Religion is a huge thing to the religious. As an agnostic myself, I've never really thought it should be a big deal. I don't care what kind of wedding ceremony I have. I don't care if my spouse would want to teach kids about religion (I'd actually encourage it). But it's a big deal to the one who thinks religion is important.wart57 wrote:
Religion is a huge thing, and if you don't think it would have led to trouble, I think you are mistaken. If you two did deicide to get married, what sort of ceremony would it be? If you have kids, and she wanted to teach them about God and her Lutheran beliefs, would you have a problem with that? Would she have a problem with you telling the kids there is no God? I know you don't want to hear this right now, but this may be for the best in the long run.
Rant: Getting Dumped / Rave: Reunions
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31085
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Getting Dumped
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
Re: Getting Dumped
Then it was a big deal, because she and her family think religion is important. Not everything revolves around you and your own beliefs.Popeye_Card wrote:Religion is a huge thing to the religious. As an agnostic myself, I've never really thought it should be a big deal. I don't care what kind of wedding ceremony I have. I don't care if my spouse would want to teach kids about religion (I'd actually encourage it). But it's a big deal to the one who thinks religion is important.wart57 wrote:
Religion is a huge thing, and if you don't think it would have led to trouble, I think you are mistaken. If you two did deicide to get married, what sort of ceremony would it be? If you have kids, and she wanted to teach them about God and her Lutheran beliefs, would you have a problem with that? Would she have a problem with you telling the kids there is no God? I know you don't want to hear this right now, but this may be for the best in the long run.
- Bo Hart
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 8770
- Joined: April 14 06, 9:50 pm
Re: Getting Dumped
Well, it definitely came out of nowhere.lukethedrifter wrote:I think it's only fair then to be honest with a partner about something like this. Maybe she wasn't wrong about religion being a dealbreaker.
Anyway, it sounds more like a breakup than getting dumped. Tough either way, but I see getting dumped as when you don't see any reason for split and it comes out of nowhere.
While we conceded that we probably didn't love each other (yet, at least), we definitely cared for each other immensely and we were rolling along having a grand time.
As for my marriage comment, let me elaborate a little bit: the girl I just dated, Natasha, was a lot unlike girls I had dated in the past. For a long time I was convinced that I'd end up with someone really bright and witty. Natasha wasn't that (by no means dumb, don't get me wrong), she had other qualities that made her so great. She was a very caring and compassionate person. I was skeptical about dating her at first because she didn't fit the mold of girl I liked. Once we dated, I enjoyed it a lot. Even though I was skeptical about marriage with her, I think it would have followed the same path as dating. I would have warmed up to the idea of it and would eventually have embraced it.
When it comes to religion, all I care is that people respect my beliefs (she did). With my family (predominantly Catholic), I have no problem taking part in Catholic ceremonies or events when I'm asked to. It's a sacrifice I'm willing to make. That's how I would have handled it with her.Religion is a huge thing, and if you don't think it would have led to trouble, I think you are mistaken. If you two did deicide to get married, what sort of ceremony would it be? If you have kids, and she wanted to teach them about God and her Lutheran beliefs, would you have a problem with that? Would she have a problem with you telling the kids there is no God? I know you don't want to hear this right now, but this may be for the best in the long run.
The reason I didn't think that religion was a huge concern is that she isn't an overly-religious person. She doesn't attend church ever, she doesn't ever discuss it, etc. In fact, she's skeptical of a lot of things herself. That said, her family is very religious, and I know she had a lot of concerns about how welcoming they would be to someone like me over the long-term. And I also know that her parents put a lot of pressure on her to follow a similar, religious-oriented life. I obviously pointed out that her parents view on religion shouldn't matter as much as her own, but she downplayed their views on it.
I guess in some regards, she probably aspires to live a more religion-based life. I don't know that it's necessarily her being obedient so much it is her wanting to follow in the path of the parents that she admires. That's probably why it wasn't an issue now, but was something she could have seen being an issue in time.
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Re: Getting Dumped
Next time, just pretend, and pray to your own pagan god out in the tool shed.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31085
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Getting Dumped
Most things do revolve around me, but that's beside the point.wart57 wrote: Then it was a big deal, because she and her family think religion is important. Not everything revolves around you and your own beliefs.
I went through a very similar experience. Girl broke up with me, in part because of religious differences, when she wasn't even very religious. But since her family was catholic, there's the expectation or whatever that she should NEVER marry a non-catholic. Anything non-catholic, she was scared to even inform her parents. This is all despite me being raised Lutheran (agnostic now), and knowing the Bible, etc. much better than she ever did. Her parents weren't even that religious--they went to church maybe twice a month.Kyle wrote: The reason I didn't think that religion was a huge concern is that she isn't an overly-religious person. She doesn't attend church ever, she doesn't ever discuss it, etc. In fact, she's skeptical of a lot of things herself. That said, her family is very religious, and I know she had a lot of concerns about how welcoming they would be to someone like me over the long-term. And I also know that her parents put a lot of pressure on her to follow a similar, religious-oriented life. I obviously pointed out that her parents view on religion shouldn't matter as much as her own, but she downplayed their views on it.
