Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on February 15.

Fewer questions than last week. Thankfully, you get 4 bonus questions: one about deferrals, one prediction, one about the Olympics and one about Trout that is NL Central-adjacent. (You'll see.) Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/02/ ... t-107.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Lars Nootbaar makes too much sense for at least a half dozen competitors. Is a May trade a legit possibility once health is proven?

Mark Polishuk
Probably closer to the trade deadline, just so the Cards have more time to gauge offers. An earlier trade wouldn’t be out of the question since Nootbaar has had some suitors in the past, so STL might have some idea of what certain teams are willing to give up in return.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Much like TB, the Brewers tend to win most of their trades. What needs to happen in order for Milwaukee to ‘win’ the Durbin trade? I was very surprised to see Milwaukee give up on Durbin so soon for unproven prospects and a utility IF.

Mark Polishuk
The deal also struck me as surprising, but it could be that the Brewers see Hamilton (and new signing Luis Rengifo) as being able to replicate much of what Durbin brought to the table.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are Suarez and Lowe enough offensive upgrade for the Reds to win the Central?

Mark Polishuk
Kinda confused by this question since Suarez signed with Cincinnati and Lowe was dealt to Pittsburgh.

I still favor the Cubs and Brewers over either CIN/PIT in the NL Central race, but the other two should at least be in wild card contention, and will make things interesting in the division.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I assume the Reds question was about Nathaniel Lowe – which is odd considering he’s just on a minors deal at the moment.

Mark Polishuk
It’s a sign of how forgettable Nate Lowe’s season was that I’d already blanked on him signing with the Reds, oops.

I doubt Lowe will be a needle-mover for the Reds, though stranger things have happened. Maybe getting back into a winning environment will help him regain his old Rangers form.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If there’s one thing I’ve never understood, it’s the way new GMs will put certain players lower on their charts because he’s not “his guy”, he was the previous regime’s guy. You understand what I mean? The Granillo thing felt like that, he wasn’t “Chaim’s guy” so maybe he was more expendable to him than Mo. We’ve seen Bendix do it a few times, too. I’m sure there’s tons of behind the scenes to it, but from a fans perspective I’ve always thought that was odd.

Mark Polishuk
Any two executives (even within the same organization) will have differing views on their prospect base. So it isn’t surprising that a new exec entering a team will look to get rid of the guys that his old team never valued, unless that exec learns some behind-the-scenes intel that changes his mind.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Brewers added and subtracted this offseason. I can’t tell if they got worse or are about the same. What do you think about their offseason?

Mark Polishuk
On the one hand they signed my offseason dark horse free agent darling Luis Rengifo, so I have no choice but to predict Milwaukee will now win the World Series.

On a more serious note, the Brewers had the kind of offseason I’d be worried about if they weren’t the Brewers. Their track record implies that they’ll figure things out and still be contenders for another NL Central title, but on paper, I don’t love their moves this winter.

It also doesn’t help that the Cubs, Reds, and Pirates have all theoretically gotten better.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------

I can’t see MLB getting a salary cap but do you think that they can eliminate deferred contracts in the next agreement?

Mark Polishuk
Some kind of limit on deferred money seems reasonable. The MLBPA will resist since they (rightly) will view it as a way of curbing spending, but in lieu of an actual salary cap, addressing deferrals could be seen as a bit of compromise.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will there be baseball in 2027?

Mark Polishuk
Yes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which current MLB player would be the best winter Olympian, and at what event?

Mark Polishuk
Eddy Alvarez played in MLB as recently as 2024, and he literally won a silver medal as a speed skater in the 2014 Winter Olympics.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How will Trout be remembered once his career is over? Will people remember him as one of the best ever in his prime?

Mark Polishuk
Trout is a first-ballot HOFer, and he’ll rightly be remembered as an all-time great.

Unfortunately, every discussion of Trout will inevitably include mention of his near-total lack of playoff exposure. He’s this generation’s Ernie Banks, the superstar who never got a chance to shine in the playoffs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Post Reply