Rant: Indie elitists

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
PujolJunkie
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10370
Joined: March 22 07, 4:54 pm
Location: north county, stl
Contact:

Rant: Indie elitists

Post by PujolJunkie »

I'm not sure how many people will really get this rant, but holy crap I'm pissed over this. I've been having a debate all day about the fact that Joy Division's "Love Will Tear Us Apart" was covered by pop-punk band Fall Out Boy and the fact that the lead singers voices were completely and utterly opposite and the original is considered by many indie purists to be one of the best songs ever written. I happen to prefer the cover.

In this argument, I've had a friend of the friend I'm debating this over chime in and call me names and that I'm caught up in my generation because I listen to different music than he does. I proceeded to tell this person that they are a douche bag. This brings me to my main complaint: Indie elitists who consider their music the only music until a single blows up, ends up on the radio and the entire indie cred of that band is shot deep to Hell.

I am the type of person who likes all types of music. Everybody says it, but I have everybody from Lil Wayne to Conway Twitty(extensively) to Frank Sinatra to Motorhead in my music library. I don't care whether or not that band has 6 platinum albums. I don't care what they wear. I don't care if they've never been heard of. I just like music. I like the hip hop artist Common because his rhymes speak to the heart, it's true life and it's flowing artistry. I like the pop punk band Metro Station because they play upbeat dance style jams that just make me kind of hyperish. I like Conway Twitty because his voice is absolutely awesome and his style just makes me tap my foot.

Therefore, it bothers me when someone insults my musical tastes based on one artist. My friend was actually bashed on his own Facebook page for recommending a band to me and when confronted about it, he turned around and said to this person, no joke, "Man, that was before they got popular. After that I was like 'Screw this.'"

Is that really a valid reason for not enjoying a person/band's music? Because of it's popularity? Then how can this person justify liking Prince? Ah. Whatever. Music is becoming one of those things I refuse to debate.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by cards2468 »

I suppose when you know something before others know it, you'll feel entitled to have it and that nobody else can enjoy it. Sorta like a girl owning a pair of Uggs before they become popular and then being angry when they see every girl wearing them now.

As for the music, I think Bob Dylan is 1 of the best artists ever, but I do prefer the covers that come from his songs than his actual recording. Tell them that supporting the cover benefits the original writing through royalties they'll be paid.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Richie Allen »

That's the kind of emotion I like to see about one's music!

Elvis Costello once said something along the lines of when he was a teenager it was all about the music for him and his generation and the clothes and skateboards and whatever was secondary. Today, which was about 15 years ago if I'm remembering correctly, it's about the clothes and the looks and the image first and the music is secondary. A lot of people let things other than the music dictate what they listen to. It's kind of sad and pathetic.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Arthur Dent »

Richie Allen wrote:Today, which was about 15 years ago if I'm remembering correctly, it's about the clothes and the looks and the image first and the music is secondary.
I don't know about that. It's certainly true of bands that are getting heavy MTV promotion, but as a general statement, I don't think it's correct. I'm also not sure it's new. Image was a big factor in the early days of rock and roll with record companies constructing their own bands to fit a certain image. Even with great bands like the Beatles, it seems that many fans felt the music was secondary and preferred to scream so loud in their concerts that nobody could hear it.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Richie Allen »

Arthur Dent wrote:
Richie Allen wrote:Today, which was about 15 years ago if I'm remembering correctly, it's about the clothes and the looks and the image first and the music is secondary.
I don't know about that. It's certainly true of bands that are getting heavy MTV promotion, but as a general statement, I don't think it's correct. I'm also not sure it's new. Image was a big factor in the early days of rock and roll with record companies constructing their own bands to fit a certain image. Even with great bands like the Beatles, it seems that many fans felt the music was secondary and preferred to scream so loud in their concerts that nobody could hear it.
But I think one of the differences back then is you had to be able to make good music to be taken seriously. At least taken seriously for an extended period of time. Despite the Beatles being viewed by some as only being about the hair and "Yeah, yeah, yeah" they were also admired by people like Richard Rodgers and most every other band/musician/composer in the world. I don't think there's any debating their talent. Elvis, same thing. Sure he was a big movie star and glamor boy but he also took his music very seriously and made sure he put out great records.

