mikechamp wrote: ↑January 14 26, 12:36 pm
heyzeus wrote: ↑January 14 26, 10:47 am
I will miss his Hall of Very Good bus.
You don't think he's going in the HoF?
It's a good question. He's at 51.6 WAR currently and I don't see that going up a lot higher. Edmonds' candidacy went like a fart in the wind at 64.5 career WAR, and Berkman went nowhere at 55.9.
But they're not third basemen, and Arenado had a great peak and great defensive rep too. His close comp as of now is Ron Cey (55.6 WAR), who isn't in, or Evan Longoria (58.9 WAR), eligible in 2028.
To me, it feels like Arenado is a bit short of the Scott Rolen/Ron Santo threshold. There really aren't a ton of 3Bs in the Hall, which is unfair since it's a tough position that has to be great defensively (footwork, arm) and also is expected to hit well.