Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by wart57 »

lukethedrifter wrote:
wart57 wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:The absolutist position that life begins at conception- no ifs ands or buts- and must be preserved at all costs puts one in a tricky position to argue.
Ectopic pregnancies? IVF selection? Extreme and nonviable birth defects? Mother's health?
My mother was told to have an abortion when she was pregnant with me because of a high birth defects, but mostly because she could very well have died carrying me to full term. She believed that I was alive, and that to have an abortiuon would be to murder me. If she had not believed this, I would not be here today.
I truly am glad for you. But step back and consider that if in 20 similar cases maternal death would have resulted from 15 and viable children from 2 would that be considered a reasonable tradeoff for you.
Please consider I generated the numbers myself to use for the purpose of discussion.
So now we need to put a value on each life, who's life is more important, the mother or the child.
Bad stuff happens. I know that if this was the case with my wife, she would have gone through with the pregnancy, to her the life of the child is more important.
But is this really the same thing as a woman getting an abortion because she does not want to be inconvenienced by a baby?

User avatar
docellis
America's Most Beloved Twitter Joke Thief
Posts: 24741
Joined: April 18 06, 6:54 pm

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by docellis »

wart57 wrote:But is this really the same thing as a woman getting an abortion because she does not want to be inconvenienced by a baby?
Yeah, I'm sure it is really that simple in all cases of abortion.

I'm sure a woman is sitting in bed eating bon bons and thinking "Oh I just can't be bothered with this silly pregnancy thing! Let's kill it!"

Personally I am against abortion - but I think it should be legal because I know that the above scenario is 180 degrees from reality. Nobody has an abortion to avoid inconvenience.

They have abortions as a last resort.

And don't tell me "They could have given it up for adoption!"

You're not a woman. You do not understand what a woman who would be having an abortion, as a last resort, would be facing. From society, from her family, from her employer....

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by lukethedrifter »

Popeye_Card wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:
wart57 wrote:Is the death penalty the same thing? Did that baby commit a horrible crime? For what it is worth, I don't believe in the death penalty. As far as justifiable killing, I am assuming you mean self defense, I believe in that, because the other person chose to try to kill you, so you are just supposed to sit there and be killed? The baby did nothing but had the audacity to be created when two people had sex. As far as war goes, who here is in FAVOR of War?
So then it's safe to say that you approve of having the choice to kill certain lives over others?
I'll be honest, you're making a pretty flimsy argument.

Your moral stance on abortion should be based on when you think a embryo/baby becomes a viable human life. If you believe it is a life as an embryo and still accept abortion as an alternative, then you have to personally make the moral decision that it's a life worth sacrificing for the well-being of another (the parents).

And the moral aruments are seperate from the political/legal argument. I am personally against abortions, but I'm pretty much on the fence when it comes to their legality.
I agree. Though I hold a position in favor of legalized abortion I have for the longest time had issue with many who share that position. In particular I find the position that it's hypocritical to be in favor of Capital Punishment and opposed to abortion to be ludicrous. This despite my position in opposition to CP and in favor of AB rights.

maddash
is eerily well-versed on Project Runway and irony
Posts: 8508
Joined: June 26 06, 3:07 pm

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by maddash »

Here's how I feel:

A embryo/fetus is a living human, but not necessarily a human being
A 'human being' is a human with what we generally call consciousness
Consciousness is what separates us from other animals
If a fetus has consciousness, it probably (just my opinion) doesn't have it until the third trimester. In fact, it's possible that a newborn isn't capable of what we would call consciousness until months after birth
I think that most pro-life people make the case that killing a conscious and innocent human is immoral - and with a few exceptions, I would agree. But this argument hinges on what is consciousness, and when whatever it is actually begins.
Consciousness is a philosophical question that I don't believe our government should be in the business of answering.

I understand it creates a paradox, where our freedom to answer that question for ourselves can take away the possibility for a potentially conscious fetus to answer it as well... but not everything in life is as cut and dry as we'd like. I believe the freedom to make that choice outweighs its potential harms of the choice itself.

... of course, if you've read my posts before you'll see that most of this is just a construct. I don't believe humans have souls, I believe our consciousness is itself nothing more than a byproduct of a highly evolved brain. We're very smart apes whose morality is a combination of biological and sociological evolution. Any decision made on this topic by humans is solely to benefit the stability of our construct/society. There is no moral or immoral, only that which stabilizes a society that benefits our long term survival.

