MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
Fan_In_NY
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5410
Joined: April 18 06, 7:22 pm
Location: Birthplace of Baseball- Hoboken, NJ

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Fan_In_NY »

MrCrowesGarden wrote: ↑
January 14 26, 12:31 am
How many years did Mo set us back? I mean, I know the answer is "zero" if Dewitt spent like he should have.
I think it was more the lack of resources/investment in player development/scouting over anything else. Now I'm not sure if that's a Dewitt spending guideline as I think the cost of player development/scouting is sooo low when considering overall payroll.

If Dewitt opened the wallet and let Mo spend last off-season and he dug into the 6th-16th AAV in the market (because I dont think the Cardinals ever will mess with the top 5 players in a given season) you are looking at a list of Alonso, Adames, Manaea, Eovaldi, Severino, Teoscar Hernandez, Kikuchi, Nick Martinez, Buehler, Christian Walker, Joc Pederson.

If anything the Cardinals would be set back further if they had signed almost any of them, and would be doubly bad if they paid for 2 of them.

The 2024 Free Agency Season that 6th-16th group looks like - Sonny Gray, Nola, Teoscar, Eduardo Rodriguez, Giolito, Hader, Jung Hoo Lee, Stroman, Max Chapman, Hoskins, Frankie Montas.

Again heavily weighted to that group being more negative than positive in turning around the Cardinals fortune.

The 2023 Free Agency that 6th-16th group looks like - Rodon, Bogaerts, Swanson, Bassitt, Edwin Diaz, Nimmo, Kershaw, Rizzo, Martin Perez, Joc Pederson, Jose Abreu.

A couple of names that would have been interesting, but again more duds than studs.

Unless there is some natural tie to the area the Cards aren't getting the Soto, Judge, Shohei free agents. The ones in this 6th-16th range are fine to take the chance as a missing piece, but you really need to draft, develop, re-sign and make shrewd trades because its dangerous to keep dipping into that pool. Mo failed to do any of that - and in fact generally the talent was so poor there arent even many cases that there were players that were worth re-signing.

So more than a $$ issue (although I have zero sympathy for an ownership group that keeps raising ticket prices and asks for even a penny of tax money or an ounce of sympathy towards maintaining their stadium while having this terrible team on the field) I fault Dewitt for not recognizing that Mo was failing at major aspects of his job in terms of being responsible for the whole organizations talent pool.

User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

Fan_In_NY wrote: ↑
January 14 26, 12:54 am
MrCrowesGarden wrote: ↑
January 14 26, 12:31 am
How many years did Mo set us back? I mean, I know the answer is "zero" if Dewitt spent like he should have.
I think it was more the lack of resources/investment in player development/scouting over anything else. Now I'm not sure if that's a Dewitt spending guideline as I think the cost of player development/scouting is sooo low when considering overall payroll.

If Dewitt opened the wallet and let Mo spend last off-season and he dug into the 6th-16th AAV in the market (because I dont think the Cardinals ever will mess with the top 5 players in a given season) you are looking at a list of Alonso, Adames, Manaea, Eovaldi, Severino, Teoscar Hernandez, Kikuchi, Nick Martinez, Buehler, Christian Walker, Joc Pederson.

If anything the Cardinals would be set back further if they had signed almost any of them, and would be doubly bad if they paid for 2 of them.

The 2024 Free Agency Season that 6th-16th group looks like - Sonny Gray, Nola, Teoscar, Eduardo Rodriguez, Giolito, Hader, Jung Hoo Lee, Stroman, Max Chapman, Hoskins, Frankie Montas.

Again heavily weighted to that group being more negative than positive in turning around the Cardinals fortune.

The 2023 Free Agency that 6th-16th group looks like - Rodon, Bogaerts, Swanson, Bassitt, Edwin Diaz, Nimmo, Kershaw, Rizzo, Martin Perez, Joc Pederson, Jose Abreu.

A couple of names that would have been interesting, but again more duds than studs.

Unless there is some natural tie to the area the Cards aren't getting the Soto, Judge, Shohei free agents. The ones in this 6th-16th range are fine to take the chance as a missing piece, but you really need to draft, develop, re-sign and make shrewd trades because its dangerous to keep dipping into that pool. Mo failed to do any of that - and in fact generally the talent was so poor there arent even many cases that there were players that were worth re-signing.

So more than a $$ issue (although I have zero sympathy for an ownership group that keeps raising ticket prices and asks for even a penny of tax money or an ounce of sympathy towards maintaining their stadium while having this terrible team on the field) I fault Dewitt for not recognizing that Mo was failing at major aspects of his job in terms of being responsible for the whole organizations talent pool.
They absolutely should dip into that top 5 free agent pool though. Everyone says can't but nothing is possible until it is.

