Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
obucard
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8181
Joined: April 18 06, 11:04 pm
Location: Central AR

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by obucard »

tothebeach08 wrote:I don't think he's being overprotective or privacy-invading. What he is being though, is a Father. He's doing exactly what his job is....parenting. Here's the thing I have found as my kid has gotten older, letting go sucks. You have to do it little by little and it still hurts. This is probably the first time this situation has come up for the two of them. Neither one knows how to handle it. True he may have over reacted in the heat of the moment, but who doesn't when it comes to their kids. When things settle down, she needs to have a talk with him and tell him that he did a good job and she will always need him, but that she cares about you and it's time to start letting go a little. Even though letting go hurts and sucks, it still is rewarding to see this kid you used to carry to bed in their footie jammies become a good, decent person. That's when you can let a breath out. Be patient Kyle, some day you will be him then you will see....
Are you saying Kyle has effectively cursed himself into having at least one daughter?

User avatar
Bo Hart
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8770
Joined: April 14 06, 9:50 pm

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Bo Hart »

OK, update time.

What I didn't tell you guys that in addition to not sleeping together, he also gave her a few more rules to follow:
- she would go to church every Sunday
- if she went out, she would only have one drink
- she would start working more
- she would curb her spending
- (the fifth was the no sleepover thing)

OK, this is where we start to get into psychopath territory: he told her that if she disobeyed any of these rules, she had to call and tell him.

So anyway... she ended up talking to her dad about this, and told her that she wouldn't be following some of this stuff. Like the sleepovers and the church thing.

First he told her that she would be paying for her own cell phone. Understandable. Next, he told her that she would give him his credit card back. Fair enough. But then he told her that her medications and her doctor visits were all on her shoulders now. That's pretty unreasonable, because she's on medication for depression right now. When you couple this with the college thing... you've got to wonder what his agenda is here. But then, an adult is an adult, right?

The financial things are one thing, but he also told her that "you will not call me with all your problems" and also told her to "not ask for advice, because [he] won't have any." One more quotable for you here: "You will be choosing to go to the gutter and I am 100% confident that that is where you will be in short order. I am never wrong, that should scare you just a little."

If you can still defend this guy... I don't know what to say. Tough love is one thing, but being clinically insane is another. He's acting like he's basically going to renounce his fatherhood over her.

This is really tough watching this happen because she absolutely adores her dad. I really have no idea what to tell her to do. Obviously a lot of what he is demanding is good, but telling someone they can't have a sleepover or telling someone they have to go to church as an adult is... outrageous.

User avatar
Fat_Bulldog
likes to grate his own cheese
Posts: 12878
Joined: May 9 06, 12:41 pm
Location: Drunk

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Fat_Bulldog »

Kyle wrote:OK, update time.

What I didn't tell you guys that in addition to not sleeping together, he also gave her a few more rules to follow:
- she would go to church every Sunday
- if she went out, she would only have one drink
- she would start working more
- she would curb her spending
- (the fifth was the no sleepover thing)

OK, this is where we start to get into psychopath territory: he told her that if she disobeyed any of these rules, she had to call and tell him.

So anyway... she ended up talking to her dad about this, and told her that she wouldn't be following some of this stuff. Like the sleepovers and the church thing.

First he told her that she would be paying for her own cell phone. Understandable. Next, he told her that she would give him his credit card back. Fair enough. But then he told her that her medications and her doctor visits were all on her shoulders now. That's pretty unreasonable, because she's on medication for depression right now. When you couple this with the college thing... you've got to wonder what his agenda is here. But then, an adult is an adult, right?

The financial things are one thing, but he also told her that "you will not call me with all your problems" and also told her to "not ask for advice, because [he] won't have any." One more quotable for you here: "You will be choosing to go to the gutter and I am 100% confident that that is where you will be in short order. I am never wrong, that should scare you just a little."

If you can still defend this guy... I don't know what to say. Tough love is one thing, but being clinically insane is another. He's acting like he's basically going to renounce his fatherhood over her.

This is really tough watching this happen because she absolutely adores her dad. I really have no idea what to tell her to do. Obviously a lot of what he is demanding is good, but telling someone they can't have a sleepover or telling someone they have to go to church as an adult is... outrageous.
He is going over the top.

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Fat Strat »

I'll give you the same advice that I give engaged couples. When you marry someone you're marrying not only the girl but the entire family. You're inheriting their quirks, problems, and issues and accepting them as your own. Sometimes that's a good thing. More often than not, it's a difficult issue that couples have to go through.

I realize that you guys aren't to that point yet, but regardless of the length or status of your relationship, it's your responsibility, in my professional opinion, to support your girlfriends relationship with her dad and to build it up rather that being an obstacle to it or helping tear it down. The end result of that attitude is forcing her to chose between her relationship with you or the life that she would build with you in it and her relationship with her father and life that she's had with him and could continue to have with him. I have NEVER seen anyone in that situation who ended up happy about it or didn't have emotional or psychological issues because of it.

