Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11787
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by mikechamp »

Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
November 19 26, 4:10 pm
I do wish there was some way for a group representing the public / fans having a seat at the bargaining table.
Now you're sounding like an English football supporter.

:wink:

User avatar
Fan_In_NY
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5411
Joined: April 18 06, 7:22 pm
Location: Birthplace of Baseball- Hoboken, NJ

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by Fan_In_NY »

The owners gain more from a floor-cap systems than the players do for gaining a floor. The owners cost certainty will increase franchise value significantly more times higher than what the players will get from teams having to hit a floor.

I do think there is a push to get the TV deals to be more nationalized - thats a big benefit for the small market owners. Essentially boosting their revenue share. Big market owners don't want to do that, but will if they get a cap so that they dont need to bid against each other for no-upper-limit superstars. I don't think you get the big market owners sharing more revenue unless they some how get something else out of it - which has got to be the top end cap...or the creation of another revenue stream. I think they have already stretched the revenue streams related to the playoffs...can't possibly be more rounds...unless they increase the number of games in the DS round.

With any cap system we have seen owners differentiate baseball revenue from other revenue to not have to share with the players. Players are real skeptical of this because essentially the players are likely the attraction that is the draw. For example Ballpark Village revenue would likely be exempt from the revenue calculation...but really they generate their revenue because there is a game at Busch. Or catering at a luxury box is through a different vendor so that doesnt get shared with the players.

I think if the owners tossed back a portions of their increased value added to franchise sales after a cap system then I think you might see players come around to it. Like a value added tax, that the players get to share in - never going to be able to be calculated but thats the type of move needed to move the players to a cap.

nubapa1971
Single A Minor League Player
Posts: 1
Joined: November 20 26, 3:50 am

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by nubapa1971 »

I hear you, Popeye – a fan voice at the bargaining table would be huge. Even a modest advisory panel could keep the league from feeling like a closed-door club.

Online
User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30874
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by ghostrunner »

I think there's more to it than the owners being billionaires. Minor leaguers aside, every major leaguer who's played even half a season should have money to keep themselves and their lifestyle afloat for a couple years. Especially knowing this was coming. I'm sure not all do, but I think MLB and the union have gotten more proactive about educating young players on financial issues among other things. The union and other players are likely to help out those who need it. Owners can personally survive, but they also have business demands and debts that I assume they can't easily finance personally. Vendors, team staff, stadium staff, etc...

Here's that piece i was referring to earlier, and I got my baseball Craigs mixed up. It was Craig Calcaterra, not Goldstein:
All of that aside, here's what I think will happen:

The CBA expires on December 1 at 11:59PM. The owners will lock out the players effective at midnight, December 2;

There will be increasingly acrimonious and unfruitful negotiations from before then until everyone breaks for Christmas. This will be the time when the sides do their best to explain, publicly, how unreasonable the other side is being;

Things will quiet down a great deal in January, and from then until well into February it will seem like an agreement will never be reached;

In early March, the owners will begin to experience revenue loss. No one will be buying tickets, no one will be going to spring training games with just minor leaguers playing, and none of the counter-programming the league set up over a year prior will be particularly successful;

The owners – many of whom are leveraged like crazy and have debt payments to make – will be staring at serious, serious revenue loss in a matter of weeks. And no, it doesn't matter that most of them are billionaires and can cover the debts of the holding companies which own their teams with personal funds. Billionaires DO NOT pay money out of their own pockets if there is even the slightest chance that it can be avoided. It's simply not the done thing. To do so will get you disinvited to all the good billionaire parties and orgies and stuff;

By mid-to-late March great movement will be made, primarily because the owners will drop their demand for a salary cap. A new CBA will then be hammered out relatively quickly and an extremely abbreviated spring training will be held. That may not happen in quite enough time for Opening Night on March 24, but they'll race to get as close to it as possible. They may very will figure out how to squeeze in a 162-game season like they did in 2022, in fact, but at worst they'll do a 144-154-game season like 1995.

Maybe it won't go that way. I don't know. But if I had to tell a mysterious, elderly bridge-keeper how I think it'll go in order to secure safe passage, that'd be what I'd tell them.

User avatar
Joe Shlabotnik
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 24297
Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
Contact:

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by Joe Shlabotnik »

Anybod got deails on the owmership debt levels he mentioned? Didn't know about that.

User avatar
Lesson
Grandmaster Flashchat
Posts: 6632
Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by Lesson »

Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
November 19 26, 10:39 am
If you have a floor of $180MM, a lot more teams are going to have to spend. I don’t really care about the stars getting more. It should funnel more toward pre-arb players. Then when a team is looking at a smaller gap between a pre-arb player or signing a veteran, maybe they roll the dice on a free agent signing.
This is more of a critique on American sports vs international, but you're right that players are typically rewarded for past performance in the U.S. as opposed to future performance. It's not just a MLB thing either. Same thing applies with NFL, NHL, NBA. I do think the owners will have to concede on pre-arbitration year duration before FA, but that won't fundamentally solve the cap vs no cap debate.

I also think there are people owning MLB teams who are frugal to an extreme degree that shouldn't be owning and operating them anyway.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31100
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by Popeye_Card »

I'm not sure that I buy the argument that the billionaires will get super anxious when revenue isn't rolling in. They also have virtually zero expenses coming in at the same time. No different than the overhead they carry all winter long every year as games are not being played.
Lesson wrote: ↑
November 20 26, 9:47 am
I also think there are people owning MLB teams who are frugal to an extreme degree that shouldn't be owning and operating them anyway.
I think all uber-rich people are frugal to an extreme degree, some are just better at hiding it than others. 90% of our stock market growth is currently balanced on technology whose main value proposition is saving corporations money by slashing their workforce, so that they can "increase shareholder value". It shouldn't be too surprising that these same people want to pay baseball players less.

User avatar
Lesson
Grandmaster Flashchat
Posts: 6632
Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by Lesson »

Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
November 20 26, 10:02 am
Lesson wrote: ↑
November 20 26, 9:47 am
I also think there are people owning MLB teams who are frugal to an extreme degree that shouldn't be owning and operating them anyway.
I think all uber-rich people are frugal to an extreme degree, some are just better at hiding it than others. 90% of our stock market growth is currently balanced on technology whose main value proposition is saving corporations money by slashing their workforce, so that they can "increase shareholder value". It shouldn't be too surprising that these same people want to pay baseball players less.
The owner I had in mind is the Pirates owner who directly tied payroll to gameday revenue and pocket the rest.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by Socnorb11 »

Some owners are definitely tight-asses, but it's hard to just say that they shouldn't own a team though. Are more generous billionaires lining up to buy the Pirates, for example? What are the options?

I tend to agree with Popeye that owners won't be as financially vulnerable during a lockout as players. Most owners are literally billionaires, and baseball ownership isn't their primary revenue stream. They also know that a salary cap would stabilize budgets going forward, which would likely increase team valuations. They're smart enough to understand that long-term value, because they've seen it in the NFL.

Median player salary is $1.4 million. That sounds like a load of money to me and you, but after taxes I'm guessing that most players haven't been able to build much of a cushion. The union will help to some degree, obviously. Starting in May though they'll essentially being missing 1/6 of their annual income every single month that an agreement isn't reached. That's difficult.

User avatar
CardsofSTL
All Hail the GDT Master
Posts: 70105
Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
Location: Columbus, OH

Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor

Post by CardsofSTL »

Socnorb11 wrote: ↑
November 20 26, 4:15 pm
Some owners are definitely tight-asses
Link?

Post Reply