But Mo idled. Analysis paralysis.

jagtrader
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12659
Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by jagtrader »

The plan seems to be to have a sub-$100 million payroll. That means this process of unloading every possible contract should've happened last winter. If you didn't have the person in place to make those changes, you should find a different person. Sitting still for a year was just idiocy. It has caused unnecessary pain by delaying the rebuild.

User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Famous Mortimer »

"If you ignore the best players, the free agent market sucks" is an interesting take

User avatar
CardsofSTL
All Hail the GDT Master
Posts: 70085
Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
Location: Columbus, OH

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by CardsofSTL »


User avatar
Lesson
Grandmaster Flashchat
Posts: 6630
Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Lesson »

jagtrader wrote: ↑
January 14 26, 6:58 am
The plan seems to be to have a sub-$100 million payroll. That means this process of unloading every possible contract should've happened last winter. If you didn't have the person in place to make those changes, you should find a different person. Sitting still for a year was just idiocy. It has caused unnecessary pain by delaying the rebuild.
I think the FO didn't want to fully commit to a rebuild based off 2024 and thought running it back with a full-season of Fedde in-place would have led to a WC berth while letting Mo take the brunt of any criticism and having Bloom deal with the aftermath.
Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
January 14 26, 7:59 am
"If you ignore the best players, the free agent market sucks" is an interesting take
I don't think that is what @Fan_In_NY is trying to convey.
MrCrowesGarden wrote: ↑
January 14 26, 5:22 am
They absolutely should dip into that top 5 free agent pool though. Everyone says can't but nothing is possible until it is.

But Mo idled. Analysis paralysis.
Maybe a few years ago, sure, but not recently with the impending lockout + TV contract situation.

Slider
All-Star
Posts: 1645
Joined: July 23 08, 2:36 pm

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Slider »

Couple random thoughts.
1. A little weird to see rumors now that Donavan might be packaged with either JoJo or Noot to complete a trade.

2. Is Ivan going to catch? Pages and Pozo both are under team control. Can’t see either going to the minors and then there is Crooks. Early on there was talk of trading Pages, which made the Pozo signing make sense. But if he is not traded, are we splitting catching time between three guys?

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31085
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Popeye_Card »

Well we only can apparently trade with like 4 teams, so it makes sense that Donovan, JoJo, and/or Noot will be going to one of those 4 whether they are packaged together or not.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by ghostrunner »

Slider wrote: ↑
January 16 26, 9:27 am
Couple random thoughts.
1. A little weird to see rumors now that Donavan might be packaged with either JoJo or Noot to complete a trade.

2. Is Ivan going to catch? Pages and Pozo both are under team control. Can’t see either going to the minors and then there is Crooks. Early on there was talk of trading Pages, which made the Pozo signing make sense. But if he is not traded, are we splitting catching time between three guys?
My impression is they plan to have Herrera catch. Bloom made a comment a month or so back suggesting the system hadn't prepared him very well.

https://redbirdrants.com/chaim-bloom-su ... l-disarray

More in that article, but this is the gist:
"I don't think, when you look a the entirety of his career, I'm not sure he was ever really set up for success at that position because of a number of factors ... Some of it's just about the state of the organization, what else is a available at the position internally where you might not get that fair shot, and yet you're being asked to perform in the big leagues, so you're not in a fair teaching environment."

Pozo signed a minor league contract, so I assume for now it'll be Herrera and Pages backing up, and Gorman at DH most of the time.

Slider
All-Star
Posts: 1645
Joined: July 23 08, 2:36 pm

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Slider »

ghostrunner wrote: ↑
January 16 26, 10:52 am
Slider wrote: ↑
January 16 26, 9:27 am
Couple random thoughts.
1. A little weird to see rumors now that Donavan might be packaged with either JoJo or Noot to complete a trade.

2. Is Ivan going to catch? Pages and Pozo both are under team control. Can’t see either going to the minors and then there is Crooks. Early on there was talk of trading Pages, which made the Pozo signing make sense. But if he is not traded, are we splitting catching time between three guys?
My impression is they plan to have Herrera catch. Bloom made a comment a month or so back suggesting the system hadn't prepared him very well.

https://redbirdrants.com/chaim-bloom-su ... l-disarray

More in that article, but this is the gist:
"I don't think, when you look a the entirety of his career, I'm not sure he was ever really set up for success at that position because of a number of factors ... Some of it's just about the state of the organization, what else is a available at the position internally where you might not get that fair shot, and yet you're being asked to perform in the big leagues, so you're not in a fair teaching environment."

Pozo signed a minor league contract, so I assume for now it'll be Herrera and Pages backing up, and Gorman at DH most of the time.
Pozo signed a major league contract. That is what spurred the idea of Pages being traded. The major league contract was confusing at the time given Bloom’s comments about Ivan and having Pages already.

Post Reply