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by wart57 »

TimeForGuinness wrote:
wart57 wrote:Is the death penalty the same thing? Did that baby commit a horrible crime? For what it is worth, I don't believe in the death penalty. As far as justifiable killing, I am assuming you mean self defense, I believe in that, because the other person chose to try to kill you, so you are just supposed to sit there and be killed? The baby did nothing but had the audacity to be created when two people had sex. As far as war goes, who here is in FAVOR of War?
So then it's safe to say that you approve of having the choice to kill certain lives over others?
They are not the same thing. If someone is coming at me with a knife or a gun, I am dropping him if I can, but to compare that to an innocent life that is just beginning is not even comparable.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by Arthur Dent »

Isn't defining "life" just semantic? The word can be formally defined to be whatever you like. The real question is what forms deserve protection and at what point. People don't agree on that, and defining life is really no help.

Personally, I don't see an unfertilized egg as completely different than a fertilized one. Both represent potential babies. Fertilization is just one of the many steps in the continuous development process. I really don't know if there is any well defined point where a group of cells turn into something that must be protected.

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by wart57 »

docellis wrote:
wart57 wrote:But is this really the same thing as a woman getting an abortion because she does not want to be inconvenienced by a baby?
Yeah, I'm sure it is really that simple in all cases of abortion.

I'm sure a woman is sitting in bed eating bon bons and thinking "Oh I just can't be bothered with this silly pregnancy thing! Let's kill it!"

Personally I am against abortion - but I think it should be legal because I know that the above scenario is 180 degrees from reality. Nobody has an abortion to avoid inconvenience.

They have abortions as a last resort.

And don't tell me "They could have given it up for adoption!"

You're not a woman. You do not understand what a woman who would be having an abortion, as a last resort, would be facing. From society, from her family, from her employer....
I never siad it was always the case. I guess since I am not a woman I can't have an opinion. Sorry to be a bother to all you women out there.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by lukethedrifter »

wart57 wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:
wart57 wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:The absolutist position that life begins at conception- no ifs ands or buts- and must be preserved at all costs puts one in a tricky position to argue.
Ectopic pregnancies? IVF selection? Extreme and nonviable birth defects? Mother's health?
My mother was told to have an abortion when she was pregnant with me because of a high birth defects, but mostly because she could very well have died carrying me to full term. She believed that I was alive, and that to have an abortiuon would be to murder me. If she had not believed this, I would not be here today.
I truly am glad for you. But step back and consider that if in 20 similar cases maternal death would have resulted from 15 and viable children from 2 would that be considered a reasonable tradeoff for you.
Please consider I generated the numbers myself to use for the purpose of discussion.
So now we need to put a value on each life, who's life is more important, the mother or the child.
Bad stuff happens. I know that if this was the case with my wife, she would have gone through with the pregnancy, to her the life of the child is more important.
But is this really the same thing as a woman getting an abortion because she does not want to be inconvenienced by a baby?
I don't get the bolded part. If you are asking a question then yes I believe we make a value judgment that the woman's life is more important.

As to the convenience issue, that is a problem, one that Planned Parenthood does more to address than any other organization.


Anyone have any guesses as to who/which organization is the largest contributor to Family Planning programs?

User avatar
docellis
America's Most Beloved Twitter Joke Thief
Posts: 24741
Joined: April 18 06, 6:54 pm

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by docellis »

wart57 wrote: I never siad it was always the case. I guess since I am not a woman I can't have an opinion. Sorry to be a bother to all you women out there.
Well, it is pretty consistent for you to take a statement to the extreme.
Last edited by docellis on January 15 09, 2:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31085
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Planned Parenthood Protestors Downtown

Post by Popeye_Card »

lukethedrifter wrote:This despite my position in opposition to CP and in favor of AB rights.
I'm pro-CP. One of the few planks of the Republican platform I can actually agree with. Maybe the only one. Though I'm not sure how much of a deterant to crime it really is (I think many would rather die than to be forced to live 50 years in prison), and as it's currently constructed, it's more costly to kill a prisoner than to hold him for life. I believe in an eye for an eye. The problem comes in proving guilt with 100% accuracy.

Post Reply