Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by dmarx114 »

Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:26 am
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:23 am
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:17 am
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:07 am
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 9:56 am
A 97 win team trading their best pitcher and another good pitcher for some prospects because they don't want to pay him (Peralta) is just as bad or not worse than the Dodgers signing everybody imo.

Teams that are good should not be trying to shed payroll and not pay their good players. But that's just my thoughts.
He's only making $8M, so I don't think this is a salary dump. I think it's turning a depreciating asset (age 30, final year of contract) into 2 really good prospects.

Didn't think my 25,000th post would be analyzing a Mets-Brewers trade, but here we are.

Hopefully post 50,000 in 2045 is about a Cards world series win.
Where the Brewers are currently, their sole focus should be "What can I do in 2026 to maximize our teams chances to win the WS", and trading your best pitcher for a couple of prospects does not achieve that. This is all due to owners being a cheap. There's a reason they haven't sniffed a WS in over 40 years. Brewers will continue to be good like they always are in the regular season and get smacked in the wildcard series or the LDS like they do every year.
I don't think the Brewers share your outlook. I think they look at it through the lens of "what can I do to maximize my chances of making the playoffs year in and year out?"
"The Cardinals Way 2015-2023"
I think our goal was similar, but not progressive to the point of trading away an ace in a season where we are a contender. We couldn't even trade away Helsley in a year where we were rebuilding.

Brewers have now shipped out Hader, Devin Williams, and Peralta during the off season before their final year of the contract.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by ghostrunner »

Yeah, I'm with Magneto. They just had 97 wins, highest run differential in the league, hadn't lost anyone else of significance, and they're trading their best pitcher?

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31085
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by Popeye_Card »

Well for his part Peralta has given up 7 HR in 25.1 IP over the last three postseasons for the Brewers. Clearly hasn't been helping them over the hump in the playoffs.

Magneto2.0
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 18100
Joined: June 16 07, 2:12 pm

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by Magneto2.0 »

ghostrunner wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:43 am
Yeah, I'm with Magneto. They just had 97 wins, highest run differential in the league, hadn't lost anyone else of significance, and they're trading their best pitcher?
Yeah I just think when you have a window of competitiveness, you should be focused on maximizing it rather than prioritizing future assets or playing it safe.

Because what happens when you make these moves for the future and the "good prospects" don't pan out, and now you're 5 years removed and you think back "Man, that was our best chance to win a WS and we didn't do everything we could to fill out the roster to give us our best chance to win".

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by dmarx114 »

I think it's fair to suggest whether a team should prioritize the short term over the long term.

But in this trade specifically, I don't think Peralta was traded cause the Brewers were trying to shed payroll in 2026.

User avatar
CardsofSTL
All Hail the GDT Master
Posts: 70085
Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
Location: Columbus, OH

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by CardsofSTL »

Seems like a hefty price tag for one season.

And if they extend him, I think he's going to hit the age curve hard ala Montgomery.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by phins »

Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:17 am
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:07 am
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 9:56 am
A 97 win team trading their best pitcher and another good pitcher for some prospects because they don't want to pay him (Peralta) is just as bad or not worse than the Dodgers signing everybody imo.

Teams that are good should not be trying to shed payroll and not pay their good players. But that's just my thoughts.
He's only making $8M, so I don't think this is a salary dump. I think it's turning a depreciating asset (age 30, final year of contract) into 2 really good prospects.

Didn't think my 25,000th post would be analyzing a Mets-Brewers trade, but here we are.

Hopefully post 50,000 in 2045 is about a Cards world series win.
Where the Brewers are currently, their sole focus should be "What can I do in 2026 to maximize our teams chances to win the WS", and trading your best pitcher for a couple of prospects does not achieve that. This is all due to owners being a cheap. There's a reason they haven't sniffed a WS in over 40 years. Brewers will continue to be good like they always are in the regular season and get smacked in the wildcard series or the LDS like they do every year.
I disagree here. Their focus should be on the long term health of their franchise and ensuring they can win for years. Maximizing your World Series window is taking your percentages from like 5% to maybe 8%. The error bars are vast and the marginal gains are tiny.

For me, trading depreciating players for top shelf prospects is the way to go. Odds are that Peralta will be only one WAR better than their replacement this year, while that isn't insignificant, the value gained just isn't worth the price of losing two usable/startable players.

And I think Williams ends up in CF.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by phins »

Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:46 am
Well for his part Peralta has given up 7 HR in 25.1 IP over the last three postseasons for the Brewers. Clearly hasn't been helping them over the hump in the playoffs.
And his metrics do not support his overall results and he's a prime regression candidate. The explanation I've come up with is the Mets didn't value Williams as highly as many of us did and Sproat saw enough regression in his stuff in 2025 they decided to cash him in now and roll with others (I'd have traded Tong instead if the Brewers would go for it).

