I know this was from a couple weeks back, but I took some time to relax and am just now catching up. Some of the Q&As might be dated, but others are not.
More questions than last time, but no bonus questions. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/12/ ... at-95.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any chance the O's are still in on Kyle Tucker?
Mark Polishuk
Probably not. If the O’s make another big strike, it would likely be for pitching.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see Arenado or Castellanos ending up with the Padres?
Mark Polishuk
Arenado makes no sense given Machado’s presence at 3B. Castellanos is a slightly better fit since SD isn’t entirely settled at DH, but if the Padres want an outfield bat, they can do a lot better.
I guess Preller and Dombrowski might be able to come up with some kind of interesting bad contract swap, but I don’t really see a fit here.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What is the best return the Cards can get for JoJo? And can put a top 15 kid with Nolan to get a better return?
Mark Polishuk
Likewise, a rebuilding team like the Cardinals isn’t likely to move any kind of notable prospect along with Arenado just to help a trade go through. The Cards have shown they’ll just eat some salary to accommodate these deals in order to help improve the returns.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What would it cost to get Santander from Blue Jays for the Reds?
Mark Polishuk
Hard to see a trade match there. If you’re the Reds and you’re in need of offensive help, surely you’d want someone who a) isn’t so expensive, and b) isn’t coming off essentially a non-starter of a 2025 season.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are Yankees in on Tucker at all and is Tucker objectively the better player than Bellinger or not?
Mark Polishuk
Reports indicate that Tucker is a backup plan if Bellinger can’t be re-signed. That’s kind of interesting framing that the far more expensive player is the “plan B” since in theory, Tucker is more difficult to sign. But, the Yankees seem to have correctly gauged Tucker’s market as limited to just a few teams, so they have the ability to wait and see on both him and Bellinger.
Objectively, Tucker is certainly the more consistent and better player than Bellinger, as evidenced by their numbers over the last few seasons. Whether that’s worth, say, an extra $200MM gap or more in salary remains to be seen, in terms of the Yankees and other teams are evaluating the two.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Chances of Okamoto going to the Pirates?
Mark Polishuk
Probably seems unlikely. While the Bucs have been busy in adding offense (and willing to spend some money), Okamoto’s probably not going to Pittsburgh unless his market really collapses.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who is favored to sign Imai? Do the Cubs have a legit chance? There’s only a week left for him to sign.
Mark Polishuk
There doesn’t appear to be a clear favorite for Imai, but the Cubs have been linked to him and would appear to have as much of a shot as anyone in the field. The Cubs have a history of landing top-level Japanese talent, and Imai might fall within the Cubs’ “spend pretty big but not TOO big” price range.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What kind of pitching return are the Sox looking for in a Luis Robert trade with the Reds? Chase Petty?
Mark Polishuk
Chris Getz would sign off on that deal right now if Cincinnati offered Petty for Robert, but that’s not going to happen. As rough as Petty’s 2025 season was, he is still highly regarded as a prospect, and not someone the Reds would be too willing to dangle for a player with as many question marks as Robert (and at his price tag).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would Tucker accept a short-term, high AAV deal to join a contender?
Mark Polishuk
Hey look, it’s Andrew Friedman’s burner account!
If Tucker’s market really doesn’t develop as expected, a shorter-term deal is a possibility. But it’s not so late in the offseason that his camp needs to be panicking yet, and I suspect Tucker still lands a lengthy mega-deal.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How do u feel about what the Pirates done so far?
Mark Polishuk
I’ve been impressed. The Buccos brought in a couple of proven veteran hitters, a very intriguing MLB-ready player in Garcia, and a bit of a lottery ticket with upside in Mangum. And, they’ve done this while not dipping too deeply into their rotation mix.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
FO is high on Jefferson Quero. If the Brewers were to trade Contreras would that be a complete shock – 2 years before free agency – and what chance you give that happening?
Mark Polishuk
It would be a real surprise if it happened now. The trade whispers about Contreras will get a lot louder by this time next year, but there’s very little chance the Brewers will deal an All-Star catcher now and roll with Quero + stopgap veteran catcher when they’re trying to win a World Series.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Nootbaar is not going anywhere until the deadline, if at all, correct?
Mark Polishuk
Probably not.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
