Grade Bloom's First Offseason
-
Spider John
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 10952
- Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
- Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
His moves may not work out, but at least it seems like they have a plan and a purpose instead of serving up a a bowl of Mo's Do Nothing BS stew.
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
I gave him a B for leaning into the draft picks and moving expensive players. Felt like the value was more quantity than quality on a few trades and they were mostly boom/bust returns.
You can see they have either a plan or a mandate to see what they have in their position players and don't do anything to block any young position players from having a role. To me, you already know what Gorman, Walker, Saggese, Victor Scott et al are at the major league level and leaning into them and relying on them makes little sense to me.
At one point I asked a buddy if Bloom understands it's legal to acquire position player prospects.
You can see they have either a plan or a mandate to see what they have in their position players and don't do anything to block any young position players from having a role. To me, you already know what Gorman, Walker, Saggese, Victor Scott et al are at the major league level and leaning into them and relying on them makes little sense to me.
At one point I asked a buddy if Bloom understands it's legal to acquire position player prospects.
-
jagtrader
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12659
- Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
Can't block Nathan Church and Thomas Saggese. How will we find out if they're major league backups or just minor leaguers?
- Fan_In_NY
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5410
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:22 pm
- Location: Birthplace of Baseball- Hoboken, NJ
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
He did a lot - time will tell if the minor league system develops anything. But I think the most important thing he did this offseason/last season was loading up the development staff, getting some new scouts, etc. Odds are that only about 20% of the prospects turn out to be of any use, but he certainly has a plan - unfortunately it won't be until 2028 that we likely see a competitive team on the field.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30870
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
Bloom has said he wants to try and turn things around quickly. The easiest way to do that is money, but the amount needed to bring last years team up to snuff wasn't coming from these owners. So I assume the hope is by leaving all slots open, over the next season or two he can amass a base of players he feels is good enough. Then he can either sign free agents where the holes are or trade from what should be an even more improved farm system next year after the draft and probably a couple midseason trades.
I also wonder if he or his staff thinks some of these guys haven't been developed the right way, as he suggested about Herrera. I don't know what's gone on to that effect in the offseason with Gorman, Scott, and Walker, but maybe they think they have reason to hope for improvement. Doesn't seem likely, but also what is there to lose? You cut Walker and Gorman and you don't have much better internally. You could've added Eugenio Suarez and some other big bat for 1-2 years and this team still isn't in contention and I doubt it really helps attendance. Maybe one of the AAA guys surprises or Baez keeps coming on strong. I'm in the camp that doesn't about the runs or wins this year, as long as they're actually on a path to improving that later.
I also wonder if he or his staff thinks some of these guys haven't been developed the right way, as he suggested about Herrera. I don't know what's gone on to that effect in the offseason with Gorman, Scott, and Walker, but maybe they think they have reason to hope for improvement. Doesn't seem likely, but also what is there to lose? You cut Walker and Gorman and you don't have much better internally. You could've added Eugenio Suarez and some other big bat for 1-2 years and this team still isn't in contention and I doubt it really helps attendance. Maybe one of the AAA guys surprises or Baez keeps coming on strong. I'm in the camp that doesn't about the runs or wins this year, as long as they're actually on a path to improving that later.
- GeddyWrox
- Caught you a delicious bass
- Posts: 14716
- Joined: April 20 06, 8:43 pm
- Location: Please use blue font for the sarcasm impaired.
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
I'm also in the B/B+ range.
We won't truly know for another couple years though.
We won't truly know for another couple years though.
- TGantz
- R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
- Posts: 6698
- Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
- Location: The Lou
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
Very depressing. It's been beaten into the ground, I know, but I'm not over it yet.ghostrunner wrote: ↑February 17 26, 1:29 pmBloom has said he wants to try and turn things around quickly. The easiest way to do that is money, but the amount needed to bring last years team up to snuff wasn't coming from these owners.
Ownership is willing to pay incredible amounts for their franchise players to play for other teams, because ultimately it will save them a little money in the long run. They will have very few loose ends to worry about during a possible 2027 lockout. Yay.
Gray, Contreras, and Arenado committed to being Cardinals for years and by all accounts, were doing everything they could to win. The Cards didn't even miss the playoffs by that many games. None of the Central teams improved much this offseason except maybe the Cubs.
We didn't need Arenado out of the way for Gorman. Gorman has 1400 career ABs. That's not exactly a cup of coffee. Arenado is a decent bounceback candidate with him being decently healthy for the first time in awhile. Gray wasn't blocking anyone and is a solid contributor while also being a leader for the young guys. Contreras took all of Oli and Mo's BS on the chin and was still committed to the team. Still an above average contributor and leader.
