Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
editor
Fringe Major League Player
Posts: 128
Joined: January 10 09, 2:06 am

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by editor »

I've bounced back and forth on this subject too many times to go into detail but I will say this. If a woman doesn't want to have it, and you tell her that she has to have it, she will take it into her own hands via more extreme means to make sure she doesn't have it. It just amazes me how conservatives can be so pro-war yet claim they have some higher appreciation for life and be pro-life. :?

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by lukethedrifter »

Jocephus wrote:
docellis wrote:
wart57 wrote:Do you know what it is like to be a man? If not, using your logic, you should not be able to have an opinion on a mans subject, oh wait, that would be sexist.

This is my final comment on the entire thing. If you think you are mature enough to have sex, you need to be prepaired for the consequences.
I have never said that people who have abortions are evil, or that it was an easy descision for them, but someone needs to talk for the innocent lives involved.
I never said I knew what it was like to be a man - but that is irrelevant to the discussion since men can't have abortions.
dont be so sure about that doc

Image
Um, that's not really a man.

editor
Fringe Major League Player
Posts: 128
Joined: January 10 09, 2:06 am

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by editor »

maddash wrote:Here's how I feel:

A embryo/fetus is a living human, but not necessarily a human being
A 'human being' is a human with what we generally call consciousness
Consciousness is what separates us from other animals
If a fetus has consciousness, it probably (just my opinion) doesn't have it until the third trimester. In fact, it's possible that a newborn isn't capable of what we would call consciousness until months after birth
I think that most pro-life people make the case that killing a conscious and innocent human is immoral - and with a few exceptions, I would agree. But this argument hinges on what is consciousness, and when whatever it is actually begins.
Consciousness is a philosophical question that I don't believe our government should be in the business of answering.

I understand it creates a paradox, where our freedom to answer that question for ourselves can take away the possibility for a potentially conscious fetus to answer it as well... but not everything in life is as cut and dry as we'd like. I believe the freedom to make that choice outweighs its potential harms of the choice itself.

... of course, if you've read my posts before you'll see that most of this is just a construct. I don't believe humans have souls, I believe our consciousness is itself nothing more than a byproduct of a highly evolved brain. We're very smart apes whose morality is a combination of biological and sociological evolution. Any decision made on this topic by humans is solely to benefit the stability of our construct/society. There is no moral or immoral, only that which stabilizes a society that benefits our long term survival.
sorry for the double post.

But I completely agree with this post. Glad to see haltz is on-board too.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by lukethedrifter »

editor wrote:
maddash wrote:Here's how I feel:

A embryo/fetus is a living human, but not necessarily a human being
A 'human being' is a human with what we generally call consciousness
Consciousness is what separates us from other animals
If a fetus has consciousness, it probably (just my opinion) doesn't have it until the third trimester. In fact, it's possible that a newborn isn't capable of what we would call consciousness until months after birth
I think that most pro-life people make the case that killing a conscious and innocent human is immoral - and with a few exceptions, I would agree. But this argument hinges on what is consciousness, and when whatever it is actually begins.
Consciousness is a philosophical question that I don't believe our government should be in the business of answering.

I understand it creates a paradox, where our freedom to answer that question for ourselves can take away the possibility for a potentially conscious fetus to answer it as well... but not everything in life is as cut and dry as we'd like. I believe the freedom to make that choice outweighs its potential harms of the choice itself.

... of course, if you've read my posts before you'll see that most of this is just a construct. I don't believe humans have souls, I believe our consciousness is itself nothing more than a byproduct of a highly evolved brain. We're very smart apes whose morality is a combination of biological and sociological evolution. Any decision made on this topic by humans is solely to benefit the stability of our construct/society. There is no moral or immoral, only that which stabilizes a society that benefits our long term survival.
sorry for the double post.

But I completely agree with this post.

Is this to say that the idea of rights, morality, religion, natural law is a human construct? Because if so, I agree

editor
Fringe Major League Player
Posts: 128
Joined: January 10 09, 2:06 am

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by editor »

lukethedrifter wrote:
editor wrote:
maddash wrote:Here's how I feel:

A embryo/fetus is a living human, but not necessarily a human being
A 'human being' is a human with what we generally call consciousness
Consciousness is what separates us from other animals
If a fetus has consciousness, it probably (just my opinion) doesn't have it until the third trimester. In fact, it's possible that a newborn isn't capable of what we would call consciousness until months after birth
I think that most pro-life people make the case that killing a conscious and innocent human is immoral - and with a few exceptions, I would agree. But this argument hinges on what is consciousness, and when whatever it is actually begins.
Consciousness is a philosophical question that I don't believe our government should be in the business of answering.

I understand it creates a paradox, where our freedom to answer that question for ourselves can take away the possibility for a potentially conscious fetus to answer it as well... but not everything in life is as cut and dry as we'd like. I believe the freedom to make that choice outweighs its potential harms of the choice itself.

... of course, if you've read my posts before you'll see that most of this is just a construct. I don't believe humans have souls, I believe our consciousness is itself nothing more than a byproduct of a highly evolved brain. We're very smart apes whose morality is a combination of biological and sociological evolution. Any decision made on this topic by humans is solely to benefit the stability of our construct/society. There is no moral or immoral, only that which stabilizes a society that benefits our long term survival.
sorry for the double post.

But I completely agree with this post.

Is this to say that the idea of rights, morality, religion, natural law is a human construct? Because if so, I agree
yes luke. precisely that.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by Arthur Dent »

Morality definitely has a basis in nature/biology. There's actually some very interesting research ongoing on this topic right now.

User avatar
GatewaySnayke
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11923
Joined: July 23 06, 11:54 pm
Location: GatewaySnaykebird

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by GatewaySnayke »

I'm surprised this debate took off in the direction it did, because this was about the pro-lifers using a picture of what appeared to be a miscarried baby or mutilated fetus in the late, late stages of pregnancy. And I'm really surprised that anyone can rationally say that it's OK to prominently hang up that kind of disgusting imagery on a very busy street.

User avatar
GatewaySnayke
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11923
Joined: July 23 06, 11:54 pm
Location: GatewaySnaykebird

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by GatewaySnayke »

Molly wrote:I'm not jumping into the fray but you should change the title of this thread. Planned Parenthood is a pro-choice group.
Yeah?

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by ghostrunner »

GatewaySnayke wrote:I'm surprised this debate took off in the direction it did, because this was about the pro-lifers using a picture of what appeared to be a miscarried baby or mutilated fetus in the late, late stages of pregnancy. And I'm really surprised that anyone can rationally say that it's OK to prominently hang up that kind of disgusting imagery on a very busy street.
Are you saying it should be illegal or just that it's in poor taste?

editor
Fringe Major League Player
Posts: 128
Joined: January 10 09, 2:06 am

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by editor »

ghostrunner wrote:
GatewaySnayke wrote:I'm surprised this debate took off in the direction it did, because this was about the pro-lifers using a picture of what appeared to be a miscarried baby or mutilated fetus in the late, late stages of pregnancy. And I'm really surprised that anyone can rationally say that it's OK to prominently hang up that kind of disgusting imagery on a very busy street.
Are you saying it should be illegal or just that it's in poor taste?
I think he is saying it's in poor taste and implying it should be illegal.

Post Reply