I'm just being a dork. The only thing I know about soccer is that the US is like Skip Schumaker.thrill wrote:Define good. We're top 15 in the world. That's pretty good.InvincibleCakeEater wrote:I would have been more excited if the US was good at soccer
USA Soccer thread
- InvincibleCakeEater
- GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
- Posts: 28275
- Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
- Location: Raptured
Re: USA Soccer thread
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: USA Soccer thread
Man - confidence /momentum is such the deal in soccer. after that first goal by Brazil, they just seemd to be toying with the US.
For US- hopefully they can build depth and competition from this.
For US- hopefully they can build depth and competition from this.
-
MrSaigon
Re: USA Soccer thread
We didn't play a hard nine (ty). It wasn't the first time this tournament. Spain could have easily scored three goals in the second half of the semi-final, but somehow the defense never let down and Howard was a monster. Looked pretty crappy in the second half against Italy. Good tournament, though. We got to play Brazil twice, Spain, Italy and a surprising Egypt team in a competitive environment.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: USA Soccer thread
I couldn't disagree more. Out gassed and out classed, but the effort was certainly there.MrSaigon wrote:We didn't play a hard nine (ty).
-
MrSaigon
Re: USA Soccer thread
I'm sure it's not a conditioning thing, or I would certainly hope not. Is it more a circumstance of the approach of the other (very talented, in this case) teams that the U.S. just seems to fall back and get hammered on in the second half?thrill wrote:I couldn't disagree more. Out gassed and out classed, but the effort was certainly there.MrSaigon wrote:We didn't play a hard nine (ty).
I played soccer (never at a high level), and I watch a bit, but I'm not real good at watching critically, and there is probably a lot that just goes right over my head, especially when a team like the U.S. is playing a team like Italy, Spain and Brazil.
- TabascoElvis
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5728
- Joined: June 15 06, 8:29 am
- Location: Library of Congress? Detroit? Beyond the sun?
Re: USA Soccer thread
Alright, I've only started looking at what went on because I didn't get a chance to watch it [see rant thread], but I read that Bradley made some questionable substitutions. Any comments about that?
[I haven't read anything about the play of the game yet.]
[I haven't read anything about the play of the game yet.]
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: USA Soccer thread
thrill, I'm with you.
I think the US had a great chance if they could have held off the first goal from Brazil for at least 10-15 minutes in the 2nd half. When Brazil came out and scored, the tide turned quickly. There was still 43 minutes of game left.
Also, do you think we should have subbed sooner if we were tiring quickly?
I thought it was a big step for the US if they can show that they can learn from this experience. The set pieces from Brazil will pick any team apart...and that's what you really have to step back and realize about this game. No matter who played Brazil in the final, Brazil would be the favorite to win (unless Spain, but then it's probably dead even).
I think the US woke up a lot of teams after this tournament. Let's hope we can use it to go forward, because I think we'll play tougher matches against everyone from here on out.
/It was nice to see Donovan show up
I think the US had a great chance if they could have held off the first goal from Brazil for at least 10-15 minutes in the 2nd half. When Brazil came out and scored, the tide turned quickly. There was still 43 minutes of game left.
Also, do you think we should have subbed sooner if we were tiring quickly?
I thought it was a big step for the US if they can show that they can learn from this experience. The set pieces from Brazil will pick any team apart...and that's what you really have to step back and realize about this game. No matter who played Brazil in the final, Brazil would be the favorite to win (unless Spain, but then it's probably dead even).
I think the US woke up a lot of teams after this tournament. Let's hope we can use it to go forward, because I think we'll play tougher matches against everyone from here on out.
/It was nice to see Donovan show up
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: USA Soccer thread
Well first off, 5 games in two weeks is a ton of games. Especially when you play a high effort, lots of running style that the US plays. Doubly especially when you rely on a very thin group of guys to get it done. We needed our depth but were missing some of our horses, so the same 12 guys, the starting XI plus Feilhaber, played all the minutes.MrSaigon wrote:I'm sure it's not a conditioning thing, or I would certainly hope not. Is it more a circumstance of the approach of the other (very talented, in this case) teams that the U.S. just seems to fall back and get hammered on in the second half?thrill wrote:I couldn't disagree more. Out gassed and out classed, but the effort was certainly there.MrSaigon wrote:We didn't play a hard nine (ty).
I played soccer (never at a high level), and I watch a bit, but I'm not real good at watching critically, and there is probably a lot that just goes right over my head, especially when a team like the U.S. is playing a team like Italy, Spain and Brazil.
Brazil had 59% possession which means the US was chasing all game. They were running a ton. Spain had similar possession numbers, but they're possession was quick exchanges in the middle of the field which allowed the US to hang back and just keep their defensive shape. Like this:
----mf----mf----mf----mf----
----d------d------d------d-----
Spain's passing was on the ground, with the 8 US mids and defenders between the ball and the goal. They were very direct through the middle.
