Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11769
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois
Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Anthony Franco that occurred on December 12. (You can find him on Twitter at @affranco10 if you really want to ask him something.)
His chats only happen behind their paywall now, but they gave enough of a preview that I could cobble a few divisional Q&As together for everyone. Enjoy!
The link to the truncated chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/12/ ... al-53.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Four guys under contract (Hayes, Greene, Trevino, Pagan) and less than $80 million in payroll per BR. They can't be serious about not signing anyone, right?
Anthony Franco
Not sure where you've got the sub-$80M mark but I think they're more like 105 once you factor in arb projections and minimum salary players to build out the roster.
They should've non-tendered Lux and should still shop him and Steer, kick around ideas about swapping Singer for a bat. I don't expect them to do much in free agency, though.
They've never gone beyond $64M on a free agent and Schwarber was a special case from ownership's perspective.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is there a taker for Willson Contreras if he waives the no trade? Mets? Someone else?
Anthony Franco
Mets make the most sense, Boston could work there. Arizona, San Diego, Texas all fit positionally but probably require the Cards to eat more than half the money.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Kyle Tucker, Framber Valdez, or Bo Bichette - who do you think signs first of this trio?
Anthony Franco
I'll take Bo, largely on the assumption that he goes back to Toronto.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If a team loves the Rule 5 player they chose, but don't really want to keep him on the MLB roster all season per the MLB rules, can they work out a deal with his previous team to keep him or must they pass him through waivers first, and then if he passed through waivers, must offer him back to his previous team?
Anthony Franco
Needs to go through waivers and get offered back to the original team first. They can then try to trade for him back, which does happen sometimes -- usually for cash.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
His chats only happen behind their paywall now, but they gave enough of a preview that I could cobble a few divisional Q&As together for everyone. Enjoy!
The link to the truncated chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/12/ ... al-53.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Four guys under contract (Hayes, Greene, Trevino, Pagan) and less than $80 million in payroll per BR. They can't be serious about not signing anyone, right?
Anthony Franco
Not sure where you've got the sub-$80M mark but I think they're more like 105 once you factor in arb projections and minimum salary players to build out the roster.
They should've non-tendered Lux and should still shop him and Steer, kick around ideas about swapping Singer for a bat. I don't expect them to do much in free agency, though.
They've never gone beyond $64M on a free agent and Schwarber was a special case from ownership's perspective.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is there a taker for Willson Contreras if he waives the no trade? Mets? Someone else?
Anthony Franco
Mets make the most sense, Boston could work there. Arizona, San Diego, Texas all fit positionally but probably require the Cards to eat more than half the money.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Kyle Tucker, Framber Valdez, or Bo Bichette - who do you think signs first of this trio?
Anthony Franco
I'll take Bo, largely on the assumption that he goes back to Toronto.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If a team loves the Rule 5 player they chose, but don't really want to keep him on the MLB roster all season per the MLB rules, can they work out a deal with his previous team to keep him or must they pass him through waivers first, and then if he passed through waivers, must offer him back to his previous team?
Anthony Franco
Needs to go through waivers and get offered back to the original team first. They can then try to trade for him back, which does happen sometimes -- usually for cash.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
- Famous Mortimer
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3961
- Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
- Location: Cherokee
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
If the Cardinals are going to have to eat money to trade Contreras, then...why not just keep him? How low-chance of a lottery ticket is worth it for a player that I at least enjoy watching?
-
dmarx114
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 25482
- Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
The money is a sunk cost and he is blocking a younger option.Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑December 15 25, 12:35 pmIf the Cardinals are going to have to eat money to trade Contreras, then...why not just keep him? How low-chance of a lottery ticket is worth it for a player that I at least enjoy watching?
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
I don't know that they'd need to eat money to trade him. It's just that the return would be minimal and he'd have to approve the trade (players also usually get a sweetener for approving a trade).
The reason he said eat half the money is to fit the books of those teams. If someone wants to give a top-50 prospect for him, then you'd consider eating more money.