They could have kept Donny and the three mentioned above while adding talent. Giolito or Ranger Suarez would have been a good addition along with May. They could have found a spot for E. Suarez to add some pop along with Bader.
Buuuut since they're all gone I guess it's May+Dick Fitts+Jose Fermin (reinvented as a 5th OF) instead of Gray+Contreras+Arenado+Donovan+R. Suarez+E. Suarez+May+Bader=Central division winners.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30870
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
Just using fangraphs' WAR ( I didn't compare the entire team, just the top 10 hitters in PA and the top 6 starters in IP for the Cards, Brewers and Cubs) if you do 2025 over and remove Pallante, Walker, and Nootbaar, give Arenado a boost and double his WAR (1.8 - which is still below even his '24 number), then add 2025 WAR for Bader and the two Suarezes, you're still 3rd in the division on those metrics. Cardinals bullpen would've made up some more of that difference, but still that's pretty iffy. And I would guess the Brewers bench contributes a lot more than ours does.
Doesn't appear that Eugenio has played anything but 3rd for years, so that'd be tough to work him in unless you DH him and move Herrera back to catcher. Now you're dropping Pages, who was 7th on the team in position player WAR in 112 games.
I think they needed 5-6 free agents in the 3-4 WAR range to threaten the Brewers for first place last year and then there's the Dodgers in the playoffs. Doesn't top them but you need to give yourself a fighting chance. The resulting payroll probably puts them 5th-7th in payroll and they've only done that twice since the DeWitts took over. Definitely not a place they're going to stay. And having done that, they're doing nothing to replenish the farm system which it seems everyone acknowledges was in bad shape. And that needs to be fixed both for developing their own talent and making trades.
Not making excuses for ownership, but I think we have a good idea what their own limit is and given Bloom's position I can't fault him for what he's done so far.
Doesn't appear that Eugenio has played anything but 3rd for years, so that'd be tough to work him in unless you DH him and move Herrera back to catcher. Now you're dropping Pages, who was 7th on the team in position player WAR in 112 games.
I think they needed 5-6 free agents in the 3-4 WAR range to threaten the Brewers for first place last year and then there's the Dodgers in the playoffs. Doesn't top them but you need to give yourself a fighting chance. The resulting payroll probably puts them 5th-7th in payroll and they've only done that twice since the DeWitts took over. Definitely not a place they're going to stay. And having done that, they're doing nothing to replenish the farm system which it seems everyone acknowledges was in bad shape. And that needs to be fixed both for developing their own talent and making trades.
Not making excuses for ownership, but I think we have a good idea what their own limit is and given Bloom's position I can't fault him for what he's done so far.
- TGantz
- R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
- Posts: 6698
- Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
- Location: The Lou
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
Thanks for the breakdown. It makes me feel a tad better about recent events. But it shows how far the organization has fallen overall which sucks.ghostrunner wrote: ↑February 19 26, 11:07 amJust using fangraphs' WAR ( I didn't compare the entire team, just the top 10 hitters in PA and the top 6 starters in IP for the Cards, Brewers and Cubs) if you do 2025 over and remove Pallante, Walker, and Nootbaar, give Arenado a boost and double his WAR (1.8 - which is still below even his '24 number), then add 2025 WAR for Bader and the two Suarezes, you're still 3rd in the division on those metrics. Cardinals bullpen would've made up some more of that difference, but still that's pretty iffy. And I would guess the Brewers bench contributes a lot more than ours does.
Doesn't appear that Eugenio has played anything but 3rd for years, so that'd be tough to work him in unless you DH him and move Herrera back to catcher. Now you're dropping Pages, who was 7th on the team in position player WAR in 112 games.
I think they needed 5-6 free agents in the 3-4 WAR range to threaten the Brewers for first place last year and then there's the Dodgers in the playoffs. Doesn't top them but you need to give yourself a fighting chance. The resulting payroll probably puts them 5th-7th in payroll and they've only done that twice since the DeWitts took over. Definitely not a place they're going to stay. And having done that, they're doing nothing to replenish the farm system which it seems everyone acknowledges was in bad shape. And that needs to be fixed both for developing their own talent and making trades.
Not making excuses for ownership, but I think we have a good idea what their own limit is and given Bloom's position I can't fault him for what he's done so far.
I don't blame Bloom at all. I appreciate his attempts at transparency, and I think he got solid returns on all of the trades. Ownership sucks.
-
jagtrader
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12659
- Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am
Re: Grade Bloom's First Offseason
If Jose Fermin is starting in LF on opening day, the grade isn’t an A.


