MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43331
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Post by heyzeus »

st.lewis11 wrote: ↑
December 7 25, 7:59 pm
Looking at numbers in Baseball Reference, it sure seems that Edmonds is more qualified for the HOF than Kent is.
He is.

So is Lou Whitaker.

jagtrader
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12659
Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Post by jagtrader »

The Don Mattingly propaganda from the media types who considered him their favorite player growing up is really something. He's been on a ballot of some kind 17 times now. Maybe we can look at someone else.

User avatar
st.lewis11
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 15773
Joined: June 14 06, 10:17 pm
Location: Small southern IL town, 40 min from STL

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Post by st.lewis11 »

I know Valenzuela's career wasn't really HOF worthy under the unwritten standards set by them, but I lived in SoCal at the time when witnessing Fernandomania took off. His run over those years was so amazing. Before then, most of Mexican-Americans hated the Dodgers (research Chavez Ravine history), but that Fernando's era brought their culture & new group of fans into game.

Sometimes I wonder if the HOF's emphasize too much over the stuff like longevity and counting numbers. I feel like "impact" sometimes isn't rewarded enough. I think maybe guys like Fernando, Tommy John, Curt Flood should get more consideration. After all, it's Hall of Fame, not Hall of Very Elite Players.

User avatar
Joe Shlabotnik
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 24291
Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
Contact:

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Post by Joe Shlabotnik »

st.lewis11 wrote: ↑
December 8 25, 10:00 am
I know Valenzuela's career wasn't really HOF worthy under the unwritten standards set by them, but I lived in SoCal at the time when witnessing Fernandomania took off. His run over those years was so amazing. Before then, most of Mexican-Americans hated the Dodgers (research Chavez Ravine history), but that Fernando's era brought their culture & new group of fans into game.

Sometimes I wonder if the HOF's emphasize too much over the stuff like longevity and counting numbers. I feel like "impact" sometimes isn't rewarded enough. I think maybe guys like Fernando, Tommy John, Curt Flood should get more consideration. After all, it's Hall of Fame, not Hall of Very Elite Players.
Agreed.

User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Post by Famous Mortimer »

st.lewis11 wrote: ↑
December 8 25, 10:00 am
Sometimes I wonder if the HOF's emphasize too much over the stuff like longevity and counting numbers. I feel like "impact" sometimes isn't rewarded enough. I think maybe guys like Fernando, Tommy John, Curt Flood should get more consideration. After all, it's Hall of Fame, not Hall of Very Elite Players.
I tend to agree, but I'm okay with some element of logevity being important. Those shorter peaks are why teams have their own Halls of Fame, maybe.

Much like a broken record, I say this every time it's brought up, but there are a ton of cheats and some genuinely awful people in the Hall of Fame. Seems weird that this is the unbreakable line in the sand. Well, it's because they lied to the writers.

If Bud Selig is in, then so should every Hall-worthy player who juiced. Embarrassing faux-moralistic waste of space.

jagtrader
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12659
Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Post by jagtrader »

I'd love to see the rabbit holes people would go down trying to quantify "impact."

User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: MLB Hall of Fame 2026

Post by Famous Mortimer »

Also, I think Curt Flood should be in because his impact on the game is vastly more positive than every commish. Plus, he was a great player.

By the way, any of you who are in St Louis and want the book "The Cooperstown Casebook", send me a message and I'll meet you with it somewhere.

Post Reply