Brazil on the other hand does much more wing play. Their outside mids, kaka and robinho play much closer to the goal than a traditional formation like Spain's. Since they are closer to goal, their flanks are covered by their outside backs who play much more advanced than traditional formations. They get away with this because Maicon and Avles are supremely technical and fast and have better ability to play the ball at their feet than, well in my opinion, any other outside backs in the world. They'd be our two best midfielders if they were American. They are also fast enough to get back in an emergency, though their forward positions, which I mentioned last night and led to the two goals, mean they can be exploited by a fast counter attack or runs into space behind them that stay onside.
Anyway, they are incredible passers and crossers, so instead of advancing possession through the middle like Spain, they are constantly switching the point of the attack from right to left to middle and so on. That kind of possession demands a supreme effort from the defending team to constantly be reacting to both sides of the field. Brazil lets the ball do their running for them while the US had to just flat out hustle. When you're pinned back in your own end like that against an opponent full of 10 world class players, you'll eventually make a mistake in that perfect formation that I showed above. Someone will chase and get caught out and give up a chance. Staying organized while constantly running back and forth, side to side across the field is impossible. Eventually you'll make a mistake, though against a team of players like Brazil, you may not even have to make a mistake to give up a goal scoring opportunity. Sometimes it just comes down to a perfect cross, a perfect set piece, a perfect free kick or being just plain skinned by a better player one-on-one.
That's what happened today. If Bradley was in, maybe it's different. Well it's definitely different, but maybe it's better. We needed depth today because of this right here:
Not really. I'll get to why below.TabascoElvis wrote: I read that Bradley made some questionable substitutions. Any comments about that?
Yes. The problem for Bradley was his substitution options were a step down in class. Kljestan and Bornstein are great MLS players, but they are a long way from being able to step into a game with the likes of Brazil. He should have subbed sooner but I don't blame him for not wanting to put what he knows to be inferior players out there.TimeForGuinness wrote:Also, do you think we should have subbed sooner if we were tiring quickly?
I'm not saying it would have meant a win, but Michael Bradley is, with Dempsey and Donovan, our best out-field player. He's certainly our most devastating two-way midfielder. Missing him was gigantic. That's not to say Benny did a bad job. I thought Benny acquitted himself well, but if Bradley plays and he or Clark are gassed, Bob can stick Benny in for one of them instead of the outmatched Sacha Kljestan. If Maurice Edu is healthy, then you have another Europe based midfielder to raise the depth chart. If you have Bradley and Clark starting, you have a complete second set of center mids in Edu and Feilhaber that are a very small step down in class when they take the pitch. You don't get the drastic drop off. Same deal with Brian Ching. He isn't a world beater, but as a third striker option, he is brilliant at tracking back to defend, win balls and hold up play so we could have more possession in Brazil's back third. If you noticed how many headers in their area Brazil won on our long balls in, Brian Ching could have helped with that greatly. That could have allowed us to turn the tables and have them on their heels for more time. Wear them out while also giving our heroic defenders a little bit of a breather.
Those are nice thoughts, but I guess what I'm getting at is that Bob Bradley probably subbed too late, but I believe that if he had all his horses in the stable, he would have done it much sooner and maybe we don't give up that third goal. Or even the second one.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: USA Soccer thread
excellent informative analysis thrill. when I hear my soccer relatives talk like that -I know I can't chime in.
...but that won't stop me here -
Brazil was really impressive with the heart they played - I didn't notice that deer in headlights, fear of losing that dooms so many teams when an upset is in the making. Scoring that quick goal in the second half made a difference -but they didn't panic even after getting screwed out of their 2nd goal
General observation on this level of soccer - being able to win the battles in traffic is huge. Always am amazed at how physical it gets, and how rarely does a guy get the ball without someone on them knocking them around.
Its probably hard to replicate the live-action and talent level without getting your players maimed in a non-game. But if I were a national team coach, I'd have a goon squad to practice offensive and defensive corner kicks against , and practice sparring for control of goalie kicks.
And one vote from me to ban those horns from the world cup audience.
...but that won't stop me here -
Brazil was really impressive with the heart they played - I didn't notice that deer in headlights, fear of losing that dooms so many teams when an upset is in the making. Scoring that quick goal in the second half made a difference -but they didn't panic even after getting screwed out of their 2nd goal
General observation on this level of soccer - being able to win the battles in traffic is huge. Always am amazed at how physical it gets, and how rarely does a guy get the ball without someone on them knocking them around.
Its probably hard to replicate the live-action and talent level without getting your players maimed in a non-game. But if I were a national team coach, I'd have a goon squad to practice offensive and defensive corner kicks against , and practice sparring for control of goalie kicks.
And one vote from me to ban those horns from the world cup audience.
-
paskal
- Veteran Player
- Posts: 731
- Joined: April 20 06, 7:52 pm
Re: USA Soccer thread
I cringed when Lalas said the US was like 96-1 when leading at halftime. Told my friend I was watching the game with "But it's Brazil!"

