Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on January 25.

Just about the same amount of questions this week, but 4 bonus questions: 2 about the HoF, one about contract clauses and one about a possible lockout. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/01/ ... t-102.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who’s broadcasting Cincinnati Reds games this year: MLB or another entity?

Mark Polishuk
Unclear for now. Of the nine teams that ended their contracts with Main Street Sports, some (including the Reds) could re-up for a temporary one-year deal, or perhaps they just sign on to let MLB handle their broadcasts. Having the league do the broadcasts at least brings more stability in the short term, lest teams go through this whole thing again down the road with MSS.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Giants reported interest in CJ Abrams seems a little fishy. I don’t doubt they inquired, or possibly brought up a few names they might discuss, but it came across as a PR move to say hey we tried to do this. I feel like they have the pieces to get that trade done if they really wanted to. Your thoughts?

Mark Polishuk
I think it might’ve been a tactical move except not in the way you’re thinking. It might’ve been a hint to the Cardinals in the vein of “hey, we can explore other 2B options, so stop dragging your feet on our Donovan offers.”
-----------------------------------------------------------------
While the Mets got a huge ace in Peralta, I do wonder if it was worth Williams and Sproat for most likely just one year of Peralta.

Mark Polishuk
Stearns very likely thinks he can extend Peralta, or make a push to re-sign him next winter if he reaches free agency.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is there a realistic chance of a Geno/Reds reunion in your estimation?

Mark Polishuk
Given the Reds’ apparently payroll restrictions, it doesn’t seem too likely.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Why have the Cardinals not moved Donovan yet??

Mark Polishuk
Offers haven’t met their liking, simple as that.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does Cutch have enough left to be worth re-signing? Should the Pirates have honored him with a big sendoff last year instead of dragging him along?

Mark Polishuk
As per Cutch’s frustrated post on X, he isn’t pleased with his situation. The trouble with having a “sendoff” for McCutchen last year is that he doesn’t seem ready to retire.

The Pirates are kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place here. On the one hand, McCutchen is a franchise icon, and he deserves better than what seems to be “wait and see” treatment from the front office. On the other, McCutchen isn’t particularly productive as a player any more, and the Bucs might simply want to get a more useful player on the 26-man roster.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are Quintana or Jordan Montgomery a type of veteran starter the Cards are looking for?

Mark Polishuk
Those types of guys, yeah. A Monty reunion in St. Louis coming off his TJ surgery makes a lot of sense.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Cards trade from their catching depth? If so, who makes the most sense?

Mark Polishuk
Herrera’s health is the x-factor here. I suspect the Cards might’ve been more proactive about trading a catcher already if they had a better sense about how many (or any) games Herrera will be able to handle behind the plate in at least 2026. If Herrera is mostly a DH, then suddenly the Cardinals’ depth starts looking more shallow.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could Gorman be the A’s next 3rd baseman? He’s cheap and could probably hit 30 HRs in that ball park.

Mark Polishuk
The Cards seem more committed to giving Gorman one more last chance than they do of trading him. But, if Gorman struggles again and Wetherholt is ready to move into the 3B picture, Gorman could be a midseason trade candidate.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
is their room in the tank for a Yandy Diaz trade? Hes' a relatively affordable proven bat, and Singer could fit the bill for the return. That would also free payroll space which the Reds rave about.

Mark Polishuk
Trading Lowe probably closed the door on the chances of Yandy being dealt, though I guess in Tampa Bay the door is never entirely closed on trade possibilities. But, the Rays probably want more for their rotation than Singer, and Yandy is now an even bigger piece of Tampa’s lineup.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any chance Brewers extend William Contreras? Or are we going into his last season with the team before he gets traded and then we rely on Jeferson Quero?

Mark Polishuk
Very probable that Contreras is traded next winter.

That seems far likelier than the Brewers signing him to an extension, but I’ve been surprised before.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Your top 5 ballparks to watch a game at?

Mark Polishuk
Rogers Centre in Toronto, PNC Park in Pittsburgh, T-Mobile Park in Seattle, Wrigley Field, and Oracle Park in San Fran (if I remember to bring a jacket and toque for night games).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Brady Singer + Luis Mey or Zach Maxwell for Jasson Dominguez. Who says no?

Mark Polishuk
New York would want a lot more than that for the Martian.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Skenes or Skubal: who gets the bigger contract? Or are they waiting on each other to sign for this reason?

Mark Polishuk
Skenes will get the bigger contract since Skubal’s free agency is coming next winter. So Skenes will be using Skubal as a baseline for years down the road. Assuming Skenes remains healthy and dominant, of course.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If you’re Eugenio Suarez and the Athletics offer you a multi year deal and the Brewers offer you a one year deal, which do you take?

Mark Polishuk
Depends on how much the A’s offer is worth, but if this hypothetical has a similar AAV, I’d suspect Suarez might favor Milwaukee. He gets to play for a clear-cut contender, and in a Major League ballpark.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Andruw Jones is a Hall of Famer, can Jim Edmonds be that far behind?

Mark Polishuk
Edmonds is long overdue for a second HOF look on a veterans’ committee vote.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I am now 27 years old, which means I have now watched the full careers careers of players on the hall of fame ballot, and it has really re-contextualized voting for me. I used to be a “small hall” guy, using stats and JAWs to argue against fringe candidates. But now I just feel insane trying to argue Felix or Pedroia were not hall of famers after watching their careers unfold. Curious if you ever had a similar thought?

Mark Polishuk
Voters face this same conundrum in deciding whether or not to choose guys who “felt like Hall of Famers” even if their stats didn’t necessarily measure up. I do think Felix and Pedroia both probably get in eventually, since more writers will start to focus more on the “ten great years” aspect over the fact that these guys didn’t do much beyond that prime.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I have only really been paying attention to the HOF voting for the last decade or so, It seems that it is getting watered down with guys that I did not think of as HOF players when they were on the field. Is the HOF letting more very good players in now or do some of the old time guys in the HOF that I thought were amazing are actually just very good?

Mark Polishuk
We tend to elevate past players due to reputation or legend, when you’re right that in some cases, their actual stats don’t really measure up to what we’d consider a “HOF resume”.

And that’s not even considering the 20-30 guys who got into Cooperstown just because the writers liked them, or because they played for winning teams, or because they played with Frankie Frisch (who oversaw the veterans committee for years).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is it possible to create a contract that forces your team to be competitive? Could Ramirez have put a clause in to make CLE a top 15 spender? Or else he could opt out??

Mark Polishuk
The Guardians would never agree to such a contract. And, their response is probably also “we’ve made the playoffs seven times in the last decade, how is that not competitive?”
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How long will lockout be? Could 2027 season be lost? How much tax will Dodgers have to pay after this season?

Mark Polishuk
The 2027 season won’t be lost. Frankly, I’m not even sure any games will be lost. For now I’m thinking we’ll see a lockout and lots of sabre-rattling on both sides, but then an early-March agreement to preserve the full 162 games (just like in 2022)
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Post Reply