Again, there is a solid chance that Henderson/Sproat are within one WAR of Peralta, with a non-zero chance they outperform him. Henderson was electric last year and the Brewers are magicians with pitchers, so they could get Sproat back to his changeup of 2024 and have a real dude on their hands.

I love the strategy and philosophy they employ and wish the Cardinals could follow suit with a little more payroll power.

User avatar
TGantz
R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
Posts: 6698
Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
Location: The Lou

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by TGantz »

phins wrote: ↑
January 24 26, 8:21 am
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:46 am
Well for his part Peralta has given up 7 HR in 25.1 IP over the last three postseasons for the Brewers. Clearly hasn't been helping them over the hump in the playoffs.
And his metrics do not support his overall results and he's a prime regression candidate. The explanation I've come up with is the Mets didn't value Williams as highly as many of us did and Sproat saw enough regression in his stuff in 2025 they decided to cash him in now and roll with others (I'd have traded Tong instead if the Brewers would go for it).

Again, there is a solid chance that Henderson/Sproat are within one WAR of Peralta, with a non-zero chance they outperform him. Henderson was electric last year and the Brewers are magicians with pitchers, so they could get Sproat back to his changeup of 2024 and have a real dude on their hands.

I love the strategy and philosophy they employ and wish the Cardinals could follow suit with a little more payroll power.
I don't want to speak for you, but I would guess you're a fan of their strategy due to your knowledge of prospects and the minor leagues.

As more than a casual observer, but not expert, I see them as the Rays. A franchise that always uses shoe string budgets and young guys to be competitive, then ships them off when they get good to start the process over no matter what immediate effect it has on the product. That would drive me nuts. No free agent to be excited about is ever added. Trades involve getting rid of the best players and having to rely on faith that the returning prospects will pan out.

I'd rather have Perlata now on a 97 win team. It doesn't help that he has a great personality. Imagine if the Cardinals traded Wainwright in his prime for prospects like Brady Aiken.

Edited to add- I fully admit to under valuing prospects and their impact. There is no baseball without prospects, and obviously some of them pan out. I'll just never agree with shipping out stars in their prime where we have empirical evidence of their abilities for prospects with 10x more variables that could go wrong. All to save money in a multi-billion dollar industry.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Post by phins »

TGantz wrote: ↑
January 24 26, 8:37 am
phins wrote: ↑
January 24 26, 8:21 am
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:46 am
Well for his part Peralta has given up 7 HR in 25.1 IP over the last three postseasons for the Brewers. Clearly hasn't been helping them over the hump in the playoffs.
And his metrics do not support his overall results and he's a prime regression candidate. The explanation I've come up with is the Mets didn't value Williams as highly as many of us did and Sproat saw enough regression in his stuff in 2025 they decided to cash him in now and roll with others (I'd have traded Tong instead if the Brewers would go for it).

Again, there is a solid chance that Henderson/Sproat are within one WAR of Peralta, with a non-zero chance they outperform him. Henderson was electric last year and the Brewers are magicians with pitchers, so they could get Sproat back to his changeup of 2024 and have a real dude on their hands.

I love the strategy and philosophy they employ and wish the Cardinals could follow suit with a little more payroll power.
I don't want to speak for you, but I would guess you're a fan of their strategy due to your knowledge of prospects and the minor leagues.

As more than a casual observer, but not expert, I see them as the Rays. A franchise that always uses shoe string budgets and young guys to be competitive, then ships them off when they get good to start the process over no matter what immediate effect it has on the product. That would drive me nuts. No free agent to be excited about is ever added. Trades involve getting rid of the best players and having to rely on faith that the returning prospects will pan out.

I'd rather have Perlata now on a 97 win team. It doesn't help that he has a great personality. Imagine if the Cardinals traded Wainwright in his prime for prospects like Brady Aiken.

Edited to add- I fully admit to under valuing prospects and their impact. There is no baseball without prospects, and obviously some of them pan out. I'll just never agree with shipping out stars in their prime where we have empirical evidence of their abilities for prospects with 10x more variables that could go wrong. All to save money in a multi-billion dollar industry.
I'm certainly not here to try and change your mind. You get to decide what's important to you and how you want to see the see team run.

For me, it's all situation dependent. I believe the substitutes (replacements for Peralta) will replace him just fine, if not exceed him. Plus getting a player I think can start in Jett Williams. It's all about value and sustainability for me.

In my view, they took themselves from a 97-win team to a 96-win team (illustrative, that's not their baseline). That's the 50th percentile outcome, with outcomes where they actually better this season by swapping out Peralta for Henderson/Sproat/Williams.

Post Reply