Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on November 9.

A good amount of questions this week, and 3 bonus questions: one about the first offseason activity, one about watches and one about the upcoming HoF vote. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/11/ ... at-85.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would Tucker or Bellinger be a bigger priority for the Yankees?

Mark Polishuk
I actually think Bellinger’s a better fit for the Yankees’ particular needs since he can play 1B and CF. Plus, he’s less expensive than Tucker will be, and the Yankees already know Bellinger can handle playing in the Bronx.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any chance the Cubs go after Murakami to play 3rd?

Mark Polishuk
Sure, I think there’s a possible fit there.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Cards trade Donavan? Could Brendan Donovan bring back a mid-rotation pre-arb starter or MLB-ready mid rotation?

Mark Polishuk
Donovan appeals to so many teams that I think his price tag will be a bit higher than some expect. He’s under team control for two years, so the Cardinals can hold out to see if they can land a more controllable type of pitcher.

They could wait until the deadline if the right offers aren’t there this winter, but there’s no reason for a rebuilding team to hang onto Donovan too much longer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How about the Giants trading for Brendon Donovan and Sonny Gray? They could take on all of the Gray’s contract and give up less prospects for Donovan. They need pitching and second base!

Mark Polishuk
Gray’s tax number is so outsized that the Cardinals probably can’t close the door on a scenario like this. But, moving one of their better trade chips just to save money isn’t a great look for a team that surely wants to bring in all the young talent they can.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who says no: Kurtz for Burns?

Mark Polishuk
Athletics
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Reds, a budding young team with a ton of potential in a very winnable division, are, again, playing it conservative on payroll (flat to last year). How much do you think the potential lock out in 2027 is going to play into contract signings this offseason?

Mark Polishuk
It’ll be a big factor, no doubt. Not that the Reds were too likely to break the bank on a big signing anyway, but some teams will surely be holding back on the spending in the hope that the next CBA will change the rules to some extent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could the Pirates make trade like last year Ortiz/Horwitz to acquire a hitter?

Mark Polishuk
They should make at least two trades like this to give their offense a proper shot in the arm.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is KC making the same mistake the Cards did with Yadi giving Salvy legacy contracts in his declining years!

Mark Polishuk
“Mistake” is a bit of a stretch. Perez is still hitting lots of homers and is a major clubhouse voice, even if his overall offense is inconsistent and his defensive metrics have plummeted. If they let Perez go, the Royals would then be putting more pressure on Mitchell and Jensen to step into a regular catching role right now.

I don’t think it hurts KC to retain a guy who’s still a useful player and a franchise icon. The two-year length of the contract probably acts as the unofficial end date of Perez’s career, too.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If they actually trade Hunter Greene, I rage quit forever.

Mark Polishuk
I kinda doubt they’ll move him, of all pitchers, since Greene has shown he can be a frontline guy.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Should Woodruff take the QO from the Brewers?

Mark Polishuk
If I’m Woodruff’s agent, I advise him to reject, since he can comfortably top one year/$22.025MM on the open market.

But that ignores the possible emotional attachment between Woodruff and the Brewers. Not to mention that there’s enough injury uncertainty around Woodruff that while he’d top the QO price, it might not be that all that much. Chances are he rejects it, but I wouldn’t be totally shocked to see Woodruff accept.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see Toronto as a potential landing spot for Tucker, especially if Bichette departs, or do you think they focus their resources on other areas?

Mark Polishuk
If Tucker is signed and Bichette leaves, that makes the OF Tucker/Varsho/Santander or Springer on an everyday basis (with Straw occasionally spelling Varsho against some lefties). That also makes Gimenez/Barger/Clement/Schneider toggling between the three non-1B infield spots, and Lukes becomes a full-time backup.
So it kinda still works, but if Bichette did leave, Toronto might prefer to bring in another starting infielder to leave themselves more outfield flexibility.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What happens first a big free agent signing or a big trade?

Mark Polishuk
Trade. I guess it’s a matter of what you’d consider a “big” signing or trade, but most of the top free agents will wait a while to gauge their offers. A larger trade could technically happen at any time.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
A serious question: Why do managers wear watches in the dugout?

Mark Polishuk
So they can theatrically toss the watch on the ground, then yell “hey ump, even a broken clock is right twice a day, and that’s still better than you!”

Real answer: I dunno, they just like wearing watches?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Anyone getting in the Hall out of this group of eight?

Mark Polishuk
It’ll ultimately depend on who is on the committee, since if it happens to be a lot of players/writers/execs sympathetic to a particular player, their chances will be greatly boosted. For instance, if there’s an Atlanta-centric focus to the panel, Dale Murphy’s chances look a lot better.

I find it hard to believe that Bonds and Clemens will draw enough support for induction since their last appearance on the ballot fell so flat. Maybe I’m a little biased as a Blue Jays fan, but perhaps Delgado’s candidacy will be helped by how his stats measure so favorably against most of the other candidates.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Post Reply