Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
Maclowery
Child Pot Activist
Posts: 7742
Joined: June 15 06, 7:27 am
Location: NYC

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Maclowery »

I'd like to be the first person to say that you should break up with her.

Your girl telling him to bug off and living her Sinful Life unsupported by Pops sounds like a non-option, I assume. Lying to him and continuing the sleepovers also appears to be a non-option. And living a stunted, uncomfortable relationship dominated by her dad's rules is going to be really, really damaging in the long run.

If you two are truly meant for eachother, then she needs to be frank with her father, and face the music, if it means that you two will be in six-figure debt or something.

User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

Arthur Dent wrote:I agree with Fat.
On the other hand, it's fairly weird that dad would still be paying for cell phones and credit cards. Is this common?
I can't speak to how common it is, but I moved about six months ago, but I'm still on my family's plan for cell phones so I guess my parents still pay for mine (though I do live three hours away now and I think that's a big reason why). I also still use a shared credit card which I had in college, though I think the only thing I use it for now is to buy gas.

I'm not completely financially independent at this point, but have a lot more than I did. My parents probably give me a hundred dollars a month or so to help out with groceries. If I have a sudden emergency (like a major problem with my car), they'll help me with it (thankfully, I haven't had to deal with that). Otherwise, it's all on me.

User avatar
Sutter'sBeard
is the oscar meyer weiner kid
Posts: 3140
Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
Location: Decatur, IL

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Sutter'sBeard »

Fat_Bulldog wrote:
Kyle wrote:OK, update time.

What I didn't tell you guys that in addition to not sleeping together, he also gave her a few more rules to follow:
- she would go to church every Sunday
- if she went out, she would only have one drink
- she would start working more
- she would curb her spending
- (the fifth was the no sleepover thing)

OK, this is where we start to get into psychopath territory: he told her that if she disobeyed any of these rules, she had to call and tell him.

So anyway... she ended up talking to her dad about this, and told her that she wouldn't be following some of this stuff. Like the sleepovers and the church thing.

First he told her that she would be paying for her own cell phone. Understandable. Next, he told her that she would give him his credit card back. Fair enough. But then he told her that her medications and her doctor visits were all on her shoulders now. That's pretty unreasonable, because she's on medication for depression right now. When you couple this with the college thing... you've got to wonder what his agenda is here. But then, an adult is an adult, right?

The financial things are one thing, but he also told her that "you will not call me with all your problems" and also told her to "not ask for advice, because [he] won't have any." One more quotable for you here: "You will be choosing to go to the gutter and I am 100% confident that that is where you will be in short order. I am never wrong, that should scare you just a little."

If you can still defend this guy... I don't know what to say. Tough love is one thing, but being clinically insane is another. He's acting like he's basically going to renounce his fatherhood over her.

This is really tough watching this happen because she absolutely adores her dad. I really have no idea what to tell her to do. Obviously a lot of what he is demanding is good, but telling someone they can't have a sleepover or telling someone they have to go to church as an adult is... outrageous.
He is going over the top.
Image

He's a arm wrestling truck driver?

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Richie Allen »

I can't believe someone your age, in that type of situation, having no understanding of the Dad's concerns.

User avatar
JCShutout
MacGyver of Underwear
Posts: 13368
Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
Location: South City

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by JCShutout »

While I'm with Fat and others on the importance of nurturing her relationship with her father, there is never any reason whatsoever under ANY circumstance for a parent to say such hurtful things to a child as "I'm 100% sure you're going to end up in the gutter". His language, if you're communicating it accurately, indicates he has fairly serious issues. Withdrawing financial support? Understandable? Withdrawing emotional support? Serious emotional issues on his part and he should probably seek counseling. He is essentially stating his love for his daughter is extremely conditional, which will be damaging to her future relationships unless she is able to come to terms with those hurts and move past them, which is very difficult.

Now, if he is there for her, but when she calls for emotional support, he holds to his beliefs, that's fine, but cutting off communication is terrible and manipulative.

That said, she should still seek communication and a good relationship with him, I just hope she's emotionally stable enough to be able to deflect his issues. its always more painful coming from a parent.

User avatar
Bo Hart
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8770
Joined: April 14 06, 9:50 pm

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Bo Hart »

Richie Allen wrote:I can't believe someone your age, in that type of situation, having no understanding of the Dad's concerns.
OK, I need to touch upon this issue because there have been a lot of responses like this.

Let me put this straight: if I had a daughter and she was only 19 years old, then yes -- in all likelihood, I would have a problem with my daughter having sleepovers with the guy. Or, in other words, I couldn't envision myself approving of it.

WITH THAT SAID, I am also a very liberal personal, and strongly believe in personal freedom. Just because I didn't agree with something that my daughter was doing doesn't mean that I would strong-arm her and threaten to take things away from her if she didn't follow my demands. I mean, yeah, it's easy for me to say these things now when it's completely from an empathetic standpoint... but come on. As an adult, you're a role model and you're setting an example for her. If you're using tactics like he's using, you're helping justify the use of ridiculous tactics like this in the future.

I can understand him having concerns, even if I don't think it's his business. I can not understand threatening consequences.

2 years from now, spending a few nights together or not will not be a big deal. Her relationship with her father will still be a big, big deal. As it should be.
OK, to address this and any responses like this: completely agree.

This is why my situation sucks so bad. I've only been dating this girl for about five months. That sad, things have been going really well. I can definitely say this is the most stable and enjoyable relationship in my life so far -- by far. I know that she feels the same way, too.

