A lot fewer questions than last week. I did include 2 bonus questions: one about 5-and-10 rights and one about a SP that could be an option for the 2027 Cardinals. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/11/ ... t-926.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With Bauers signing with Boston, do the Brewers roll with Vaughn at first base or explore an outside addition?
Mark Polishuk
Some reporting from this week indicated that this might be Milwaukee’s direction, with Vaughn plus a prospect or two being given a shot. The Brewers could always re-evaluate things with an in-season trade.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Gorman traded or DFA’d?
Mark Polishuk
Maybe there’s another team out there who thinks they can fix him, but my guess is that Gorman is non-tendered by Friday’s deadline.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Hunter Greene and Matt McLain for Ketel Marte? Marte has baggage. Greene will miss most if not all season and McLain still has upside. Risk for both sides. Who says no?
Mark Polishuk
Arizona. The D’Backs still want to win something in 2027, and this trade doesn’t really help the team at all for next year. And even the future upside is a question mark given Greene’s health history and how McLain has done basically nothing since 2023.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Your gut…are Joey Ortiz and Garrett Mitchell both playing in Milwaukee next year?
Mark Polishuk
Yes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Arias, Abreu, Gonzalez, Delzine enough for Elly?
Mark Polishuk
This is the type of offer Cincinnati would heavily think about, and would probably ultimately take. It’s enough of an offer that I kinda doubt the Sox would float it, actually.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Given that the Cubs are apparently already out on Skubal, can they really be truly considered contenders? Not even trying for a top of the line SP when their rotation is basically empty in a huge market indicates that the team isn’t serious on competing, and there are a lot of regression candidates (will PCA really put up 10+ WAR every year?).
Mark Polishuk
Entirely agree. There’s no reason the Cubs “couldn’t” be in on Skubal, as the organization prints money.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Jays going to add Brandon Lowe?
Mark Polishuk
He’d make a lot of sense as a lineup upgrade, and Lowe is more proven at the MLB level than a player like Sato.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is the Brewers trade for Walker a flyer on a former closer or is this an indication of where things stand on Megill?
Mark Polishuk
Basically a flier. While it’s very likely Megill will be dealt, trading for a pitcher like Walker is something the Brewers would’ve done anyway.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Mark, with the Cubs needing a frontline starter and a cheap stop-gap corner outfielder, would a trade with the Twins for Joe Ryan and Trevor Larnach make some sense? (each on expiring deals, projected $16M combined arb). Who do you think the Twins would want in return in that sort of deal?
Mark Polishuk
Don’t forget that the Twins trying to win in 2027, so I doubt they’re moving Ryan unless a really huge offer is presented. Larnach is more readily available, especially since Minnesota already tried to move him at the last trade deadline. With just a year of control remaining, the team’s asking price wouldn’t be that big. The Cubs also need bullpen help, so they don’t exactly have a Bryan Abreu around to offer the Twins.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who is more likely to get extended: William Contreras or James Wood? Jim Bowden said that their respective clubs would love to lock them in extensions.
Mark Polishuk
Wood seems likelier to me. Contreras probably isn’t being dealt this winter, but it’s not usually Milwaukee’s style to extend an established veteran.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What’s the fix in Cincinnati? There is talk they don’t even have a budget yet? Is ownership trying to sabotage their chances again and waste what might be Elly’s last full year with them?
Mark Polishuk
I saw that detail from Gordon Wittenmyer’s recent piece about the front office apparently not having a budget yet. Though, if you’re Nick Krall, obviously you’ve got a pretty good idea about what your spending capacity will be. Krall isn’t sitting around with his fingers crossed thinking “come on, $200MM payroll, this is the year….”
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Jordan Wicks for Dylan Crews. Who says no?
Mark Polishuk
Probably the Nats, since they might want a similar ex-top prospect in need of a change of scenery. Wicks drew some top-100 attention but he wasn’t viewed as a blue-chipper like Crews.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What is Gleyber’s market? Would it be too hopeful to think the Reds would sign him?
Mark Polishuk
Not out of the question. It’s an open question as to whether or not Gleyber will finally be able to land the multi-year deal that has eluded him the last couple of years, but I suspect he’ll again have to settle for a one-year commitment. That puts him in Cincinnati’s range, though other teams will also be viewing Torres as a short-term, plan B type of addition. Maybe if the Reds are more aggressive now and view him as their Plan A for second base, they can jump the market.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could the Reds trade Steer for B Valenzuela?
Mark Polishuk
Man, a lot of interesting questions from the Cincinnati fans in this chat. Reds Nation has plenty to talk about tonight! This would be an interesting deal for both sides. Steer is the kind of multi-positional guy the Jays like, even if he isn’t terribly productive against RHP. Valenzuela might have starting catcher upside, and is more valuable to the Reds than he would be to the Jays as a backup.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does St Louis have room to make a splashy signing? What players would make some sense to break the playoff drought?
Mark Polishuk
How many fanbases are rolling their eyes at four years being considered a “drought”?
The Cards are another team who probably don’t feel the need to make a big expenditure. This is only year #2 of their rebuild, remember. While the team did better than expected in 2026, it still wasn’t enough to make the front office feel one big signing can get St. Louis back to the postseason.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could the Cubs fall off and into a rebuild letting the free agents walk out the door? Will they sign a good player?
Mark Polishuk
One can certainly take some issue with the Cubs’ approach, but the front office isn’t going to just sit on their hands all winter. Multiple pitchers will be brought in, at least one outfielder will be brought in, and Chicago (on paper) will probably be a pretty good team again in 2027, though obviously a lot depends on the quality of their acquisitions.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If a player with 10 and 5 rights gets traded (with their consent), do they still have no trade protection with their new club? Or is the “5” reset now?
Mark Polishuk
Once you hit 10-and-5 status, you have it for the rest of your career.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Shane Bieber: 1 year $8.5 million w $15 million club option who says no (and $1.5 million buyout) so $10 million guaranteed.
Mark Polishuk
A lot of teams would love Bieber at that price tag.
-----------------------------------------------------------------