Floods
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Floods
That's the bridge at Winona.
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: Floods
I'm a Water Resources Engineer, and I develop hydraulic models to determine the effects of building dikes to protect towns. I feel like I should give my 2 cents.
Building dikes actually does much more to raise flood levels upstream of the dikes than it does downstream because you create the bottleneck where the dikes are located. True, by building the dikes, you lose a little bit of flood storage in the floodplain, but it's actually not as much as you might think. The vast majority of the flow stays in the main channel area. Floodplains have to be extremely wide to start seeing significant effects of lost storage.
When dikes and bridges are built, there are regulations for how much they can raise the 100-yr flood level by constricting flow. Each state has a different regulation, but it's commonly 0.5-1.0 feet.
Every hydraulic system has a specified "level of protection", whether it be the 10-, 100- or 1000-yr event. The level of protection depends on how much harm could happen if the system failed - along with other economic factors. I don't work on projects to design dams or levees, so I don't know what there typical level of protection is. anyway, I've also been thinking about the "changing of the rules" and am curious about if/when/how the accepted rules will change. The "rules" for return intervals for flood flows will change much more quickly than return intervals for rainfall. When determining a particular (ex. 100-yr) flood, we typically examine flow gage data and determine flood frequency and return intervals. Therefore, the big floods get incorporated almost instantly. However, for rainfall, there are standard publications used with precipitation isotopes for various types of storms. It takes time to incorporate new data and create a new publication. On that note - I just researched this a few weeks ago - in Mpls/St. Paul, we've had exactly 6 storms in the past 60-yrs that were 10-yr storms or greater - perfect return frequency. Of those 6 storms, 2 of them were also 100-yr storms - not so good on that return frequency.
Building dikes actually does much more to raise flood levels upstream of the dikes than it does downstream because you create the bottleneck where the dikes are located. True, by building the dikes, you lose a little bit of flood storage in the floodplain, but it's actually not as much as you might think. The vast majority of the flow stays in the main channel area. Floodplains have to be extremely wide to start seeing significant effects of lost storage.
When dikes and bridges are built, there are regulations for how much they can raise the 100-yr flood level by constricting flow. Each state has a different regulation, but it's commonly 0.5-1.0 feet.
Every hydraulic system has a specified "level of protection", whether it be the 10-, 100- or 1000-yr event. The level of protection depends on how much harm could happen if the system failed - along with other economic factors. I don't work on projects to design dams or levees, so I don't know what there typical level of protection is. anyway, I've also been thinking about the "changing of the rules" and am curious about if/when/how the accepted rules will change. The "rules" for return intervals for flood flows will change much more quickly than return intervals for rainfall. When determining a particular (ex. 100-yr) flood, we typically examine flow gage data and determine flood frequency and return intervals. Therefore, the big floods get incorporated almost instantly. However, for rainfall, there are standard publications used with precipitation isotopes for various types of storms. It takes time to incorporate new data and create a new publication. On that note - I just researched this a few weeks ago - in Mpls/St. Paul, we've had exactly 6 storms in the past 60-yrs that were 10-yr storms or greater - perfect return frequency. Of those 6 storms, 2 of them were also 100-yr storms - not so good on that return frequency.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Floods
Very informative. Thanks.
Didn't rivers like the Mississippi historically have very wide floodplains?
Didn't rivers like the Mississippi historically have very wide floodplains?
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: Floods
Yes and no. It obviously depends on the surrounding topography. In Mpls, the Mississippi is in a gorge, so there isn't much of a floodplain. OTOH, after the 1993 floods, I was helping rebuild some places near my hometown in southern Iowa that were more than 2 miles from the Mississippi, but had about 10 feet of water. I remember seeing aerial photos of the Miss/Missouri confluence during that flood. there was water everywhere.Arthur Dent wrote:Very informative. Thanks.
Didn't rivers like the Mississippi historically have very wide floodplains?
Around Fargo, ND, the surrounding area is so flat, that Red River floods go everywhere.
Also, in order for an area to be removed from a floodplain after building a dike, the dike has to be "certified" by the Corps of engineers. Without the certification, then the area behind the dike remains mapped as floodplain and any residents in the floodplain have to buy flood insurance.
- fulldeck
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3239
- Joined: April 21 06, 7:31 am
- Contact:
Re: Floods
http://www.thehawkeye.com/Story/River-Web-061008
Flood warnings have been issued for most locations along the Mississippi:
* Keithsburg. The river was 16 feet and rising Wednesday morning. A 21.7-foot crest is expected Tuesday. When the river reaches that level, water reaches the top of the Keithsburg levee. It also affects grain elevators in New Boston.
* Gladstone. The river was at 12.6 feet Wednesday. The river is expected to rise to 19 feet Tuesday evening. At 17 feet, water reaches the tops of some levees in the Henderson Drainage District.
* Burlington. The river was 17.4 feet and rising. The river now is expected to 23 feet Tuesday morning.
* Keokuk. The river was at 16.5 feet and rising Wednesday. It is forecasted to rise to 23.7 feet June 18. At 23 feet, water affects Illinois 96 between Nauvoo and Hamilton.
Flood warnings have been issued for most locations along the Mississippi:
* Keithsburg. The river was 16 feet and rising Wednesday morning. A 21.7-foot crest is expected Tuesday. When the river reaches that level, water reaches the top of the Keithsburg levee. It also affects grain elevators in New Boston.
* Gladstone. The river was at 12.6 feet Wednesday. The river is expected to rise to 19 feet Tuesday evening. At 17 feet, water reaches the tops of some levees in the Henderson Drainage District.