Today, to be honest, I'm not sure what makes most of these performers famous. It's rarely a special talent that's evident to me. It's seems more about image, looks, connections, something that's not unmistakably obvious. Certain groups and performers, sure, I can see it. They write good music. They're competent musicians. Others, I'm left to guess that it's their coolness or something I don't understand. Which is why their fame baffles me and makes me wonder if it is, in fact, about the music for the fans of these performers.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Arthur Dent »

Richie Allen wrote:Today, to be honest, I'm not sure what makes most of these performers famous. It's rarely a special talent that's evident to me. It's seems more about image, looks, connections, something that's not unmistakably obvious.
Are you talking about top 40 type acts? If so, I think that's kind of an unfair comparison. There's a lot of completely forgotten top 40 music from the 60's too. The artists we remember are naturally going to be the ones whose music we still enjoy listening to rather than over promoted images that no longer resonate. Of course, I wasn't alive in the 60's, so it's hard for me to really know, but my impression is that the difference now is that there is a much larger quantity of music produced and distributed, and while they still make gobs of money, the "top" bands/artists are no longer as important.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Freed Roger »

Back when I was a metalhead in HS, what little pop music I liked was Milli Vinilli. So when the rastafarian guys were outed as lip syncers, I liked that music even more- because I liked the music. still do sometimes.

Those indie elitist guys (gals) sound like losers. feck em. In their efforts to become non-conformists with regards to musical tastes - they have become a herd. Music is so subjective anyhows.

BTW - I'm enjoying all the music threads on GRB. I'll plug in some random recommendations from these threads and put it in Pandora and end up liking it and related stuff it spits out. Up until recently, I generally listened to the same music (classic rock & classic mellow stuff) that I liked at college age. So much I missed... I mean this as a compliment - thanks music dorks!

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Richie Allen »

Arthur Dent wrote:
Richie Allen wrote:Today, to be honest, I'm not sure what makes most of these performers famous. It's rarely a special talent that's evident to me. It's seems more about image, looks, connections, something that's not unmistakably obvious.
Are you talking about top 40 type acts? If so, I think that's kind of an unfair comparison. There's a lot of completely forgotten top 40 music from the 60's too. The artists we remember are naturally going to be the ones whose music we still enjoy listening to rather than over promoted images that no longer resonate. Of course, I wasn't alive in the 60's, so it's hard for me to really know, but my impression is that the difference now is that there is a much larger quantity of music produced and distributed, and while they still make gobs of money, the "top" bands/artists are no longer as important.
Well, I think we've gotten a little off track of the original rant...the fans. I was simply passing along a quote from Elvis Costello who was comparing the British kids in the 60s and 70s to the kids of the 90s. I agree with it to some extent but I also think the fans of the 60s and 70s were far from perfect. They made quite a few embarrassing performers rich and famous. I suppose everyone has the right to like whatever they want for whatever reason but it doesn't mean no one can complain about it.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Arthur Dent »

Freed Roger wrote:In their efforts to become non-conformists with regards to musical tastes - they have become a herd.
This has been my impression of many self-described non-conformists outside of music.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Richie Allen »

Arthur Dent wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:In their efforts to become non-conformists with regards to musical tastes - they have become a herd.
This has been my impression of many self-described non-conformists outside of music.
It seems to hold true for most kids today. Sorry, pal, the baggy pant, pissy attitude, crooked hat, sideways peace symbol thing you do with your fingers doesn't make you a rebel. It makes you a dime-a-dozen teenager that's just about 15 years late from standing out from the crowd and being slightly cool.

Post Reply