I guess in some regards, she probably aspires to live a more religion-based life. I don't know that it's necessarily her being obedient so much it is her wanting to follow in the path of the parents that she admires. That's probably why it wasn't an issue now, but was something she could have seen being an issue in time.
I found the whole thing really frustrating. It was like I was an ex-con or something because I wasn't catholic.
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
Re: Getting Dumped
I was raised Catholic and faced the same preassures. My family didn't like anyone I dated who wasn't Catholic. My wife is Romanian Penticostal, her family was shocked that I knew the bible, usually better than most of them, but it has been a constant struggle for us becasue most of them think they are superior to me (ha I laugh at them, for I know no one is superior to me!) My wife wants to go to her Romanian church, but I can't stand it becasue it is all in Romanian, and 2 hrs of listening to something I don't understand really sucks. I don't know how we are going to deal with religion for Stinky and Smelly. We go to a non-denominationl christian church right now. But I know there will be problems in the future.Popeye_Card wrote:Most things do revolve around me, but that's beside the point.wart57 wrote: Then it was a big deal, because she and her family think religion is important. Not everything revolves around you and your own beliefs.
I went through a very similar experience. Girl broke up with me, in part because of religious differences, when she wasn't even very religious. But since her family was catholic, there's the expectation or whatever that she should NEVER marry a non-catholic. Anything non-catholic, she was scared to even inform her parents. This is all despite me being raised Lutheran (agnostic now), and knowing the Bible, etc. much better than she ever did. Her parents weren't even that religious--they went to church maybe twice a month.Kyle wrote: The reason I didn't think that religion was a huge concern is that she isn't an overly-religious person. She doesn't attend church ever, she doesn't ever discuss it, etc. In fact, she's skeptical of a lot of things herself. That said, her family is very religious, and I know she had a lot of concerns about how welcoming they would be to someone like me over the long-term. And I also know that her parents put a lot of pressure on her to follow a similar, religious-oriented life. I obviously pointed out that her parents view on religion shouldn't matter as much as her own, but she downplayed their views on it.
I guess in some regards, she probably aspires to live a more religion-based life. I don't know that it's necessarily her being obedient so much it is her wanting to follow in the path of the parents that she admires. That's probably why it wasn't an issue now, but was something she could have seen being an issue in time.
I found the whole thing really frustrating. It was like I was an ex-con or something because I wasn't catholic.
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Getting Dumped
She is 100% right on this one...you are looking at it from your perspective and not hers. She's a believer, and you're not. That means you wouldn't run into a lot of problems, but it's hard to be with someone who thinks your entire base is a sham.Kyle wrote:The breakup basically stemmed from her not viewing us as a long-term match. The biggest hang-up was religion. I'm atheist and she comes from a pretty strong Lutheran family. She just thought we'd run into too many differences down the line.
In time, the fact you are an atheist and she is fairly devout would have eroded away the relationship.
- Radbird
- There's someone in my head but it's not me
- Posts: 62390
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
- Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II
Re: Getting Dumped
I'm Catholic and my family didn't care. My GF in college was a Texas Methodist and her parents hated me. They never met me, either, but not being of their faith essentially doomed the relationship. Even though I would've converted for her. Didn't matter - I was "tainted".
My wife is Catholic also, so we had no issue. The funny thing was we were already together before we knew. But I have to admit, it's made life easier. My sister married a Romanian Orthodox, and we (her family) haven't been able to participate in anything - couldn't be part of the wedding, the baptisms, confirmations. My sister converted, but it saddens her that all of the kids godparents and sponsors are from his family. But he would've been disowned if he hadn't gotten married in their church.
My wife is Catholic also, so we had no issue. The funny thing was we were already together before we knew. But I have to admit, it's made life easier. My sister married a Romanian Orthodox, and we (her family) haven't been able to participate in anything - couldn't be part of the wedding, the baptisms, confirmations. My sister converted, but it saddens her that all of the kids godparents and sponsors are from his family. But he would've been disowned if he hadn't gotten married in their church.
- KeepingItCasual
- Veteran Player
- Posts: 551
- Joined: June 5 09, 9:48 pm
Re: Getting Dumped
Me being a devout atheist I always thought my dream girl would be one. That was before I dated them. They were more miserable and unbearably cynical than I am.
- InvincibleCakeEater
- GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
- Posts: 28275
- Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
- Location: Raptured
Re: Getting Dumped
Does not compute.KeepingItCasual wrote:Me being a devout atheist I always thought my dream girl would be one. That was before I dated them. They were more miserable and unbearably cynical than I am.