* Burlington. The river was 17.4 feet and rising. The river now is expected to 23 feet Tuesday morning.
* Keokuk. The river was at 16.5 feet and rising Wednesday. It is forecasted to rise to 23.7 feet June 18. At 23 feet, water affects Illinois 96 between Nauvoo and Hamilton.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Floods
Great info. Gashouse, you say in Minn/St. Paul you had 2 100 year events in the past 60 years. Not too far from you in Houston County and over in LaCrosse/Vernon/Crawford county Wisconsins, I believe they have had 3 100 year events in 30 years. Is this correct? And wasn't the Houston County flood of '07 considered a 1,000 year event?
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: Floods
yeah, the flood last year was something like a 1000-yr event. Houston County was on the southern end of the worst areas hit last year, and on the northern end of the band of storms from last week. Obviously, the Man Upstairs is pretty pissed at them. I haven't had a reason to work with their rainfall data or flow data for that area, so I haven't looked at how many 100-yr events they've had recently.
Both events (last year and this year) were supposedly freak events. IIRC, last year, it was a remnant of a tropical storm that was moving north. Then it stalled and emptied the chambers on SE Minn - probably hit a cold air mass. I had to do some stream surveys in that area later in the fall. Even the biggest river (Zumbro) should have been pretty wade-able in October, but I couldn't even get 1/2 way across due to the high flows - still high as the watershed was still draining. We thought about putting off the surveys until the spring, but thankfully we didn't since Rochester, MN got about as much snow as Madison - well not that much, but they got hammered, too.
Then prior to this past storm, I remember the weatherman saying something about an unusual set of circumstances with the jet stream and air masses.
The 100-yr, 24-hr storm for Mpls is 6.1 inches. For Houston County MN, it's 7.0 inches. Read all about it:
http://www.sws.uiuc.edu/pubdoc/B/ISWSB-71.pdf
**One kind of important thing that just came to mind and has a HUGE impact on the floods (but obviously not the rain) is the unregulated use of drain tile in farm fields. no one except each farmer has any record of when and where drain tiles are installed. This has very significant impacts on rivers and streams. It contributes to erosion due to the higher flows in the streams - both immediately after a storm as the field drains so much faster, but it also effectively increases the size of the contributing watershed. Pre-settlement, there were lots and lots and lots of little landlocked basins. Now, they are all drained - causing higher floods and more erosion.
Both events (last year and this year) were supposedly freak events. IIRC, last year, it was a remnant of a tropical storm that was moving north. Then it stalled and emptied the chambers on SE Minn - probably hit a cold air mass. I had to do some stream surveys in that area later in the fall. Even the biggest river (Zumbro) should have been pretty wade-able in October, but I couldn't even get 1/2 way across due to the high flows - still high as the watershed was still draining. We thought about putting off the surveys until the spring, but thankfully we didn't since Rochester, MN got about as much snow as Madison - well not that much, but they got hammered, too.
Then prior to this past storm, I remember the weatherman saying something about an unusual set of circumstances with the jet stream and air masses.
The 100-yr, 24-hr storm for Mpls is 6.1 inches. For Houston County MN, it's 7.0 inches. Read all about it:
http://www.sws.uiuc.edu/pubdoc/B/ISWSB-71.pdf
**One kind of important thing that just came to mind and has a HUGE impact on the floods (but obviously not the rain) is the unregulated use of drain tile in farm fields. no one except each farmer has any record of when and where drain tiles are installed. This has very significant impacts on rivers and streams. It contributes to erosion due to the higher flows in the streams - both immediately after a storm as the field drains so much faster, but it also effectively increases the size of the contributing watershed. Pre-settlement, there were lots and lots and lots of little landlocked basins. Now, they are all drained - causing higher floods and more erosion.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Floods
What happened weather-wise (just using my amatuer eyes) in both events is that there was a distinct east-west line of very heavy storms stretching for a great distance. What was unusual was that the line had no northerly/southerly direction, it moved directly west to east. So if you were in the center, which those areas were, you got hammered and hammered for a long period of time. Throw in the 120+" of snow in that area and the ground is just saturated.
In the SW Wisco/SE Minn floods I'm not sure that anything really was a cause other than freaky weather. The farming is so small scale up there, all of it is done on the ridgetops and there is almost always a pitch to the fields so that water just runs off of there. I might be wrong, but I doubt that many farmers are installing any sort of drainage.
In the SW Wisco/SE Minn floods I'm not sure that anything really was a cause other than freaky weather. The farming is so small scale up there, all of it is done on the ridgetops and there is almost always a pitch to the fields so that water just runs off of there. I might be wrong, but I doubt that many farmers are installing any sort of drainage.
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: Floods
I was speaking generally about the drain tiles - not meaning to imply that they had a big impact on these 2 particular floods. I mean that they impact the yearly floods much more dramatically. I have no doubts that farmers there use them, but for both of those storms, the rainfall was the cause. Up to 17 inches in one location last year and places with at least 10 inches this year. That's just crazy for this part of the world.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Floods
Do you have stream flow info in addition to what you can find at the UGSG site?Gashouse wrote:I was speaking generally about the drain tiles - not meaning to imply that they had a big impact on these 2 particular floods. I mean that they impact the yearly floods much more dramatically. I have no doubts that farmers there use them, but for both of those storms, the rainfall was the cause. Up to 17 inches in one location last year and places with at least 10 inches this year. That's just crazy for this part of the world.