I'm not even suggesting that you have to agree to his demands or anything like that. Nor am I defending him and his attitude. They're not here to listen to my advice or to offer their take. Rather, I'm suggesting that you do what you can to help renew her relationship with her father and show a little respect for the nineteen years that he has spent raising her, supporting her, providing for her, and loving her. Because in the end, what's more important... you not having to go home at night or a daughter's relationship with her dad?

User avatar
stlouie_lipp
Hallelujah Brother
Posts: 13380
Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by stlouie_lipp »

Kyle wrote:OK, update time.

What I didn't tell you guys that in addition to not sleeping together, he also gave her a few more rules to follow:
- she would go to church every Sunday
- if she went out, she would only have one drink
- she would start working more
- she would curb her spending
- (the fifth was the no sleepover thing)

OK, this is where we start to get into psychopath territory: he told her that if she disobeyed any of these rules, she had to call and tell him.

So anyway... she ended up talking to her dad about this, and told her that she wouldn't be following some of this stuff. Like the sleepovers and the church thing.

First he told her that she would be paying for her own cell phone. Understandable. Next, he told her that she would give him his credit card back. Fair enough. But then he told her that her medications and her doctor visits were all on her shoulders now. That's pretty unreasonable, because she's on medication for depression right now. When you couple this with the college thing... you've got to wonder what his agenda is here. But then, an adult is an adult, right?

The financial things are one thing, but he also told her that "you will not call me with all your problems" and also told her to "not ask for advice, because [he] won't have any." One more quotable for you here: "You will be choosing to go to the gutter and I am 100% confident that that is where you will be in short order. I am never wrong, that should scare you just a little."

If you can still defend this guy... I don't know what to say. Tough love is one thing, but being clinically insane is another. He's acting like he's basically going to renounce his fatherhood over her.

This is really tough watching this happen because she absolutely adores her dad. I really have no idea what to tell her to do. Obviously a lot of what he is demanding is good, but telling someone they can't have a sleepover or telling someone they have to go to church as an adult is... outrageous.
Sounds to me like he's mad that she isn't as religious as he is. This is why I'm not a big fan of overly religious people...they seem to be fairly intolerant.

Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10952
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Spider John »

I think Fat's spot on, Kyle. I'd take that advice.

User avatar
AdmiralKird
MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
Posts: 10178
Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
Location: Tycho Crater, Luna

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by AdmiralKird »

Kyle wrote:OK, update time.

What I didn't tell you guys that in addition to not sleeping together, he also gave her a few more rules to follow:
- she would go to church every Sunday
- if she went out, she would only have one drink
- she would start working more
- she would curb her spending
- (the fifth was the no sleepover thing)

OK, this is where we start to get into psychopath territory: he told her that if she disobeyed any of these rules, she had to call and tell him.

So anyway... she ended up talking to her dad about this, and told her that she wouldn't be following some of this stuff. Like the sleepovers and the church thing.

First he told her that she would be paying for her own cell phone. Understandable. Next, he told her that she would give him his credit card back. Fair enough. But then he told her that her medications and her doctor visits were all on her shoulders now. That's pretty unreasonable, because she's on medication for depression right now. When you couple this with the college thing... you've got to wonder what his agenda is here. But then, an adult is an adult, right?

The financial things are one thing, but he also told her that "you will not call me with all your problems" and also told her to "not ask for advice, because [he] won't have any." One more quotable for you here: "You will be choosing to go to the gutter and I am 100% confident that that is where you will be in short order. I am never wrong, that should scare you just a little."

If you can still defend this guy... I don't know what to say. Tough love is one thing, but being clinically insane is another. He's acting like he's basically going to renounce his fatherhood over her.

This is really tough watching this happen because she absolutely adores her dad. I really have no idea what to tell her to do. Obviously a lot of what he is demanding is good, but telling someone they can't have a sleepover or telling someone they have to go to church as an adult is... outrageous.
lol, ur f'ed.

User avatar
stlouie_lipp
Hallelujah Brother
Posts: 13380
Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by stlouie_lipp »

Spider John wrote:I think Fat's spot on, Kyle. I'd take that advice.
+++

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by Arthur Dent »

I agree with Fat.

That said, I think threats to withdraw financial and emotional support are totally inappropriate. In my limited observations, it seems to me that these threats tend to be ineffective and damaging to the parent child/relationship ultimately making other more positive forms of influence less effective. On the other hand, it's fairly weird that dad would still be paying for cell phones and credit cards. Is this common?

User avatar
clevername
Bringer of FRBG
Posts: 10380
Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
Location: Alabama

Re: Overprotective, Privacy-Invading Father

Post by clevername »

I agree with the give and take stuff that has to go on in situations like this, but I think it often leads to people like the father here having their beliefs confirmed for them as "being right" and end up leading to more problems down the line.

This guy's going to do the same thing with the next boyfriend. And the one after that. It won't matter when he's not paying for anything anymore, I'd bet he'd still "disown" her even if he wasn't supporting her. Until the girl dates some guy from his church no one will be ok with him.

Post Reply