger King Whopper, next year might be the Year of the Tucks Medicated Pad, and after that the Year of the Depend Adult Undergarment.
- JackofDiamonds
- Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
- Posts: 15010
- Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
heyzeus wrote:In the book I'm reading now, Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace, in the future we stop using BC/AD or CE/BCE to identify years. Instead, the year name is sponsored. So this year could be the Year of the Burger King Whopper, next year might be the Year of the Tucks Medicated Pad, and after that the Year of the Depend Adult Undergarment.
How do yo like it so far? I thought it was a phenomenal read.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
Except, of course, the Islamic Calender.Maclowery wrote:Mohammad, as a prophet, had an equally massive philosophical reach - the only difference was that scholars didn't re-work calendars around his life.
Personally, I'm not sure why people care either way. I'll know what you mean with either notation. BC/AD may as well be AM/PM. Yeah, they stand for something, but it doesn't really matter what it is.
According to Wikipedia/The Los Angeles Times, outrage over this very important dispute prompted Andrew Schlafly to found Conservapedia. Seems appropriate.
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43335
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
It's like running a marathon: Sometimes painful, sometimes exhilarating, really long, but I'm expecting to feel a sense of exaltation and accomplishment whenever I finish it. Which may be 2011.JackofDiamonds wrote:heyzeus wrote:In the book I'm reading now, Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace, in the future we stop using BC/AD or CE/BCE to identify years. Instead, the year name is sponsored. So this year could be the Year of the Burger King Whopper, next year might be the Year of the Tucks Medicated Pad, and after that the Year of the Depend Adult Undergarment.
How do yo like it so far? I thought it was a phenomenal read.
- JCShutout
- MacGyver of Underwear
- Posts: 13368
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
- Location: South City
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
I don't really understand this rant. You're critiquing people of getting offended by two letters when you are getting offended about one extra letter. There is an acceptance that European and US history aren't the only histories in town. All cultures have calendars based off of their religious traditions. Why don't we use the Chinese calendar? They're going to be the major superpower soon.
Since Christianity was pretty comfortable taking over and incorporating other religious symbols in its history, I don't think days of the week are a good comparison. I think a better comparison is calling what some Christians call the "Old Testament" the "Hebrew Scriptures" instead of OT. Its more respectful, recognizing that the texts aren't exclusively ours, and have a distinct meaning to the Jewish people, and that ("old, connotating inferior) meaning isn't superceded by the (new, connotating, better) Christian interpretations.
Since Christianity was pretty comfortable taking over and incorporating other religious symbols in its history, I don't think days of the week are a good comparison. I think a better comparison is calling what some Christians call the "Old Testament" the "Hebrew Scriptures" instead of OT. Its more respectful, recognizing that the texts aren't exclusively ours, and have a distinct meaning to the Jewish people, and that ("old, connotating inferior) meaning isn't superceded by the (new, connotating, better) Christian interpretations.
- Sutter'sBeard
- is the oscar meyer weiner kid
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
- Location: Decatur, IL
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
Here's why: Remember, in the year of the boar,when Gibson posted a 1.12 era.JCShutout wrote:I don't really understand this rant. You're critiquing people of getting offended by two letters when you are getting offended about one extra letter. There is an acceptance that European and US history aren't the only histories in town. All cultures have calendars based off of their religious traditions. Why don't we use the Chinese calendar? They're going to be the major superpower soon.
Since Christianity was pretty comfortable taking over and incorporating other religious symbols in its history, I don't think days of the week are a good comparison. I think a better comparison is calling what some Christians call the "Old Testament" the "Hebrew Scriptures" instead of OT. Its more respectful, recognizing that the texts aren't exclusively ours, and have a distinct meaning to the Jewish people, and that ("old, connotating inferior) meaning isn't superceded by the (new, connotating, better) Christian interpretations.
- redbirdjazzz
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 4921
- Joined: April 17 06, 10:50 am
- Location: Columbia, MO
Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era
You're still using the same dates and the same calendar. It's an empty gesture at political correctness to change the letters without changing the meaning. Why is it the Common Era?JCShutout wrote:I don't really understand this rant. You're critiquing people of getting offended by two letters when you are getting offended about one extra letter. There is an acceptance that European and US history aren't the only histories in town. All cultures have calendars based off of their religious traditions. Why don't we use the Chinese calendar? They're going to be the major superpower soon.






