Pre-Rave: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Pre-Rave: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Post by ghostrunner »

bumping this, with a great post I read on a blog.

I really, really don't want this show to be gone next year.
It's been no secret that I've been hating Season 3 of Heroes and loving Season 2 of Terminator : The Sarah Connor Chronicles, so I thought it would be interesting to try and understand why.

Both shows have a big enough budget to look realistic and have high quality production values, so it's not that one show is handicapped monetarily compared to the other, instead it comes down to the writing and the execution.

Heroes tries to throw an endless stream of action at the viewer in the hope to keep them entertained. It seems to me an artefact of confidence, it's as though Heroes doesn't believe that the writing will carry the episode. The Sarah Connor Chronicles on the other hand believes in the writing, it's execution is nicely stylish and often understated, focussing on the characters. Even moments that sound like they could be cheesey are pulled off: take the episode where Sarah Connor was reading The Wizard Of Oz to a young boy, whilst John battled a Terminator; lovely stuff.

What The Sarah Connor Chronicles succeeds at is creating a world of interesting characters, about which we are constantly discovering something. It's the classic story essence of creating a situation to which a character must react, where that reaction shows us something new about the character. And consequently we come to care about the characters, or at least retain interest in them. Even the Ex-Rockstar Scottish T1000, of which I have been critical, had an episode looking after a child, which showed us something about the robot and it's intentions.

In Heroes the characters decisions seem unrealistic and rushed with an emphasis on twists and stunt plots, Sylar becoming "good" for example. Lost is a show that does twists well, because they are often bonkers, entirely unpredictable and planned in there from the start (more or less). Heroes plot twists feel like an exercise in attempted viewer retention.

From the beginning Heroes has bet everything on the big spectacular story arc, almost at the expense of everything else. And it hasn't paid off, because the story hasn't been strong enough. The Sarah Connor Chronicles on the other hand has a well known ending, or at least a possible one, and the story concentrates on the small battles along the way.

I should also mention Lena Headey who does a really fantastic job of being Sarah Connor, I think she's great, and the show never ignores her. Heroes best character, Hiro, on the the other hand is given weak plots and sidelined for long periods. You would have thought that it would be obvious that more should be made of him.

Consequently, as a summation of all these things, I force myself to watch Heroes, and I really look forward to watching The Sarah Connor Chronicles every week, it's quality Science Fiction and I'm enjoying it immensely

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Pre-Rave: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Post by ghostrunner »

I'm getting my fanboy swerve on to note that :
[SHOW]
Kyle Reese's brother got bumped off "Departed" style tonight. No glorious exit, no heroics. Walked into a room where a Terminator was and - BLAM! - ragdoll.
Next week is probably the last episode, but it's going out with a bang so far.

User avatar
OmahaCard79
Veteran Player
Posts: 1101
Joined: May 23 06, 1:02 pm

Re: Pre-Rave: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Post by OmahaCard79 »

I'm really going to miss this show if and when it gets cancelled.

I hope they don't end it with a huge cliffhanger that never gets resolved. I'll be mad because I've been watching it since week 1.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Pre-Rave: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Post by ghostrunner »

Interesting article on saving shows:

http://www.thebigmoney.com/articles/imp ... te-tv-show
Trying to convince more people to watch a struggling show on TV is entirely useless. The television industry is not a democracy; the only votes that count—scratch that, the only people allowed to vote at all—are the 12,000 to 37,000 households that have Nielsen boxes sitting above their TVs. Nielsen boxes are poll stations for the Nielsen company—the organization that reports all of the ratings for the television industry. If Nielsen doesn't know you exist, then neither do the TV networks. And if the TV networks don't know you exist, then tuning in to an endangered show is a waste of everyone's time. If a show is turned on and Nielsen isn't there to hear it, it most definitely does not make a sound.

This is why "save our show" campaigns would be wise to stop telling people to watch more TV. They should start telling people to watch more TV online.
On that note, if you happen to be on Hulu or Fox, watch a Sarah Connor online for your old pal Ghost. Really, I think you can just call it up for a minute and close it:

http://www.fox.com/fod/play.php?sh=tscc

http://www.hulu.com/terminator-the-sara ... chronicles

User avatar
robbotis
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4791
Joined: April 18 06, 7:05 am
Location: Minneapolis

Re: Pre-Rave: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Post by robbotis »

ghostrunner wrote:I'm getting my fanboy swerve on to note that :
[SHOW]
Kyle Reese's brother got bumped off "Departed" style tonight. No glorious exit, no heroics. Walked into a room where a Terminator was and - BLAM! - ragdoll.
Next week is probably the last episode, but it's going out with a bang so far.
Unfortuantely I hear it's now canceled.
If that's the case, it ended awesome.
The final scenes were so cool.
[SHOW]
Just like the original Terminator w/ Arnold "I'll be back" storming the police station.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Pre-Rave: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Post by ghostrunner »

robbotis wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:I'm getting my fanboy swerve on to note that :
[SHOW]
Kyle Reese's brother got bumped off "Departed" style tonight. No glorious exit, no heroics. Walked into a room where a Terminator was and - BLAM! - ragdoll.
Next week is probably the last episode, but it's going out with a bang so far.
Unfortuantely I hear it's now canceled.
If that's the case, it ended awesome.
The final scenes were so cool.
[SHOW]
Just like the original Terminator w/ Arnold "I'll be back" storming the police station.

Not cancelled yet, but likely. Some places are reporting it, but it's mostly all based on a site that posted that a couple of weeks ago. Same blogger also posted a supposed complete finale review before it was aired, and it turned out to be complete BS. Her basis for claiming cancellation was that all the sets were torn down, but with the storyline where it is all the regular locations have been abandoned or destroyed in the story.

The hope now is that someone else picks it up, if Fox does drop it.

Post Reply