It's obviously preposterous to try and convince her to choose me over her father. I'm genuinely sincere when I say that I don't want that to happen. Many people have felt awesome with their partner five months in to a relationship, only to see things crumble down the line. Statistically, I'm sure the chances of things working out with me and her in the long run are pretty slim. On the contrary, her father will always be there for her (provided he doesn't continue acting like the Black Angel of Death). This is especially true considering how fondly she has felt of her father coming into this.

Regardless... what he is trying to do to her in unethical and nothing short of insane. Trying to get his adult daughter to follow his rules, and having her report to him when she breaks them? What?! I want her to having a loving relationship with her father... but that's not the type of relationship he's providing right now. I'm very adamant about her standing up to him and not letting him do this to her. It's like she told me... "my relationship with him is going to be ruined either way... if I defy him, he's going to basically disown me... if I comply, I'm going to resent him for trying to control me in such a ridiculous way."


Anyway... I want to try and meet with him or something. We had a talk about religion a couple weeks ago (it lasted about two hours), and it remained friendly and diplomatic. I think he'd be the same way with a talk like that. Anyway, I want to try and talk to him from a religious standpoint... For example, something like...
Colossians 3:21 wrote: Fathers, provoke not your children to anger, lest they be discouraged.
How would you reason that he is being wrong and immoral from the standpoint of a father (from a biblical angle)? He's Lutheran, by the way, and again, he accepts the Bible word for word with no interpretation.

Also, he's comparing her to the prodigal son. He's saying that she's the "prodigal daughter." I can sincerely say that this is a hyperbole in every sense of the phrase. I've never seen someone blow something so far out of proportion. Besides, where in the story does the father drive the son into failure? Maybe he's saying that her going off to college is symbolic of the son leaving.

Finally, his justification for this is that he wants to be with his daughter for eternity, but that she's going to hell if she doesn't change. So in his view, if he cuts her off she's going to fail... then will crawl back to him, at which point he'll give her back everything he stripped away -- provided she abides by his guidelines.


Anyway, I appreciate the discussion. There have been some very helpful views expressed so far.

User avatar
tothebeach08
All-Star
Posts: 1564
Joined: January 10 08, 2:52 pm
Location: In My Happy Place

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by tothebeach08 »

You said that she is treated for depression. Don't these things (mental health issues) sometimes "run" in families? I don't know, just asking. The things he said to her, whether in anger or not, were pretty cruel. He's afraid, I think that's the bottom line. Afraid to lose her, afraid to lose control over her, and afraid of you. He's not handling this very well, obviously. If you talk to him, make sure to go in with a respectful tone for the position he holds in her life. These things usually have a way of working out the way they were meant to be.

User avatar
JCShutout
MacGyver of Underwear
Posts: 13368
Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
Location: South City

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by JCShutout »

Kyle wrote:He's Lutheran, by the way, and again, he accepts the Bible word for word with no interpretation.
That in and of itself is an interpretation.
Kyle wrote:Also, he's comparing her to the prodigal son. He's saying that she's the "prodigal daughter." I can sincerely say that this is a hyperbole in every sense of the phrase. I've never seen someone blow something so far out of proportion. Besides, where in the story does the father drive the son into failure? Maybe he's saying that her going off to college is symbolic of the son leaving.

Finally, his justification for this is that he wants to be with his daughter for eternity, but that she's going to hell if she doesn't change. So in his view, if he cuts her off she's going to fail... then will crawl back to him, at which point he'll give her back everything he stripped away -- provided she abides by his guidelines.
Tell him the prodigal father gave his son the inheritance which was wasted, so if she's really the prodigal daughter, the dad should give her enough money to get through school and to cover her meds for however long he was going to. If he's going to use the Bible, throw it back at him. That's how the story went. The prodgical dad funded the "sinful life" of the son.

Regardless, this guy seems to have serious issues and needs therapy, but since his neurosis are disguised as "faith", he won't think he needs it, which means therapy would be pointless. I would be VERY afraid of dealing with a person like this.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by thrill »

This sounds like a crappy, crappy situation. I don't know what you should do. I'll just say that in my experience, being an agent of division between her and her father will do absolutely no good for you. You're going to have to walk a fine line between being supportive of her if she chooses to rebel against her dad and not encouraging it in any way. Basically, if you have any hand in tipping the scales between her blowing her dad off and honoring what he asks of her. One of, if not both of them, will resent it, maybe for the duration of your relationship.

I would suggest that you just do your best to be the calm one at all times. Never get drawn into an argument. Respect him, respect her and just let her make her own decision and then support it even if you don't like it.
JCShutout wrote:Tell him the prodigal father gave his son the inheritance which was wasted, so if she's really the prodigal daughter, the dad should give her enough money to get through school and to cover her meds for however long he was going to. If he's going to use the Bible, throw it back at him.

This doesn't sound very Christian. He may not be acting in a Christ-like manner, but that doesn't give Kyle the go-ahead to do the same.

User avatar
Bo Hart
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8770
Joined: April 14 06, 9:50 pm

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Bo Hart »

JCShutout wrote:That in and of itself is an interpretation.
Of course it is, but you really can't reason when someone on that.

This is the same guy that told me that "Islam requires you to murder another person to get into Heaven, at which point you'll have fifty virgins waiting," and the same one who argued that "as time goes on, evolution is becoming less-and-less accepted."

Post Reply