Most likely it's a nice flyer prospect and they eat 25% of the money.
The reason he said eat half the money is to fit the books of those teams. If someone wants to give a top-50 prospect for him, then you'd consider eating more money.
Most likely it's a nice flyer prospect and they eat 25% of the money.
-
jagtrader
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12659
- Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
It’s ok if not every position is filled with pre-arbitration players. The world won’t end despite what ownership and Miklasz are trying to claim.
- CardsofSTL
- All Hail the GDT Master
- Posts: 70085
- Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
- Location: Columbus, OH
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
Who is he blocking?dmarx114 wrote: ↑December 15 25, 1:26 pmThe money is a sunk cost and he is blocking a younger option.Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑December 15 25, 12:35 pmIf the Cardinals are going to have to eat money to trade Contreras, then...why not just keep him? How low-chance of a lottery ticket is worth it for a player that I at least enjoy watching?
- Fan_In_NY
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5410
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:22 pm
- Location: Birthplace of Baseball- Hoboken, NJ
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
Burleson. Which would then either let an interesting bat first player stuck somewhere to fit into the roster/lineup or Herrera to play DH or 1B with Burleson. But essentially the Cards do not see themselves being competitive during the time that they have Contereras under contract. So if they can get assets that do fit the timeline better they would see that as a move in the right direction. I do caution that if you constantly wait for a window you may never have one...but we need to see if this player development program works out to see if it is a possible avenue to long term success or just a way to cut salaries significantly.CardsofSTL wrote: ↑December 15 25, 8:44 pmWho is he blocking?dmarx114 wrote: ↑December 15 25, 1:26 pmThe money is a sunk cost and he is blocking a younger option.Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑December 15 25, 12:35 pmIf the Cardinals are going to have to eat money to trade Contreras, then...why not just keep him? How low-chance of a lottery ticket is worth it for a player that I at least enjoy watching?
- CardsofSTL
- All Hail the GDT Master
- Posts: 70085
- Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
- Location: Columbus, OH
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
I don't agree that he's blocking Burleson. There's enough at bats there for them both.Fan_In_NY wrote: ↑December 15 25, 10:12 pmBurleson. Which would then either let an interesting bat first player stuck somewhere to fit into the roster/lineup or Herrera to play DH or 1B with Burleson. But essentially the Cards do not see themselves being competitive during the time that they have Contereras under contract. So if they can get assets that do fit the timeline better they would see that as a move in the right direction. I do caution that if you constantly wait for a window you may never have one...but we need to see if this player development program works out to see if it is a possible avenue to long term success or just a way to cut salaries significantly.CardsofSTL wrote: ↑December 15 25, 8:44 pmWho is he blocking?dmarx114 wrote: ↑December 15 25, 1:26 pmThe money is a sunk cost and he is blocking a younger option.Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑December 15 25, 12:35 pmIf the Cardinals are going to have to eat money to trade Contreras, then...why not just keep him? How low-chance of a lottery ticket is worth it for a player that I at least enjoy watching?
By all means trade Contreras if there's a good offer but it seems like they're doing it to save 10~ million.
-
jagtrader
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12659
- Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
Contreras isn't blocking anyone. It's another cut payroll fairy tale some fans seem to buy into.
- Famous Mortimer
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3961
- Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
- Location: Cherokee
Re: Anthony Franco's NL Central comments
If Burleson is a better hitter than Contreras, it's by the slimmest of margins (2 points of OPS+ last year) so I just don't buy that there's any blocking going on.
I get that we all want the future where the Cardinals are challenging again to come quicker, but if they're eating money to get more than the lotteriest of lottery tickets for Contreras, I just don't see the point. If they want me to go to the ballpark next year, then it'd be nice to have some players I like watching on the team.
I get that we all want the future where the Cardinals are challenging again to come quicker, but if they're eating money to get more than the lotteriest of lottery tickets for Contreras, I just don't see the point. If they want me to go to the ballpark next year, then it'd be nice to have some players I like watching on the team.

